Why the players go Off the clan after WAR Started? Put an End to it

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by buntingan

They are not hostage bad hoppers can see how many wars have been won by a clan so they should have not join in the first place. its not balance, hopper has a way of knowing how good or bad is the clan before joining while a clan leader have nothing to check with.

---

If you are forced to remain in a certain place and are not allowed to leave on your own volition, then required to do something for the person or group that is preventing you from leaving before you can be released, you are by definition a hostage.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

Actually I spoke to the wand earlier and gave why that was a valid statement. Your desperation had you going back several posts looking for a phrase you could retort on. (and if that was the best you could could do then you are hard up indeed) Rather than speak to the good information posted here as to why this entire suggestion is foolish and short sighted you instead are doing that. I take it that since you have several times here passed on that 'debate and discussion' you so much claimed you were standing up for that you actually got nothing for that. Its often a sign of guys that got nothing to come back with is choosing to instead complain that the information got given as we can see in you continuing that path. Of course the information given kills the point you wanted to make. Its because the point you wanted to make was never valid. Get over it kid.

So the bottom line outcome of all this noise is that the OP's suggestion (original topic) was a short sighted bad idea. Its been pretty proven in the points several have made here. No one has been able to produce anything that can support it.

---

you dont have the credibility to validate someones point by talking to your wand, better go and get your medicine. You lack the vision bro, you keep degrading OP's idea as foolish and short sighted rather than thinking outside the box of how it can be polish and became better idea.

Clan War opt in/out on tomorrows update is good :)

Thats what i am talking about, now the clan and clan leader is upgraded with lot of features. Which includes player to more active and play on, clashing so cool and great way. Thanks Clan Perks rocks, started earning XP's. Still need some charts for how much XP we can earn from the war donate, attack and any other chances to get Clan XP's... ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by peenupeenu

War is the core of the game.
Heart of clan description.
Most lovable is Clan Wars.
Put an end to Clan Hoppers/War Hoppers.

Please add a rule

"Players cannot able to leave the Clan, Once War started" and "Disable the leave option once the member is in war participant" . Only Leader do kick players after WAR STARTS.
:confused: Or :confused:
Ask them to use 30 Gems to leave the clan once the WAR Starts. Then some players will not do so. Keep on clashing, I love the Game. Updates rocks, always most welcome. Waiting for SneakPeek <3

OR
How many WAR STARS in one LEAGUE.
Adding New: It will be good if we can know "how many attacks done" in total wars the player played.
Adding a WAR STARS (Total no. of stars/Total no. of attacks) like Attacks Won, Defense Won, Troops Received and Troops Donated.

Thanks
Peenumx

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by buntingan

you dont have the credibility to validate someones point by talking to your wand, better go and get your medicine. You lack the vision bro, you keep degrading OP's idea as foolish and short sighted rather than thinking outside the box of how it can be polish and became better idea.

---

You don't read well. It was the majority of other posters that saw the OPs idea as shortsighted and foolish. They thought it through well enough to see when and where it would break the game. And even said so quite well.

You on the other hand cannot see that, for al your talk about thinking out of the box you can't go past your 'I want something' and so you don't see what they do. My comments have been that YOU are short sighted and foolish. Not one word of your big talk about how people think has addressed the reasons they gave why it would break the game. But that is because you can't. So you are engaged in this little personal thing attacking guys who would give good reasons against the idea. And I have called you out on it as being like some spoiled little kid that's just mad that he can't have his lollipop.