No Loot Penelty On Collectors

As the title says, I don't think there should be a loot penelty on mines, pumps, and drills. It's really annonying when I find an inactive town hall 6 (I'm a town hall 8), who has level 9 or 10 mines and pumps. It still has an alright amount of loot available, but its only 50% of what I would get as a town hall 6. (Still keep the only 50% available on mines and pumps). I would be able to get the loot as a town hall 5, so you can imagine how frustrating it is. This would affect nobody but inactive players at a lower town hall level, so it wouldn't hurt us at all. It would still protect the loot in your storages, but not the collecters. I feel like I'm just repeating what I've said the past couple minutes, so I'll end the thread here. Thoughts anyone?

I do not see a reason to disagree so why not?

Bumpity Bump Bump Bump

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FishFishFish

This would affect nobody but inactive players at a lower town hall level, so it wouldn't hurt us at all.

---

This would affect the lower THs' ability to farming on collectors. If there's no penalty, you'll take more and leave less for those guys. Plus, it'd cause TH9-10 to also drop trophies and farm the inactive TH6s that you speak of. It's much easier and faster to barch collectors than break into storages

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sirix

This would affect the lower THs' ability to farming on collectors. If there's no penalty, you'll take more and leave less for those guys. Plus, it'd cause TH9-10 to also drop trophies and farm the inactive TH6s that you speak of. It's much easier and faster to barch collectors than break into storages

---

How is that different from now?

also in theroy it should not be worth it, since lower people have lower level and lower count of collectors making it not worthwhile to do vs real attacks. I guess it might show more people that are lazy though...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MomoZB

How is that different from now?

also in theroy it should not be worth it, since lower people have lower level and lower count of collectors making it not worthwhile to do vs real attacks. I guess it might show more people that are lazy though...

---

As OP stated, TH8 don't find it very profitable to hunt TH6s. If this idea is implemented, you and TH9-10s will find it profitable to hunt TH6, unlike the current situation where the TH10 get practically nothing from TH6

Besides, farming TH6 collectors is still decent since it's max collector level is only 2 level less than TH8's max collectors. With 12 hours of shield, an inactive TH6 base can give 2.5k * 12 * 6 / 50% = 90k gold/elixir and it'd probably take roughly 50 barb/archers to get all of that, unless it's hidden behind walls. That takes less than 5 minutes to make. 90k * 12 times per hour = 1.08m per hour which is great for a low skilled type of raiding on a TH6. A TH10 would find it much easier to pick on TH6-8s than TH9-10

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sirix

As OP stated, TH8 don't find it very profitable to hunt TH6s. If this idea is implemented, you and TH9-10s will find it profitable to hunt TH6, unlike the current situation where the TH10 get practically nothing from TH6

Besides, farming TH6 collectors is still decent since it's max collector level is only 2 level less than TH8's max collectors. With 12 hours of shield, an inactive TH6 base can give 2.5k * 12 * 6 / 50% = 90k gold/elixir and it'd probably take roughly 50 barb/archers to get all of that, unless it's hidden behind walls. That takes less than 5 minutes to make. 90k * 12 times per hour = 1.08m per hour which is great for a low skilled type of raiding on a TH6. A TH10 would find it much easier to pick on TH6-8s than TH9-10

---

well... I can see a problem if too many went low to find those inactive bases but if everyone is farming them then it would encourage people to move up again since it takes too much time to find them to begin with? Your 1 mil /hr does not factor in the time to find them to begin with.

Plus if people flood the low ranks taking a ton of time to find them, what about the next fee for th 9/10? that ♥♥♥♥ adds up fast if your hitting next for 20-30 mins, I spent 400000 gold before because I kept finding 2000-100000 gold elxier bases with nonexistent DE (infact that is what made me go inactive as a th8, was so mad)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MomoZB

well... I can see a problem if too many went low to find those inactive bases but if everyone is farming them then it would encourage people to move up again since it takes too much time to find them to begin with?

---

Putting low level bases under shield is very easy. Based on how SC says inactives are pushed back in the queue, a huge number of people farming at low trophies and people under shields would increase those inactive bases (with more than the minimum 12 hours of collecting) to appear. Plus in sub 200, you'd get hit in less than 5 seconds when you're offline which suggests that there are a lot of people down there relative to the number of bases. However they don't have problems with farming since I see many TH8 with nearly maxed storages

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MomoZB

Your 1 mil /hr does not factor in the time to find them to begin with. Plus if people flood the low ranks taking a ton of time to find them, what about the next fee for th 9/10? that ♥♥♥♥ adds up fast if your hitting next for 20-30 mins, I spent 400000 gold before because I kept finding 2000-100000 gold elxier bases with nonexistent DE (infact that is what made me go inactive as a th8, was so mad)

---

It didn't but when you only need 50 troops, you can start searching sooner while the other 150 troop trains. You can even use a couple of archers to snipe collectors or TH that defense towers aren't protecting to get a bit of gold to cover your next cost unlike at higher leagues where it's not worth attacking most bases

as though people needed more encouragement to go barching...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sirix

This would affect the lower THs' ability to farming on collectors. If there's no penalty, you'll take more and leave less for those guys. Plus, it'd cause TH9-10 to also drop trophies and farm the inactive TH6s that you speak of. It's much easier and faster to barch collectors than break into storages

---

That's what most people do now. If they were to take loot penalties from collectors it would just add more loot to the economy. plus if the base is inactive and the collectors are full what's the point they'll be doing the same anyway