New Leadership Positions/Roles

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OldAndConfused

lol... you are trying to force immature leaders... that get told all day long in global not to give co away [but ignore it] into a situation where they are forced to limit the number of this high rank... Do you really think that is going to stop those same "leaders" from giving away the top rank like a cookie to the first people that asks for it - followed by the next rank down once they are filled?


Yes, sure. I will expect to help a lot of people, and hinder none. Just because you can't make something damn-fool proof doesn't mean you shouldn't try.

The current roles allow the leader to relax just fine if the leader uses them correctly.

Yes, sure, it is not required for leaders who know what they are doing, but there are lots of others.

I say, stop trying to engineer out dumb leaders and let them learn to listen to people that are smarter than them or suffer the consequences of their choices. Its just possible that playing a game can make you learn something.

I say, make the clans easier to run, especially if so easily done. In hindsight, introducing the unlimited over powerful co-leader was a silly decision causing grief for many.

Jrap proposes limiting to ten. Does anyone have experience in a well run clan where there are needed to be 11+ leaders, or 14+ with ViceLeaders? I strongly doubt it. Does anyone know a clan where the game was ruined due to cheapened co-leader within their clan?

To the original poster... when people say they have problems with your idea its probably not a good thing to attack them. Apart from just looking really bad to everyone thats reading it... your idea may just not be what many people want OR heaven forbid... might not be as awesome as you think it is.

You have an itch to scratch... everyone does... so listen to what is said... get people to clarify... and if you still disagree... thank them for their input.


Yes, that's true. On your part, you haven't stated a problem with the proposal, beyond having a problem with providing help to others not as clever as you. (this idea, which I strongly support, will have no benefit to my clan either, but I think it will improve the game experience for others)

---

Replies in bold above.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by George1971

Replies in bold above.

---

I have not stated what I think is wrong with the proposal because I think it was adequately covered by other users of this thread.

Regarding your other points... clearly... I completely disagree.

Thanks for your input :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OldAndConfused

I have not stated what I think is wrong with the proposal because I think it was adequately covered by other users of this thread.

Regarding your other points... clearly... I completely disagree.

Thanks for your input :)

---

You completely disagree that anybody knows of any clan where the game experience was ruined by the ease of cheapening promotion to co-leader? That's absurd.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by N1NJ4W4RR10R

Great job!
Would love to see this in the next update

PS. Thx for all the detail, its pretty annoying to see those threads that just ask for a new rank, but don't put any detail.

---

Thanks!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PigRidingNigga

:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:DItz not needed

---

Learn how to spell?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CaptainAB13

Very good idea

---

Thanks!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by scarface56

Very nice for spy

---

I agree thats partly why I came up with this idea. Thanks!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by George1971

Replies in bold above.

---

Thanks George for your help! I will change vice leaders from 2 to 3 now. And when I'm not as busy I will change the format of the thread. I also mentioned you in the thread :)

This idea is great. I actually came on this forum to suggest an idea similar to this...but not as well fleshed out. I am the leader of a clan and I have several long term, loyal players who are more than elders but-- I can't promote everyone to co-leader and besides, that cheapens the co-leader position for my COs who are awesome. So more ranks are definitely needed.

Love the idea of the 'New' rank so I can see who recently joined.

I want to see this in the next update.

P.S. Don't worry about people's comments about twits giving away Captain ranks...people will be able to mismanage any system you give them. The important thing is to improve the clan system for the functioning clans and leaders -- and this would be a BIG improvement.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BALMMAKER

This idea is great. I actually came on this forum to suggest an idea similar to this...but not as well fleshed out. I am the leader of a clan and I have several long term, loyal players who are more than elders but-- I can't promote everyone to co-leader and besides, that cheapens the co-leader position for my COs who are awesome. So more ranks are definitely needed.

Love the idea of the 'New' rank so I can see who recently joined.

I want to see this in the next update.

P.S. Don't worry about people's comments about twits giving away Captain ranks...people will be able to mismanage any system you give them. The important thing is to improve the clan system for the functioning clans and leaders -- and this would be a BIG improvement.

---

Exactly! Thank you!!!!!

Another ideas : We can kick/promote/demote someone on clan chat no need to go to clan menu.Also directly promote to co-leader or elder / demote to user or elder :) Not need to tap 2 times for them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mythness

Another ideas : We can kick/promote/demote someone on clan chat no need to go to clan menu.Also directly promote to co-leader or elder / demote to user or elder :) Not need to tap 2 times for them.

---

That would be too dangerous for some prone to misclick, fat fingers on little phones.

When you you get good at managing a clan, demotions and kicking is a rare event.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by George1971

That would be too dangerous for some prone to misclick, fat fingers on little phones.

When you you get good at managing a clan, demotions and kicking is a rare event.

---

True that
10char

I think this is a great idea, especially the hiding of traps and such to new members to prevent war spies. Those can be really annoying