Supercell we need online/offline indicators

ONLINE & OFFLINE INDICATORS
ASAP PLEASE

Supercell please make these changes effective asap. Im sure others share the same idea but has yet to speak out about it. As the leader in my clan "GUARDS OF WAR" I often log on and speak in open chat but only to find myself talking to myself at times. this is very annoying at times. Please supercell create a icon that will appear to a members name to indicate weather they are online or not.
Thanks for your time supercell

-King Johnson (LEADER)
Guards of War

This idea is ruled out

Please read the ​sticky

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hesto25

This idea is ruled out

Please read the ​sticky

---

Just because its ruled out on someone else post does not mean we cant continue to try for it.

Thanks

Not to spam or anything, but can someone explain the reason in simple terms for why this has been ruled out?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KingJohnson

Just because its ruled out on someone else post does not mean we cant continue to try for it.

Thanks

---

Quote from the sticky thread:
"Posting these ideas will result in your thread being removed without notice!"

Translated: "Don't post ruled out ideas!"

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KingJohnson

Just because its ruled out on someone else post does not mean we cant continue to try for it.

Thanks

---

Actually thats exactly what it means as ruled out ideas just get deleted. This is just a privacy issue, youre reasoning for wanting this is basically "I'm online and want to see who else is online but not talking because they dont want to be bothered at the moment"

I don't care about online offline, but what i do care about is being able to revenge right away and if they always have shield then they often get away with massive raids, that shouldnt be right, so revenge as i see it should kick an online player offline while the revenge attacker has his attack, boom beach does it if you try and stay online, it lets you get attacked, its not revenge obviously but still it kicks you out of the game, and revenge often just gets ignored cos you dont get the loot bonus so it should be easier to have the revenge to make the game more open, chances are they would have spent the loot pretty quick anyway.

I don't always want people to know when I am on.... Sometimes I'm just collecting loot or getting a feel for how the cos and elders do things when I'm not there.... All sorts of reasons I don't want want to be tracked by others.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ectar

I don't care about online offline, but what i do care about is being able to revenge right away and if they always have shield then they often get away with massive raids, that shouldnt be right, so revenge as i see it should kick an online player offline while the revenge attacker has his attack, boom beach does it if you try and stay online, it lets you get attacked, its not revenge obviously but still it kicks you out of the game, and revenge often just gets ignored cos you dont get the loot bonus so it should be easier to have the revenge to make the game more open, chances are they would have spent the loot pretty quick anyway.

---

Wow. You know that's two sided right?

How would you like to get kicked out of the game while you're raiding?

How about this: The kicked defender gets to use his army to defend. And his spells. And if his heroes died, he could place one new one anywhere on the map. And activate its ability. Not only that, but the defender should get to move his buildings around and rearm traps. Finally, the defender should have access to the "Surrender" button in case he/she gets too tired.
Rant over.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KingJohnson

Just because its ruled out on someone else post does not mean we cant continue to try for it.

Thanks

---

OMG that's too funny.

It is not ruled out on someone else's post. its ruled out by SC themselves. That guy was simply telling you, he was not deciding anything himself.

Make all the noise about this you want. SC has already said they were not doing it and why. (Because they consider it a privacy concern)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hesto25

Wow. You know that's two sided right?

How would you like to get kicked out of the game while you're raiding?

How about this: The kicked defender gets to use his army to defend. And his spells. And if his heroes died, he could place one new one anywhere on the map. And activate its ability. Not only that, but the defender should get to move his buildings around and rearm traps. Finally, the defender should have access to the "Surrender" button in case he/she gets too tired.
Rant over.

---

well if you were raiding i think you could carry on with the attack as you are not in the home screen, you could finish the attack and then if you are still being raided you could be watching the attack as it happens, that is already a feature, i just think revenge is not used unless someone really riles you up, but you still have to check when they are attackable, and you have to have troops ready for the revenge, its just frustrating, and many times i ignore attacks on me cos i know its not worth my time to revenge, and if its nor worth the attack why would you bother? it needs more of an incentive like a revenge bonus, like you win the loot back that you lost as well if you three star them, or a percentage of the loot if you one star, they dont even need to kick you out of game really, why dont you have your warbase as the revenge base? so you can get revenged while online without it effecting your online play?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by THNSUM

I don't always want people to know when I am on.... Sometimes I'm just collecting loot or getting a feel for how the cos and elders do things when I'm not there.... All sorts of reasons I don't want want to be tracked by others.

---

I agree with this^^^

Privacy issue is overblown. A simple invisible mode, with invis being a default when someone logs on, would resolve it for the most part

Hey man just think a little bit, I want to play clash of clans and I don't want my girlfriend who has an account to watch my online!!!

Just kidding but I heard or read once that supercell ruled out because of privacy or something like that...