Printable View
I like these ideas - especially the anti spies and the fact that you can only have a specific amount of *elders* (for egs)
The only thing I would tweak is that you can take out of others donation box - get rid of this idea and I think this thread is pretty much perfect ;)
I do love the idea of adding limited vice leader positions who have the ability to remove rampaging, tantrum throwing, or trolling co-leaders: someone who holds the same level of authority as the leader (apart from kicking the leader or other vice leader, or promoting vice... only the leader should get to choose those roles), because we cannot be on 24/7. I am also not opposed to the vice leader position instead being a limited number of co-leaders and changing the current membership roles names to co-leader (limited), elder, senior, member. In either case there is still a "new" limited helper position.
Also, I saw several people mention the idea of cool down times... I thought maybe that could be viable if adding the new rank is not. Make it so after say 3-5 kicks a co-leader makes he has a cool down time of several hours. That could stop trolls or irate co's from decimating entire clans within seconds.
Thanks for your thread and ideas!!
I created a poll using your vice information, and title role information also posted in this thread. I decided not to double post my comment, so have edited my original post here. If you wish to see my poll with the comment I originally posted here, it's at http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/961898-Add-Vice-Leader-or-limit-of-Co-leaders-or-put-a-cool-down-time-on-co-kicks
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...95#post6204295
I'd like ur opinion on my version of this idea!!!! That should be the right link
This is a nice idea beaucose it's boring when everybody is co-leader and do what he wants... :) Sorry if something is wrong... I'm from Germany :P
The Blacklist (Lvl 5) is the best Clan ever :D
There definately needs to be another rank between co and elders
I like where you're going with the leader thing. I like the set up now with the lead and co leads. Maybe a captain is a good idea but ultimately the leader should only promote co leads. Im in a group now with about 10 co leads and an inactive leader. I dont even know if he/she plays and it drives me crazy! I would like to see if a leadership challenge can go out. Ive been in this clan for about a year and with me and a couple others we built it to a lvl 7 clan. But no leader to kick or demote the players who just go inactive. Its not fair to us who avidly play every day! Lose wars because of a faulty leader. Overall im all for this idea. I have more thoughts and views. Let me know what you think!
Need a war warden
who can maintain the war....
who can make a war plan n
who can maintain WAR DONATION BOX
N if he makes a plan n LOCK a member with plan or with a attack number THEN that member cant be able to attack anyone without his LOCKING NUMBER until the WAR wARDEN UNLOCK it..
He also maintain DONATION BOX N can be able to lock it..n he can lock to it to any member with his choice..before war he can make a request for DONATION BOX according his choice..n if he lock ARCHER for a member then that MEMBER cant be able to TAKE any troops except ARCHER...N IN MY OPINION THE POSITION WILL BE
Leader(1)
Co leader(5 n more)
War warden(5)
Elder
Yonger
how about adding ranks with no control over the clan, same like member but higher.
Nah OP, that's way too convoluted. And why would you want to restrict the number of given roles to a certain number? What if I wanted everyone else to be vice ? That idea alone could lead to friction for no reason.
Its too many roles all in all. The four levels we have are fine tbh.
I like the idea that noobs cannot see tesla and bombs for a few days, that's kinda cool. :smirk:
Love the idea to prevent war spies xDQuote:
-NEW (the same role w/ few changes)
-They basically have no authority until promoted to a higher role, but they can participate in clan wars.
-They also cannot see traps or hidden teslas when looking at other members bases and war bases. (This will prevent war spies.) (This is optional; leaders decision)
-They also cannot see what are in members clan castles and war castles, but they can still donate troops. (This is optional; leaders decision)
-After one week of being a new, their role will turn to blank like it does now and they will be able to see traps, hidden teslas, troops in castles, etc.
These changes will prevent clan war spies. Also, this makes it where the leader doesn't always have to be on, but they still have full control over their clan. This will make the leadership roles in a clan more structured.
Just to let you guys know the clan donation box I am refering to is the Clan Troop Bank in my signature. To see that thread just click on the link. Thanks!
(Not sure if I should be writing a separate thread for this, but.....)
Also like to suggest being able to edit and change the name of the positions in the game though the roles are essentially the same (for those who wants to keep a theme that matches clan name) So for example, let's say we have a clan named "Metamorphosis", the Leader could be called a "Butterfly", Co could be a "Cocoon, Elder could be "Caterpillar" and Member be an "Egg".
Just an idea since it's a game for fun, so why not be able to name things for a laugh? :P