4 STAR SYSTEM!!! CLAN WARS (Increase the game dynamics)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mikrojr

I am reading about this proposal to change the STAR system and I believe it's a BAD idea!

Why?
1. Adding more STAR's decreases the separation between a PERFECT ATTACK (100%) and a "not Perfect attack".
2. Getting a 3 STAR is a challenge, and it should be rewarded appropriately. (ie. much more!)
3. In our clan, NOT getting a 3 STAR is considered a "failed" attack.
4. Why should a clan, who can't do 3 STAR attacks, be given a greater opportunity to earn stars with "failed" attacks?
5. The current system encourages excellence, a revamped system, with more STAR's, would encourage mediocrity.

Bottom line, the current system is good, and doesn't need to be changed.

Thanks,

Mikro jr

Btw, if you want to join our clan, look us up ... Top Chiefs (#9UPR2QG9)

---

THANK YOU FOR YOUR OPINION! IM GOING TO RESPOND ONE BY ONE TO YOUR POINTS
Why?
IN MY OPINION IT INCREASE THE WAR DYNAMICS!
1. Adding more STAR's decreases the separation between a PERFECT ATTACK (100%) and a "not Perfect attack".
AS I SEE THINGS IT MAKES DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ATTACKS THAT AIM TO GET ONLY 50% +TH WHICH IS REALLY SIMPLE WITH ATTACKS OF MORE THAN 75% +TH WHICH IS REALLY DIFFICULT IF YOU ATTACK AN OPPONENT WITH THE SAME TH LEVEL.
2. Getting a 3 STAR is a challenge, and it should be rewarded appropriately. (ie. much more!)
OK ! I AGREE ( A 100% ATTACK SHOULD BE REWARDED MORE / THE SAME IF YOU GET 4 STARS )
3. In our clan, NOT getting a 3 STAR is considered a "failed" attack.
I`M IN A TOP 100 RANK CLAN. IN MY CLAN ATTACKING YOUR SAME NR OPPONENT AND GETTING ONLY 2 STARS IS NOT CONSIDERED A FAIL. ATTACKING A TH LOWER OR AN OPPONENT RANKED MUCH LOWER IN THE MAP - IS CONSIDERED A FAIL
4. Why should a clan, who can't do 3 STAR attacks, be given a greater opportunity to earn stars with "failed" attacks?
THIS IS NOT WORTH RESPONDING! YOUR PERCEPTION OF OTHER CLANS IS NOT REAL
5. The current system encourages excellence, a revamped system, with more STAR's, would encourage mediocrity.
4 STAR WOULD NOT ONLY ENCOURAGE EXCELLENCE BUT ALSO WILL MAKE A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN BARELY 50%+TH ATTACKS TO THOSE NEARLY 100%
Bottom line, the current system is good, and doesn't need to be changed.
IT`S YOUR OPINION!
Thanks,
THANK YOU TOO

Btw, if you want to join our clan, look us up ... Top Chiefs (#9UPR2QG9)
MAY BE ONLY FOR A MOMENT BECAUSE I REALLY DOUBT WHAT YOU SAY IS REALISTIC

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Skenderbeu

2. Getting a 3 STAR is a challenge, and it should be rewarded appropriately. (ie. much more!)
OK ! I AGREE ( A 100% ATTACK SHOULD BE REWARDED MORE / THE SAME IF YOU GET 4 STARS )
3. In our clan, NOT getting a 3 STAR is considered a "failed" attack.
I`M IN A TOP 100 RANK CLAN. IN MY CLAN ATTACKING YOUR SAME NR OPPONENT AND GETTING ONLY 2 STARS IS NOT CONSIDERED A FAIL. ATTACKING A TH LOWER OR AN OPPONENT RANKED MUCH LOWER IN THE MAP - IS CONSIDERED A FAIL

Btw, if you want to join our clan, look us up ... Top Chiefs (#9UPR2QG9)
MAY BE ONLY FOR A MOMENT BECAUSE I REALLY DOUBT WHAT YOU SAY IS REALISTIC

---

Skenderbeu, I look at the top clans and I don't see skill, I see high level.

Lots of people, who have the time, or who have played from the birth of CoC, have levelled their bases to Godly levels, but that doesn't mean they have skill with the game. Should we reward these unskilled players with a reward system that accommodates their unskillful play? Of course not.

Skill and High level are certainly not the same. The current system reflects that. Stop whining about it and start learning better tactics to be successful with a 3 star!

Mikro (Top Chiefs #9UPR2QG9)
13 CLAN WARS TOTAL (4 PERFECT WARS + 5 WARS missed one STAR)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mikrojr

Skenderbeu, I look at the top clans and I don't see skill, I see high level.

Lots of people, who have the time, or who have played from the birth of CoC, have levelled their bases to Godly levels, but that doesn't mean they have skill with the game. Should we reward these unskilled players with a reward system that accommodates their unskillful play? Of course not.

Skill and High level are certainly not the same. The current system reflects that

---

First of all may i say that i dont agree with this complitelly? What are you talking about. Do you know what it takes to reach 4000 trophy? I think that yo are a th8 that attack with hogs and get always 3 stars from opponents ranked lower than you. If you had tryed high lvl before you were going to speak differently!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Skenderbeu

First of all may i say that i dont agree with this complitelly? What are you talking about. Do you know what it takes to reach 4000 trophy? I think that yo are a th8 that attack with hogs and get always 3 stars from opponents ranked lower than you. If you had tryed high lvl before you were going to speak differently!

---

Yeah, I hear that at every level. TH7 is different! TH8 is different! TH9 is different!

Whatever. It's all ♥♥.

BTW, I don't use Hogs to 🌟🌟🌟. Hogs are like balloons, but harder because the CC's are buried.
I do Pekka attacks against TH9 bases and I am TH8. Sure, they are lower TH9's, but I am a TH8, and I 3 star them in WAR with a smart strategy!

Stopping whining for this change. Go join a über clan appropriate for your TH level and learn some better strategies.

Sincerely,

Mikro

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mikrojr

Yeah, I hear that at every level. TH7 is different! TH8 is different! TH9 is different!

Whatever. It's all ♥♥.

BTW, I don't use Hogs to 🌟🌟🌟. Hogs are like balloons, but harder because the CC's are buried.
I do Pekka attacks against TH9 bases and I am TH8. Sure, they are lower TH9's, but I am a TH8, and I 3 star them in WAR with a smart strategy!

Stopping whining for this change. Go join a über clan appropriate for your TH level and learn some better strategies.

Sincerely,

Mikro

---

i dont think u know th 10 vs th 10 is like how ever how this change will reword unskilled players??

a player who get 100% will get 4 stars and thats the best score(like u)
a player who get 75% with th will get 3 stars and thats a good score
a player who get 50% with th will get 2 stars and thats an ok score


i dont know how this will reword unskilled players

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mrkw

Great Idea. This doesn't change the game too much. It would totally change a lot of aspects in the game. Maybe this could be clan wars only?

---

If you read the whole thing, you would realize that he did specify it to be clan wars only

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Blueiron

the 3 star system in place already works fine, if it ain't broke, why fix it?

adding the 4th star may complicate things, especially when it comes to trophies etc

---

This is for clan wars only, trophies wouldn't matter, read the whole post next time

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by useless

i dont think u know th 10 vs th 10 is like how ever how this change will reword unskilled players??

a player who get 100% will get 4 stars and thats the best score(like u)
a player who get 75% with th will get 3 stars and thats a good score
a player who get 50% with th will get 2 stars and thats an ok score


i dont know how this will reword unskilled players

---

Thank you for your post. It will help me deal with other similair comments.

I think it is a good idea, in my clan there are only 2 th10, rest is 7-9 and in all 20 wars there never was a 3 star by either side at the townhall 10 players.

Maybe the inferno towers are just too strong or you do need a level 30+ King/Queen to 3 Star bases, i dont know.

But right now, i only want it for clan war.

In clan wars (at least till TH9) its either three star or none. If you leave out a star, someone else have to attack and take it. So, doesn't really matter whether you have 3 stars or 4.