Taking of resources form the clan castle

they can steel whats in the clan castle so its better to take it all rather then a part of it

if ur storage is full then u wont take the loot (not sure about this)

I would like this idea, as I don't usually need to take the de or elixir out, just the gold, and not all of that at the same time either

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

But would it be worth the programing and added complexity for Supercell to do?

Not saying it is a bad idea, just wondering if it is 'good enough'. What would be the main purpose and benifit for this? I admit that loot is more secure in the clan castle, (except for maybe dark elixir, assuming loot percentage is the same for it) than storages, and have kept loot inside it for save keeping until I had a good reason to tap into it, but I'm not sure of how many cases where pulling small amounts at a time would be very helpful; Plus trying to make the user interface for pulling only some out at a time, and have it in keeping with the game's basicly interface structure.

Yeah, I know, I just have to come by and spoil the fun and ask the complemacated[sic] questions, huh?

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by useless

they can steel whats in the clan castle so its better to take it all rather then a part of it

if ur storage is full then u wont take the loot (not sure about this)

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Keepo

I would like this idea, as I don't usually need to take the de or elixir out, just the gold, and not all of that at the same time either

---

There will be many cases for players like me.
No, they could only steal 3-7% depending on your th level. loots are sader in cc.

Gold Storage—Percent Lootable by Town Hall Level

Town Hall Level	Cap	% Available to be Stolen	Storage Amount to Reach Cap
1-5	20%	200,000	1,000,000
6	18%	200,000	1,111,111
7	16%	250,000	1,562,500
8	14%	300,000	2,142,857
9	12%	350,000	2,916,667
10	10%	400,000	4,000,000

Clan Castle War Loot—Percent Lootable by Town Hall level

1 - 5	6	7	8	9	10
10%	9%	8%	7%	6%	5%

So basicly, raiders can only get at half as much of the loot as normally obtainable from storages. However...

Dark Elixir Storage—Percent Lootable by Town Hall Level

Town Hall Level	Cap	% Available to be Stolen	Storage Amount to Reach Cap
7	6%	1,200	20,000
8	6%	2,000	33,333
9	5%	2,500	50,000
10	4%	3,000	75,000

Dark Elixir inside it's own storage seems safer, but that's assuming if the percent lootable is the same (as I mentioned earlier).

But as helpful it is to know, that's not what I'm wondering about. Given the cost of upgrades, I don't usually ever have a need to only pull a small amount from clan castle storages. Given how small it is, in comparison to the costs of upgrades, I can't think of a very good reason to add this idea in, unless I'm missing something.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

But as helpful it is to know, that's not what I'm wondering about. Given the cost of upgrades, I don't usually ever have a need to only pull a small amount from clan castle storages. Given how small it is, in comparison to the costs of upgrades, I can't think of a very good reason to add this idea in, unless I'm missing something.

---

That only applies to players like you.
We, hardcore players, only pull the resources from the cc when we need it. We always have 8m gold, 8m elixir and 200k de in our storages and the cc is only for emergency purposes.
We dont need to pull all on emergencies.

bringing up my post

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AtHayEast

That only applies to players like you.
We, hardcore players, only pull the resources from the cc when we need it. We always have 8m gold, 8m elixir and 200k de in our storages and the cc is only for emergency purposes.
We dont need to pull all on emergencies.

---

Only applies to players like me? I just said I can't see why I would need to pull small amounts from it, and you just basicly gave a different reason for why you don't need to either.

And how would you ever know I'm a so-called 'hardcore player' or not? What, is it only based on TH level? :p Because that's not exactly a good definition.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

Only applies to players like me? I just said I can't see why I would need to pull small amounts from it, and you just basicly gave a different reason for why you don't need to either.

And how would you ever know I'm a so-called 'hardcore player' or not? What, is it only based on TH level? :p Because that's not exactly a good definition.

---

Situation:
A th 9 will have 2 builders free in few minutes. He has 8m gold in storages then 1.5m gold in the cc and planning to upgrade a WT to lvl 7 which is 5,360,000 gold, and then a cannon to lvl 11 which is 3.2m. That would be 8,560,000 gold in total
He will just pull 560k gold for those upgrades and another 70k for the nexting cost, and his gold storages will be full (8m gold) again after few hours of raiding. There will still be 870k gold in the cc.

With you saying that . . . :rolleyes:

I think it's fine the way it is. If I want to collect the loot from the Clan Castle in order to help with an upgrade or to refill some lost resources, the penalty is that I collect ALL of the loot and have to try and hide the excess. I think that's fair.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JeremyIsKing

I think it's fine the way it is. If I want to collect the loot from the Clan Castle in order to help with an upgrade or to refill some lost resources, the penalty is that I collect ALL of the loot and have to try and hide the excess. I think that's fair.

---

that is a good point.