Thank you for your support!Quote:
Originally Posted by Retell
Printable View
Thank you for your support!Quote:
Originally Posted by Retell
I agreed on your idea but with little change.i would rather suggest 5 star battle.as they keep track of 25%,50%,75%,100% and town hall down,it wont be difficult to implement this.
This is the breakdown how it will work:-
25% damage - 1 star(+1 star,if th is down)
50% damage - 2 star(+1 star,if th is down)
75% damage - 3 star(+1 star,if th is down)
100% damage- 5 star
No a 25% victory don't make any sense. We need a gap closer between 50% and 100% for people who are skilled, but can not reach the nearly impossible to 3 star (without ♥♥♥♥♥♥e)Quote:
Originally Posted by vinsnd
I dont mind if anyone 1 star or 2 star me in 5 star battle.remember this in 3 star battle 2 star is consider as fail below th10 and include even th9.if i am th9 and some 1 star or 2 star me in 5 star battle that is considered as defence win.Quote:
Originally Posted by Skenderbeu
Now come with th10 problem as gap between 2 star and 3 star is so huge.to minimize the complexness of 4 star mechanism and this huge gap of 2 star and 3 star,5 star system is much more stable.
i agree that in the actual 3star system below th10 is considered a fail. The point is that 25% to get a bonus loot is unacceptable because there wont be any fails and people would start abuse with it. what do you think?Quote:
Originally Posted by vinsnd
yep even a th 7 will 25% a th10 easy and get an amazing bnus which is completely unfair:facepalm:Quote:
Originally Posted by Skenderbeu
I personally don't think the system is broken and would be okay keeping it 3 stars. However, i like your idea and am always interested in giving new stuff a try when it has been thought out and wouldn't hurt the game in any way. Your 4 star system is a good idea; no reason not to have discussion about it and maybe give it a shot someday.
Generally not a bad idea. After reading through countless pages here, I am not swayed either way. There may be however, better/simpler ways to go about breaking draws....
My personal favorite would be a sudden death round, ClanWar is Extended for a set amount of time and everyone gets one more attack. this would never work for many reasons but i think it would be cool nonetheless :)
you could also simply break ties by giving the win to the clan with more average destruction. like winning a boxing match by points and not K.O. This would elimate the problem of clans that obviously outplayed thier enemy being shafted with bad rewards and you dont have to add any stars. The average destruction feature is already in place....
Its not about breaking draw but to make a difference from a barely 50%+th from nearly 80% attacks that get same 2 starsQuote:
Originally Posted by ecstasiate
Thank you!Quote:
Originally Posted by destroyer14