Printable View
Ok so when i go through my revenge list I am only able to attack like 3 people out of 20 because the others have shields or are online. They should make it where if they are not attackable they dont show up on the list.
Tell me what you guys think
Also note that you cannot attack them with a shield but they will not have the revenge option next to their name
Agreed, Impossible for me to ever do a revenge
Also agree. But it's called a shield for a reason, maybe the ability to kick someone off line if they don't have a sheild? Just has the notification, 'you were disconnected'.
not fussed tbh ....
(if anything, I'd prefer bigger/longer attack logs -- as if i'm revenged, its usually dropped away, so I have no idea what i got from them to start with)
NO! A shield is meant to keep your base safe from attacks. I would probably quit the game if this ever happened since I'm a farmer who cares about shields.Quote:
Originally Posted by jocar2000
Does anyone ever stop and think ? If you could do this to other people they could do it to you..... I bet you ATTACK a lot more than you get attacked..... Imagine if all those people revenged you.......... You'd come back to no loot.
did you read the op?Quote:
Originally Posted by SaeedOrphan
He only asked for it not show up if you couldn't be attacked.......
does anyone ever read original posts? -- thats not what they asked for .......Quote:
Originally Posted by THNSUM
But another suggested the ability to kick people offline...... Keep reading, it's good practice.Quote:
Originally Posted by victort
my bad -- i cant read properly -- user muppetryQuote:
Originally Posted by THNSUM
(Not a bad suggestion, but then I don't usualy stay online waiting for an army, so wouldn't adversely affect me, would only aid me if I ever bothered with my revenge more than once in a blue moon)
Quote:
Originally Posted by victort
as I think about the OP, I wonder if the constant need to update the attack log as people log on and off , or as shields come and go, would cause the servers to slow down? That would not be a good thing....
Ironic solution: Tweak shield timing to where you get attacked by people you can actually revenge attack.
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...r-Shield-tweak
Take it from me, someone that has an erratic sleeps schedule, you can revenge attack people. I'm now constantly down to 6-8 people left I can attack on my 30+ list of raids on my base, waiting on them to be worth attacking (could have long ago, but didn't), because I'm on when the other guy becomes active and logs off.
If you don't get attacked while asleep, and inactive, you won't get attacked by some person on the other side of the world. They will have a shield up and sleeping, while you are awake, hitting the revenge button fruitlessly, until gone from the defense log.
Obviously, I don't support the attack under the shield option. I just see too many people being ticked off by it, even if you put limits and modifiers on it. Keep It Simple, Silly; just shift the time the shield gets used. No need for complex exceptions and limits.
the shield would not go away but the person would not have the revenge option next to their name
bump please respond
Quote:
Originally Posted by SaeedOrphan
He doesn't want to revenge while shield, but he want anyone with a shield to not be in the revenge list.Quote:
Originally Posted by THNSUM
Not to be argumentative, but we allready had that discussion, earlier in the thread, lol, if only everyone read the whole thread, lol...:rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by NF2335
But the consensus so far seems to be...... fair enough, but what op want's may cause server stress, with the amount of updating required.....
Really guys, adjust when shields are used. You block attacks from people that will have a shield up most of the time you are awake, and your chances for getting a revenge attack in improves greatly. I say improve, not guaranteed. The exposed town hall base will still hide from you fairly fast, and could actually do this on thier own without need for any added features (as suggested in my link above).
The inability to revenge within a day or so is frustrating.