No shield against revenge

It's a decent idea in theory. The problem I see is allowing revenge regardless of the shield makes for it being pointless to raid people. If I just wait for my base to be attacked by someone farming trophies all I have to do is revenge them and steal their resources and it subjects that player to losing 2x or more of their resources. This will never happen and if it does I might just quit playing. I'm a firm believer in if it ain't broke don't fix it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by edomingox

If you want to be able to revenge someone and ignore the shield, what are you going to do? Boot them and say "XXXX is getting revenge!". You can booted a good 3 or 4 times in the next hour. I know if I had that ability, I would revenge immediately before the resource stolen is used. I wouldn't go on any raids at all. I'd just sit back and see what people I can revenge on and never worry about be revenged on.

---

There are two messages you get when you want to revenge. "Active Shield" and "User is Online". Where did he say it would boot you?

i like this idea. You should be able to revenge if someone has a shield but you shouldn't be able to revenge them if they are online.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hashtagduh

There are two messages you get when you want to revenge. "Active Shield" and "User is Online". Where did he say it would boot you?

---

At first I was under the idea of being able to attack if there is no shield regardless if you are online or not. So I edited my comment with what I thought having to go offline for the revenge to work. Many people been wanting the ability to revenge someone even if they are online lately.

thats a great idea until you are in my boat..
full storages, almost full collectors, half full castle

waiting on builders so i can spend some loot

5 builders busy.. just hit th 10 so i need all i can get

so IMO this is a terrible idea.. this would allow ppl to revenge you when you have the most loot possible.. u did not get to attack them on a cherry picked day and time so they should not be able to do the same. they already get to scout your base for as long as the like and see if u have cc troops so IMO it should stay as it is

The only change to the revenge system that I would like it to have a quick indicator as to weither you can currently revenge or not,

say make the button green if you can and red if you cant... I hate strolling through 20 revenge options only to find that every one is either online or has a shield...

if the player is online or has a shield make the button red, if they dont have a shield and are offline make it green, simple

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kmsoji

The only change to the revenge system that I would like it to have a quick indicator as to weither you can currently revenge or not,

say make the button green if you can and red if you cant... I hate strolling through 20 revenge options only to find that every one is either online or has a shield...

if the player is online or has a shield make the button red, if they dont have a shield and are offline make it green, simple

---

Unfourtunately this idea is ruled out, (although it isn't game breaking as removing the revenge shield).

I could go for a two shield system where one shields you from next attacks but does not prevent revenges, and a separate revenge shield that does not protect you from next attacks. It would help make revenges more possible without subjecting me to 40 revenge attacks every day.

How about allowing you to revenge if they have a shield, but there is a catch. If you click on that revenge button and do not perform the attack then it is gone forever (ruling out the cherry picking idea).

Thoughts?

well..it should cost shield...because system is fair and it would unbalance things...
also add a pole to it..lets see people reviews..