Hi there for supercell please read can u make this in the next update

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

Clans still have an issue with people donating the wrong thing, just to get thier points up. Just remember, this is a double edged sword, it could very likely increase donations, but could get you a lot of ♥♥♥♥ and badly filled requests as well.

This is just from experience. It may actually work, but I really doubt it, given what I've seen with just a moderate push to donating.

What really is needed is some donation managing system with profiles. Each player can put up what they are willing to give, and what they are usually willing to accept, and allow others to see what the supply and demand is in the clan. The one sticking point low level members have is 'are my troops good enough?', and that could be answered by a quick glance over the list of common demands. It also helps with what to level up next, as it gives another bit of info on if something is worth putting research towards. Plus there are other benefits, but don't want to get too off topic.

---

Hmmm, I am going to have to agree with the points at the top of this.

As far as the suggestion at the bottom I have some concerns but lets see....

Would the specific for what guys to accept be mandatory or just for the donator to be so advised. And example would be a guys says "Can I get some wiz" and someone responds "I have a drag and a pekka made right now that you are welcome to but no wiz at the moment". In a case like that, if the requester feels like that is fine (and says so) there should not need to be a lot of gyrations (I.E. let request time out, change preference, re-ask) to give the agreed alternative.

So I do like the idea of being able to make it more clear to what you need to get, and do feel that people should respect that, but in agreed situations I think there should be some wiggle room. I am open to how that got carried out.

As far as lower players that is always a problem. We let our lower guys donate between wars and they understand to never do it (no one with less than max) during war. I myself have the 35 spaces and when farming will request nothing higher than a certain level just so that the low guys get their chance. I think the only fix is for the higher guys in the clan to work that way to help their lower guys develop.

Sorry your ideas get pushed down so much. I do try to call guys out on spamming practices and reduce the traffic. But yeah, it does still happen a lot.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

Clans still have an issue with people donating the wrong thing, just to get thier points up. Just remember, this is a double edged sword, it could very likely increase donations, but could get you a lot of ♥♥♥♥ and badly filled requests as well.

This is just from experience. It may actually work, but I really doubt it, given what I've seen with just a moderate push to donating.

What really is needed is some donation managing system with profiles. Each player can put up what they are willing to give, and what they are usually willing to accept, and allow others to see what the supply and demand is in the clan. The one sticking point low level members have is 'are my troops good enough?', and that could be answered by a quick glance over the list of common demands. It also helps with what to level up next, as it gives another bit of info on if something is worth putting research towards. Plus there are other benefits, but don't want to get too off topic.

---

How about this then with the ranking system make it where they can only donate what is asked for if they say level three dragon then they cant donate anything but a level three dragon if they say anything they can donate anything

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

Hmmm, I am going to have to agree with the points at the top of this.

As far as the suggestion at the bottom I have some concerns but lets see....

Would the specific for what guys to accept be mandatory or just for the donator to be so advised. And example would be a guys says "Can I get some wiz" and someone responds "I have a drag and a pekka made right now that you are welcome to but no wiz at the moment". In a case like that, if the requester feels like that is fine (and says so) there should not need to be a lot of gyrations (I.E. let request time out, change preference, re-ask) to give the agreed alternative.

So I do like the idea of being able to make it more clear to what you need to get, and do feel that people should respect that, but in agreed situations I think there should be some wiggle room. I am open to how that got carried out.

As far as lower players that is always a problem. We let our lower guys donate between wars and they understand to never do it (no one with less than max) during war. I myself have the 35 spaces and when farming will request nothing higher than a certain level just so that the low guys get their chance. I think the only fix id for the higher guys in the clan to work that way to help their lower guys develop.

Sorry your ideas get pushed down so much. I do try to call guys out on spamming practices and reduce the traffic. But yeah, it does still happen a lot.

---

for the ranking system, i just thought of something cant they decide what they want to get. Like in black jack, they can hold a few of the things they want and discard the rest if they change there mind then they can do so

Wish I could make some pics on the fly for the idea, but basicly it is just an 'advisory' thing. It would be like.
Can give...
Almost anytime: lvl5 archers, lvl5 barbarians
Give most times: lvl4 giants, lvl2 hog riders
Give during war: lvl3 dragons
Give on demand: <list of other stuff>

Accepts
Often 4+ archers, barbarians
War 3+ dragon, 2 minions, 1 <other>
Accept <list of misc others>
Don't usually want WB, Giants, Balloons, Goblins

Maybe you can save several common request messages, and use them. But that's basicly it. It just says what you usually can give, and what you usually accept. No mandatory anything, just voluntarily info.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

Thanks. Now if only I could make a dang thread that could cut through the spam of the forum, and get just half the attention a drama filled, rehashed, rant thread gets, I'd be set.

---

Exactly my point. Nobody pays attention anymore.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Death31

Exactly my point. Nobody pays attention anymore.

---

Well when you make a thread with a title like "hey look at me I have a new Idea!!!!!! Put this in next update!!!!" then it will just get filled with replies telling them to make a better thread, mostly from me ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DanGleeballs

Well when you make a thread with a title like "hey look at me I have a new Idea!!!!!! Put this in next update!!!!" then it will just get filled with replies telling them to make a better thread, mostly from me ;)

---

Don't tempted me... Honestly thought how practical it would be to write a post in a way to purposefully generate the same kind of response the noob threads make. Haven't found out how to say it and actually get stuff done.. yet :p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Crn

How about this then with the ranking system make it where they can only donate what is asked for if they say level three dragon then they cant donate anything but a level three dragon if they say anything they can donate anything

---

I think youre missing the entire point and definition of "donation" bud.