Clan Wars mega base??

So this is an idea I have for a "new" type of clan wars. I don't think it will ever happen but its an idea. it kind of only makes sense, for 10-20 person wars. as anything higher maybe just to much.to help keep this simple I'm going to explain this with a 10 person war.

The idea is you grab everyone base and put them together in given group. like 2 x 5 for 10 man wars and 3 x 5 for 15...
Meaning for argument sake saying your base plot is 50 x 50 squares. the War base would be 100 x 250 blocks, and everyone in the war will get a 50 x 50 space in that "mega base" to set up a layout. like this http://s1055.photobucket.com/user/Ad...tml?sort=3&o=0

Base Design -
so everyone would keep the standard space to design a layout, BUT the clan canwork together and make a mega base as in people can move there TH and other building into the corner of the were they meet there other clan mates. forming 1 big base or they can keep it 10 small bases far apart. http://s1055.photobucket.com/user/Ad...tml?sort=3&o=0 I know it only shows 8 people but it is just to show how your clan can work together.

Attacking -
So how does attacking work in this you ask?? its simple everyone will still get 2 attack to do Vs this Mega base. the only difference is you are not attacking only 1 person layout/base. you are attacking the 100 x 250 layout of bases. so your clan will have 20 attacks to do as much damage to this mega base as you can. so you can have you whole clan start attacking from 1 side trying to get to the group of TH's in the middle or just work around the whole base weakening it for the last blow, and your attack you will still have the normal 3Mins or until all your troops are dead. since it will be hard to kill this mega base. CC troops/buildings/defenses will not come back after an destroyed. so it will let clans come up with a game plan to kill the base

Getting Stars -
So this part is were it gets different and is open to different ways. but I feel it should get treated as a whole base not 10 bases. so the first idea I have is for every 10% of damage done to the base is 1 star, and for every TH that is destroyed you get another Star. so you can get a max of 20 stars in a 10 man war. and if you wanted to match the 30 stars you can get now you could always add 1 star for completely destroying 1 persons base.

So the bad.
It maybe be very hard for the lower guys in your clan to even do damage to this mega base when sometimes you have the top guys lvl 100- and low guys lvl 60.. BUT!! it can be over come by teamwork. as in you can use the lower guy for clean up. you can have the higher guys go in with balloons or hogs something to kill the defenses then have the lower guys come in to clean out the remaining buildings.

I know I probably explained this very bad or a lot of questions to be answered, but I feel it can be molded into a very cool and fun extra in the game. not saying it should replace clan wars but maybe another type of clan wars.

Update - from people's ideas and thoughts

So it looks like we have 2 different type of ideas here.

Idea#1 is you use everyone's existing base buildings/Defenses, and I guess the best way to describe it is not a Mega base but more of a map were everyone in the war can design a base in a set area, and were the enemy can attack from any were on this map, and attack anyone they want. in this idea everyone has 2 attacks, and the buildings do not Respawn after being destroyed.

Idea#2 is your clan gets a new plot of land that is say 4 times bigger then your normal base, and SC picks how many defenses or other buildings you go for this "Clan Village", and your clan member donate recourse to this village to upgrade it's buildings/defenses. and when attacking the enemy village your clan gets 2 attacks but the buildings respawn but only get back 50-75% of its life. (meaning you would have to kill the same building around 3-4 times for it to be destroyed when you start you next attack) this allows you to slowly weaken the base to get to the TH of the clan.

The only problem I see with the Clan Village is you are starting a new village and now u are talking about lvl level defenses and base getting attacked by peoples army's which are already lvled up. they will just plow though the village unless you put in some type of troop leveling building in the village that set the lvl of troops that are attacking in the war, so the troops will be on par with the Village you are attacking in the war.

Sincerely the best idea i have red recently. In my opinion it could be implemented in a simple war where on the top of the map you have the Mega War Base. The number of defense units (teslas, arch tow, canon, mortars, wiz tow, x-bow, inferno tow ecc) could be established by supercell because it`s difficult to calculate the balance and the leader and co-leaders only have the right to edit the Mega War Base layout picking up the deffense units from the players of the clan as their actual lvl like in a simple clan war.

Another idea of how it could be is in a form of Clan village:
Supercell introduces clan villages which are to be level up by all the players of the clan and leaders and co-leaders control. Clan Village would appear as this thread propose as a Mega War Base which all the players would have only one possibility to attack and all attacks should be coordinated to destroy all the clan village.

I would love this idea an a think that this continues in the same line of evolution of supercell conserving the game authenticity and game play.

I went and made an layout like I mentioned above.
http://s1055.photobucket.com/user/Ad...tml?sort=3&o=0 (I know this image only shows 8 people Vs 10 its meant to show how people can work together)

in it you will see 4 people in the clan can work together and make one big base instead of 10 small bases. there is endless amount of ways you can set up different types of bases,

Not a good idea. No matter how much troops you send at a "combined" base, all the splash damage defenses will tear them down if placed correctly.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Skenderbeu

Sincerely the best idea i have red recently. In my opinion it could be implemented in a simple war where on the top of the map you have the Mega War Base. The number of defense units (teslas, arch tow, canon, mortars, wiz tow, x-bow, inferno tow ecc) could be established by supercell because it`s difficult to calculate the balance and the leader and co-leaders only have the right to edit the Mega War Base layout picking up the deffense units from the players of the clan as their actual lvl like in a simple clan war.

Another idea of how it could be is in a form of Clan village:
Supercell introduces clan villages which are to be level up by all the players of the clan and leaders and co-leaders control. Clan Village would appear as this thread propose as a Mega War Base which all the players would have only one possibility to attack and all attacks should be coordinated to destroy all the clan village.

I would love this idea an a think that this continues in the same line of evolution of supercell conserving the game authenticity and game play.

---

I like a lot of the ideas you have put out there, and I think there is a lot of ways this can be turned into something fun and different. if it was a Clan Village were the clan puts recourses in to help level it up for the war, or If you keep it that everyone in the war sets up the base making it count on teamwork, and now with the new update the leaders get to pick who goes in. so if you clan mate does not want to work together they don't have to be in the war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by edomingox

Not a good idea. No matter how much troops you send at a "combined" base, all the splash damage defenses will tear them down if placed correctly.

---

Ya I was thinking about that, and was trying to figure out how can a clan over come that. and the answer I have is simple. you need teamwork and it will make clans have to use everything in the game. like say you have a clan put all there wizard towers near each other or what not. you can have you lower guys in the clan attack with lighting spells killing Key defenses making it a lot easier for the higher guys to go in and kill the base. And since the mega base destroyed buildings don't respawn you can weaken it at key points.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Skenderbeu

introduces clan villages which are to be level up by all the players of the clan and leaders and co-leaders control.

---

this is a great idea, have a clan base, and assign +\- 5 members to specific duties....
EG:
each of the 5 members are in charge of maintaining and upgrading a part of the base
1= (clan leader) clan base attacker and layout decider of clan base
2= air defence
3= ground defence and walls
4= attacking troops
5= all other buildings

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fiekie88SA

this is a great idea, have a clan base, and assign +\- 5 members to specific duties....
EG:
each of the 5 members are in charge of maintaining and upgrading a part of the base
1= (clan leader) clan base attacker and layout decider of clan base
2= air defence
3= ground defence and walls
4= attacking troops
5= all other buildings

---

So would this Clan Village be the one that is being used for clan war? if so I do like the idea a lot. it will help solve the issue of to many splash damage defenses or what not. as SC can control how many of a type of defenses can be put into the village. and maybe the clan can get a plot that is like 4 times bigger then the normal one to work on. instead of a TH is a Clan Hall or something that is bigger and maybe it can house the CC troops.

I'm not sure about having people in charge of set duties. I would say the Leader/ Co-leader should be able to move things in the village, and everyone in the clan can donate resources at any time to a Clan storage in the actual village and then the leaders can use that to upgrade the village.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by edomingox

Not a good idea. No matter how much troops you send at a "combined" base, all the splash damage defenses will tear them down if placed correctly.

---

It doesn`t make sense what you say. As it is represented in the thread you will have a MEGA BASE the lay out of which would be attacked by the hole clan trying to eat it peace by peace.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Adelima19

So would this Clan Village be the one that is being used for clan war? if so I do like the idea a lot. it will help solve the issue of to many splash damage defenses or what not. as SC can control how many of a type of defenses can be put into the village. and maybe the clan can get a plot that is like 4 times bigger then the normal one to work on. instead of a TH is a Clan Hall or something that is bigger and maybe it can house the CC troops.

I'm not sure about having people in charge of set duties. I would say the Leader/ Co-leader should be able to move things in the village, and everyone in the clan can donate resources at any time to a Clan storage in the actual village and then the leaders can use that to upgrade the village.

---

i think this could be decided at the start of a war, or have a different second war option.
like when you start the war, you can choose to use a team effort war or the clan village war.

it might be better to focus it in this way, and not allow two wars to run at the same time....

i would like to add that for the clan village war, that there be a progressive damage system, where out of two attacks, how much stack damage can be caused. so you do first attack, and when you do the second attack, you can kind of "continue where you left off".