Allow clan members to attack each other but without any loot gain/bonus

Often times there is a lot of spirited discussion amongst clan members about challenging each others bases. It would be awesome if there was a feature that would allow such a thing. Obviously there could not be any loot won/lost so people don't manipulate the system. The only thing "won" would be bragging rights amongst each other. It should cost resources to create an army/spell just as it would for a regular attack.

Thoughts?

You could easily replicate an enemies base and practice attack

agree with above, you can easily replicate an enemy's base and war would just be too easy, too op

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dynastar8

You could easily replicate an enemies base and practice attack

---

Thats a good point and I hadnt thought of it.

I suppose a work around could be there is a dedicated base just for this feature that could not be changed if you are currently in a war. We have 3 options for a regular base and 3 options for a war base. Adding one more doesnt seem out of the realm of possibilities.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dma

Thats a good point and I hadnt thought of it.

I suppose a work around could be there is a dedicated base just for this feature that could not be changed if you are currently in a war. We have 3 options for a regular base and 3 options for a war base. Adding one more doesnt seem out of the realm of possibilities.

---

Firstly, COC does not make it easy to attack the same base second time! So, practicing a particular base til we can find a strategy to beat it is not really a serious concern. Only time, you can benefit is before you can revenge a base. But, opponent is free to change his bases! Can use a shield. And at most you benefit once by repeatedly practicing!

More over, if you really want to find out how to take a base, copy the target base on to your own base and let people attack and see the successful attack replay and you have a good strategy to get your target base.

I do not really think you can actually target bases.

Idea is really good.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dynastar8

You could easily replicate an enemies base and practice attack

---

That's not true. You have to have an identical base makeup to replicate the enemy's.

Also, SC should do this because:

1) It is wanted
2) If they don't, someone will build a simulator and SC will lose control.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dma

Often times there is a lot of spirited discussion amongst clan members about challenging each others bases. It would be awesome if there was a feature that would allow such a thing. Obviously there could not be any loot won/lost so people don't manipulate the system. The only thing "won" would be bragging rights amongst each other. It should cost resources to create an army/spell just as it would for a regular attack.

Thoughts?

---

Like.

It would need limitations. For example:

* A cost, in gold or gems. The attacks themselves cost elixir.
* A frequency limit. You can do it once per day, or once per week.
* Preparation waiting time. Both players need to agree. Then they need to prepare. 12 to 24 hours after the agreement might be a suitable delay.

With these limitations, it would be too difficult to repeatedly practice against an imitation enemy base, and would therefore be used for the original intent, for friendly clan co-members to occasionally spar.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by George1971

That's not true. You have to have an identical base makeup to replicate the enemy's.

Also, SC should do this because:

1) It is wanted
2) If they don't, someone will build a simulator and SC will lose control.

---

Maxed bases already hae that. And also, any base of similar level build can get a clear picture.

1. Who cares? Many people want free gems so should SC give prople free gems?


use search before posting ♥♥♥♥♥♥ed ♥♥♥♥ on the forum

Wouldn't this be the same thing as sandbox attacking? I do not think this should be implemented in the game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by George1971

Like.

It would need limitations. For example:

* A cost, in gold or gems. The attacks themselves cost elixir.
* A frequency limit. You can do it once per day, or once per week.
* Preparation waiting time. Both players need to agree. Then they need to prepare. 12 to 24 hours after the agreement might be a suitable delay.

With these limitations, it would be too difficult to repeatedly practice against an imitation enemy base, and would therefore be used for the original intent, for friendly clan co-members to occasionally spar.

---

Good ideas. I think once per week would be fine. I'd be willing to spend 25 gems or so just back up some friendly smack talk with my clan mates :)