Printable View
So our clan has people who don't speak English or can't read because there is always someone donating 1 barbarian to clan and spoiling it for everyone. We work hard to get bigger CC ! We have dedicated leadership who fills war bases but this is always ruined by that one useless troop. Leaders should have the access to remove what has been donated to ️war bases. Who else agrees? Thanks.
I agree, good idea.
I've tried to take screenshots of donations when we have started ️️war to see who is doing it but donations don't count on war bases so we can't see who it is. So only option is to boot players one by one. Yeah, that sounds fair... Not.
Sorry disagree with this one - this gives way too much power to the leader, and forces a change a clan member may not wish to be subject to - it is their clan castle and their choice to have what they want in there - clan wars was not developed for clans to become a dictatorship, better communication in the clan and if they can't understand the language in the clan that they are in, it would be time for them to find a clan they can, hiding behind language barriers is no excuse.
good idea i agreed
I disagree with u here. So what about all the other clan members that have to go and remove that one troop and then wait for someone to donate the right troop requested??? No one has ultimate choice what they get donated anyway, you can request a dragon and get 20 barbarians, remove them, then get 4 Giants, and still no dragon. it's up to the people donating what they give, not the person requesting. That's why I proposed this idea to have one person that can help. How much power do leaders have.. Not that much. Wow! leaders can boot players or promote, that's one more than elder. It's not a dictatorship, leaders do everything they can to make sure all clan is achieving and working as a team. So you are saying boot all players who don't speak our language, well we might as well add if you can't read, are too young to understand as well. Really? In our clan there is no discrimination, we are all equal as a team. If we followed your idea there would be 20 questions on a new clan member joining. - Do u speak English, can you read, are you over 10 yrs old, what religion are you, do you smoke, do you shower twice a day? That's what it would end up like if you were going start with the 'language barrier' as you put it. I've used google translate to communicate to members in slovak, malay, indo, etc.. Took me hours but they are good players now and understand the rules. This would help so many clashers get the most fun and benefit. I can't see any possible way a leader can abuse this rite to remove troops from war bases it can only be used to help the clan.Quote:
Originally Posted by ironagedave
If you are getting that many wrong requests in the clan castle then there is something wrong in your clan, this kind of access is like a ♥♥♥♥ in someone elses account. All I am saying is that option too is open to abuse, you have multiple players in a clan who can donate and usually it is your number one or two in your clan because they will have the highest level troops in any case. If your clan is open and equal as you say it is you wouldn't need to post this thread.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sergio246
I understand what u are saying but it's not that many wrong requests, I'll explain. This doesn't happen every time but it's happened when new players have joined. I have a lvl 115 international player who stays up till 1.30am (his time) just to donate dragons to all cc that have 20+ spaces. As soon as war started, someone, (most of time are new players who aren't active till war starts) donates one barbarian to everyone, ruining it for everyone who has 20 spaces for a dragon. Now we have to go through one by one (45-50 players) and wait till players are online to reject that one troop and then hopefully my dragon donator is able to get online and fill their cc. Not sure how you think one person (the leader) can abuse this? What would he/she do? Remove everyone's defence troops for war? Troops in war base CC are for defense only, so it's not like we are taking away from their attack troops??? And like I said we can't see who is donating to war based because war cc donations don't show on their profile clan donations.
Some people give stupid healers or minions or balloons or goblins or wall breakers. WOULD YOU REALLY WANT THOSE IN YOUR CLAN CASTLE FOR WAR??? I mean war people the time to get loot and have fun. It's not a normal attack. One bad donation could cost ur clan the entire war!! the leader should be able to edit clan castle troops for war.
[thomas1234- thomas]
[level 77 th10 farming from crystal 3]
[clan party@7]
[status: leader]
[JOIN]
well I guess im just not that comfortable with one person having too much power, I guess, plus if there was ever a clan falling out and leader went ape, that too could happen, or if they took a break no one else could do this. Perhaps a war general elected for the management of clan wars might resolve this.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sergio246
On a programming note I am not sure how supercell would do this as it would be accesing another persons account which I suppose could be open to h @ ckers to abuse.
*Gets dragon from Clanmate*
*Leader comes and says "trolololololol'*
*Leader removes drag from donations*
*trooperc007 has left the clan*
I disagree just kick out the non America ones
It's not always the non-English speaking ones. Some just like to be disruptive whenever they can.
Today we had a member (English speaking) that donated a bunch of low level troops to our highest clan castles, and then immediately left our clan. Some of those members might not be on CoC before the war starts to remove those troops. So yes, it would be a great feature for the leader, or even co-leaders, to be able to remove those troops.
It would also be nice to have a log of who donated what during clan wars, but that in itself is probably too much data to keep track of.
The leader should have this power. Some players are learning and don't realize they have been donated bad troops, some just refuse to request the proper defensive troops, resulting in getting 3-starred every war. This hurts the whole clan. The leader is in that spot for a reason, he or she is in charge of creating and guiding the clan as a whole. I'm totally in favor of allowing leader to delete troops.
Too much power? A single troll in your clan can anonymously ruin the war map CC of every player in their clan. Did I mention that they can do it anonymously? As in, without fear of being caught? Without any recourse for the leader to figure out who did it and stop them?Quote:
Originally Posted by ironagedave
Accessing someone's account? Abuse? The CC in the war map is a copy of the CC at the time the war is started. In fact, if your CC upgrades during the prep day, you can't use the extra 5 troop space. The war CC is no longer connected to the person's account. The only potential issue I can think of is that a leader could be trying to remove troops at the same time as the player, because 2 players would have access to it at the same time. Not sure what a simple fix for that might be. (Not saying there isn't one.)
Sounds like Communism. I disagree with this idea.
Why not just remove the troops by yourself? Also lots of troll leaders anyways.
I agree with Sergio hes right your wrong the endQuote:
Originally Posted by Sergio246