[Suggestion] You don't loose your troops...and more

I'm new at Clash of Clans (I have a long experience in this kind of online games) but I've already found out some points that make no sense to me.
1) After an attack why do I loose all my troops even if they didn't die in battle???
It's silly and expensive!
2) Why can't my troops defend my village???
Are they invisible or what?
3) Why can I give resourses to another gamer??? There's no way we can be a true clan helping each other only with troops!
4) Why buying gems is so damn expensive???
5€ ONLY FOR 500 GEMS???
Are you kidding me???
That's a robbery!

I hope you can answer or solve some of this non-sense!
Thanks for your attention!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fedemart86

I'm new at Clash of Clans (I have a long experience in this kind of online games) but I've already found out some points that make no sense to me.
1) After an attack why do I loose all my troops even if they didn't die in battle???
It's silly and expensive!
2) Why can't my troops defend my village???
Are they invisible or what?
3) Why can I give resourses to another gamer??? There's no way we can be a true clan helping each other only with troops!
4) Why buying gems is so damn expensive???
5€ ONLY FOR 500 GEMS???
Are you kidding me???
That's a robbery!

I hope you can answer or solve some of this non-sense!
Thanks for your attention!

---

1) Its only the honorable thing to die in battle :smirk: This would be way too over powered since the game already allows you to attack lower. Imagine non stop picking on the little guys because theyre not strong enough to kill the big guys troops

2) This is how the game works and is balanced this way. No one would be winning attacks if they had to deal with 200+ spaces worth of troops

3) This would be very easy to exploit as it is in other games. Make some new accounts give resources, never have to buy gems because some big guy that doesnt need resources is just giving them out

4) It's actually really cheap compared to many other games for how much 500 gems can get you if you use them smart.

5) All the above ideas have already been ruled out or previously mentioned many many many times :facepalm:
please do read through the stickies before suggesting your next idea! :thumbsup:

1. the reason you lose all of your troops if you use them ( even if not all of them die) is to punish you for blindly dumping all of your units instead of actually planning out your attack. so you have to choose between using all of your troops and guaranteeing the win or planning a precise attack that uses the least resources but still gets the same results.

2. i do not know what to tell you other than that's just how they decided to do it. the game is set around attacking with troops and defending with buildings and clan units. they wanted to make the game interactive with other players so you have to participate in a clan to better defend your base with units

3. if they made it to where you can donate resources then people would just use multiple accounts to feed resources to one base

4. game is pay to win man. if you want to drop some $$$ to bypass all of the waiting then you have to empty your wallet. no one forces you to buy gems.

also i think it is wrong of you to refer to these things as nonsense. the first 3 complaints just sound like a little kid who is mad that the game does not work the way you want it to which is very childish. all three of these complaints could have been answered yourself if you had just put some actual thought into why things are the way they are. your fourth complaint is the most irrelevant because gems are not even a necessary part of the game. you can play the game i full, all the way to the end, without ever buying any gems. getting mad because you can not buy thousands of gems for like 3 bucks is again very childish.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fedemart86

I'm new at Clash of Clans (I have a long experience in this kind of online games) but I've already found out some points that make no sense to me.
1) After an attack why do I loose all my troops even if they didn't die in battle???
It's silly and expensive!

Over killing is the greatest sin of all and you pay for it with the loss of your troops. It is not silly the cost to attack is your troops and small match finder fee it is both fair and balanced.

2) Why can't my troops defend my village???
Are they invisible or what?

This would be way too overpowering you would never git to destroying the base, that is why you have clan castle troops instead to defend.

3) Why can I give resourses to another gamer??? There's no way we can be a true clan helping each other only with troops!

This has been requested countless times, it is a cop out of the game and very exploitable both for top level players and lower levels.

4) Why buying gems is so damn expensive???
5€ ONLY FOR 500 GEMS???
Are you kidding me???
That's a robbery!

This is how supercell make their money, it is your choice whether to buy gems or not, but if you do the sack of gems is actually the most cost effective purchase.

I hope you can answer or solve some of this non-sense!
Thanks for your attention!

---

answers are in red

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fedemart86

I'm new at Clash of Clans (I have a long experience in this kind of online games) but I've already found out some points that make no sense to me.
1) After an attack why do I loose all my troops even if they didn't die in battle???
It's silly and expensive!
This is life. You invest money, you might not get the money they didnt use back....
2) Why can't my troops defend my village???
Are they invisible or what?
yes, they are... How did you know? They turn invisible in fright when they see opponent players searching for a place to attack
3) Why can I give resourses to another gamer??? There's no way we can be a true clan helping each other only with troops!
http://i.imgur.com/98PtmjK.png
Please also take time to thoroughly read Dahimi's forum posting guide (http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-posting-guide) and the explanations to the ruled out stickie guide (http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...uled-out-ideas)
becuase I would get 49 free accounts and get free resources "donated" to my main account.

4) Why buying gems is so damn expensive???
5€ ONLY FOR 500 GEMS???
take it or leave it. Don't you know that everything you buy is overpriced? Since eveything is overpriced, overpricing seems normal.
Are you kidding me???
That's a robbery!

I hope you can answer or solve some of this non-sense!
Thanks for your attention!

---

I think you are being illogical...
You think the game is illogical...
here is what would happen if Clash was logical...

If Clash was logical....

• Archer Queen wouldn't stop shooting at walls when unneccessary.
• Troops that don't die would come back
• there would be trekking time to go to the next village (maybe a month)
• you would need some type of container to take resources back.
• many defences would still work while upgrading (painting wizard tower shouldn't stop wizard from shooting fire at troops.)
• Buildings need to be repaired
• more buildings like moats, spikes, seige towers would be possible.
• natural disasters can occur occasionally and destroy everything
• buildings cannot be rearranged because they need their foundations to move.
• balloons and archers would run out of ammo
• At least one troop has to survive to bring the resources back
• the more troops left, the shorter the trekking time back.
• enemy cc troops could attack said container to get the resources back
• shooting at a elixir or dark elixir storage would make all the elixr and dark elixir spill into the ground if not caught properly
• troops would take at least 20 years to train
• you would have to have farms and such to feed your villagers.
• once you have been raided, it might take months to repair everything.
• shields wouldn't exist
• Troops would be smart and avoid the areas where they could die from archer towers, etc.
• Gem boxes wouldn't exist
• trees and bushes would take decades to grow
• Global wouldn't be possible
• spells would require a troop to go in and place it (potentially dying)
• upgraded pumps and mines will drain the resources
• walls would have gates to accommodate for people moving around.
• eventually there will be no resources and we will have to resort to buying resources with gems
• spells would be coloured according to their spell factory colour
• heroes wouldn't need to be hammered to get upgraded
• heroes would just have to drink d. Elixir and get upgraded instantaneously
• builders would have to have different materials not just a magic hammer
• spells dropped like they are now who hit people on the head.
• villagers wouldn't run to the town hall when it is being attacked.
• villagers wouldn't disappear when town hall is destroyed
• mortars and other splash defences would hurt the defending troops and heroes too.
• projectiles that pass thought things (like cannonballs through walls) should stop at the first obstacle and damage that
• you need to train some sort of person to operate the autonomous defences
• if enemy kills the operator or the archer on the tower, the thing is useless.
• it would be impossible to have green grass after a raid until you water me.
• grass would need watering
• people would have different terrains in their base layout.
• goblins wouldn't exist
• giants of that size and immunity wouldn't exist
• skeletons running around with bombs wouldn't exist
• skeletons flying around with bombs wouldn't exist
• large healing angels wouldn't exist
• fire-breathing European flying dragons wouldn't exist
• robot samurai knight things wouldn't exist
• dark flying little creatures wouldn't exist
• hog riding hammer wielding men wouldn't exist
• animated piles of rock wouldn't exist
• undead women summoning animated skeletons wouldn't exist
• fiery flying dogs wouldn't exist.
• flying troops (except balloons) could go to the ground and avoid air defences when the time is right.
• the wizards on top of wizard towers would shout "you shall not pass"
• Normal wizards would shout "Storm and Fire heed my call"
• Barbarians would scream war cries
• Archers would aim for the head and 1HKO many troops.
• Giants would receive damage an be reluctant to attack spiked walls
• Witches would scream "you will be my minions in the end"
• When "You" touches the army camp with a hogrider, the hogrider would scream "Did someone say hogrider?"
• Heroes would be much more OP
• Walls would be much higher to prevent jumping (defence troops can't jump)
• Teslas and lvl 11 walls wouldn't work, because at the time period clash is in, electricity hadntbeen harnessed.
• loot penalty wouldn't exist
• troops would be able to leap over walls at all times like they can when defending
• defending troops wouldn't be able to jump that much (unless hog rider) (yea, just contradicted myself)
• civilians wouldn't be divided by gender (boys live in huts, girls live in the town hall)
• there would be pets everywhere
• farm animals would exist
• fully trained army wouldn't run off when the base is being attacked
• "You" would have an avatar that walks around giving orders.
• Troops can only be deployed from the forest around a base.
• Only toops close to "You" would get orders to do something.
• If "you" gets killed, the game blacks out and you have to restart.
• villagers who are unhappy with "You"'s rule might revolt and overthrow "You"
• Clash would be a horrible game

*Logic and CoC don't go well together, that is my point.*
disclaimer: I do not advocate any ideas on the list above. (well, maybe some). But you should not infer I support all of them. Infact, I might die if they were added.

Im being rather mean to you and I'm sorry, but in all honesty this is one of the worst posts I've seen. You're just ranting and angry that you don't want to spend gems. If you don't want to spend gems, then just don't. No need to rant about how overpriced it is. Many other of your ideas I would have kindly told you why it doesn't work and explain eveything, but the tone of the voice tells me to just stick a ruled out sticker on this thread.

Im sorry for the severity in which I criticsed your ideas, but they have been considered to not be implemented. Please read the stickies and be less angry if you are "suggesting" and not ranting.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fedemart86

I'm new at Clash of Clans (I have a long experience in this kind of online games) but I've already found out some points that make no sense to me.
1) After an attack why do I loose all my troops even if they didn't die in battle???
It's silly and expensive!
2) Why can't my troops defend my village???
Are they invisible or what?
3) Why can I give resourses to another gamer??? There's no way we can be a true clan helping each other only with troops!
4) Why buying gems is so damn expensive???
5€ ONLY FOR 500 GEMS???
Are you kidding me???
That's a robbery!

I hope you can answer or solve some of this non-sense!
Thanks for your attention!

---

You have obviously not thought any of this through. First, if you are new to the game, play the game for a while and read the forums before posting threads like this one. It will save you the embarrassment and humiliation of everyone pointing out why you are wrong. Now, for why the game is not how you want it:
1. If I made 10 pekkas that don't die after battle, I would ravage through every low town hall non-stop. That army would last a long time.
2. It would cost you more money to do that every time. can you stop 10 dragons with 200 barbarians?
3. We are all capable of generating resources. If I can give resources, I would pile my other accounts onto just one account.
4. Supply and demand. You'll learn that in Economics when you get in high school.

This should be in the General section. This is neither an idea or a helpful suggestion. Just a rant.