Clan Bank

I'd be ok with this, but I don't see it happening.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SgtGuitar

So pretty much you wouldn't need to wait for a req anymore and could pump donations into the bank, hoarding exp?

What at happens when bank is full? Would this make requesting obsolete?

If only 1 player donates to the bank and fills it, then this kind of takes away from others who would like to donate for exp too.

Maybe incorporate a cap as to how many you can donate per day.

---

Well I haven't thought that it would get full - good idea
I will make a cap though Thx!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

Well I haven't thought that it would get full - good idea
I will make a cap though Thx!

---

How about if each player could only donate so much to it a day?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 12lthLvLIntellect

How about if each player could only donate so much to it a day?

---

Just added

Step 1: Donate to bank.
Step 2: Retrieve from bank.
Step 3: Profit.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

Step 1: Donate to bank.
Step 2: Retrieve from bank.
Step 3: Profit.

---

I see your point. I will add something

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

you can't take the same troop you donated for a day (You donate a dragon, and there are now 2 dragons, you still can't take a dragon).

---

Ok and how much effort should they go to to track this for every single player? What happens if I leave and rejoin? What if I leave and join several clans and donate to each? What if I donate level 1 dragons? I can pull out level 2 dragons?

In short, this will never be implemented unless SC changes their minds and allows people to donate to themselves.

I also see other issues. Consider the total number of combinations of troops + troop level. Think of the interface required for pulling troops out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

Ok and how much effort should they go to to track this for every single player? What happens if I leave and rejoin? What if I leave and join several clans and donate to each? What if I donate level 1 dragons? I can pull out level 2 dragons?

In short, this will never be implemented unless SC changes their minds and allows people to donate to themselves.

I also see other issues. Consider the total number of combinations of troops + troop level. Think of the interface required for pulling troops out.

---

Good point

I think people should get XP only when the troops they donate are taken.

I don't like this idea very much. If getting troops is a problem in your clan, you can simply join a different one. That would be the easy solution.