War Troop Donations should count!

Members who donate troops are loyal and dedicated. Clan leaders often reward members based on troop donations. Hundreds of or very costly troops are donated for war. These donations should be valued, and therefore counted as donated troops in the clan list. PLEASE!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leanneg

Members who donate troops are loyal and dedicated. Clan leaders often reward members based on troop donations. Hundreds of or very costly troops are donated for war. These donations should be valued, and therefore counted as donated troops in the clan list. PLEASE!!!

---

I heard an explanation as to why it doesn't count from SuperCell once. And although at first I agreed with you, the explanation they gave for why it doesn't count actually made a decent deal of sense to me. I forget the exact explanation, but something to do with people donating then having them deleted out of the castle.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bonesaw13

I heard an explanation as to why it doesn't count from SuperCell once. And although at first I agreed with you, the explanation they gave for why it doesn't count actually made a decent deal of sense to me. I forget the exact explanation, but something to do with people donating then having them deleted out of the castle.

---

Thanks for the reply. I guess I would need to read their explanation. I would say that "so what?", the currency(troops) was still paid. I don't donate tons to random troop sucking clan mates, but come wartime, I give u til it really hurts. War troops are given in anonymity....that sucks! I hope Supercell reconsiders.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leanneg

Thanks for the reply. I guess I would need to read their explanation. I would say that "so what?", the currency(troops) was still paid. I don't donate tons to random troop sucking clan mates, but come wartime, I give u til it really hurts. War troops are given in anonymity....that sucks! I hope Supercell reconsiders.

---

Yeah I wish I could remember their exact explanation or had the link to the post.. Maybe search the forums? Because I know your not the first person to bring it up.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leanneg

Members who donate troops are loyal and dedicated. Clan leaders often reward members based on troop donations. Hundreds of or very costly troops are donated for war. These donations should be valued, and therefore counted as donated troops in the clan list. PLEASE!!!

---

I totally agree with you. It's making some members reluctant to donate troops.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bonesaw13

I heard an explanation as to why it doesn't count from SuperCell once. And although at first I agreed with you, the explanation they gave for why it doesn't count actually made a decent deal of sense to me. I forget the exact explanation, but something to do with people donating then having them deleted out of the castle.

---

I will definitely look for that explanation. But isn't troops donated to village cc can also be removed.

YES! come war time, I have many times been the guy donating over half of the troops to fill war ccs. Since my clan does back to back wars, have thousands of donates in war. I think i should get xp, Friend in need, and the refund from clan levels. The argument about troops being x'ed out from war castles is invalid.. the same thing can be done in normal ccs. There is no reason for supercell to keep this out of the game.

How about if xp and FiN stats were updated at the end of prep day, just counting the troops that stayed in the castles?

this is ruled out.....because this feature can be exploited easily...........what if one player donates to a war cc...and with the coordination of the other player...he deletes the donated troops...and the first players donates again...and repeats.....so now doest it makes sense? ..

There are already some exploitable XP gain features, but thankfully many of those are very slow, but hard to stop. Adding that in would be an easy and speedy exploit, burning a marginal amount of Elixir for XP, limited only by how fast you can make barbarians, your Elixir storages, and willingness to keep grinding.

If this was added, two conspiring exploiters could grind XP out in a record amount of time, especially if Barracks are boosted (and would be even worse if it was done during the Barbarian and Dragon Event awhile back! http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...t%21%21Boosted Event boosted barbarians, with boosted Barracks? 1 second training!)