More Time in Clan Wars

Printable View

February 11th, 2015
Jordun

More Time in Clan Wars

This is a need. I have seen multiple clan members using GoWipe (maxed troops for TH8) or dragons (Maxed troops for TH8) against decent TH8's. They execute the attacks very well but sometimes are not able to complete the attacks with 1 or to seconds to spare (or more). This is normally because of base spread. This makes it very difficult for people to three star because they are now fighting the clock more than they are the enemy.

Allowing us to have an appropriate amount of time (30 extra seconds) to complete our attacks is something that will not only create a more fair clan environment, but will allow us as users to reach our full potential and a more exciting gameplay for all!

-Jordun
February 11th, 2015
TheGreatDavis68

3 minutes is plenty of time to 3 star a base
February 11th, 2015
Jordun

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheGreatDavis68

3 minutes is plenty of time to 3 star a base

Apparently not. You probably attack people lower than you.
February 11th, 2015
Sirix

When I was TH8, time was hardly a factor. If it is, it means that you're not using your troops efficiently enough so that there's too little survivors for clean up

Besides, why should war get more time when you already get plenty of planning time? If it's hard to 3 star in war, then it'll be harder to 3 star in normal raids when you can't even prepare an army for a certain base
February 11th, 2015
mtommy2597

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

Apparently not. You probably attack people lower than you.

Near Max TH9 here. It usually comes down to troops left. 3 minutes is fine
February 11th, 2015
Jordun

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirix

When I was TH8, time was hardly a factor. If it is, it means that you're not using your troops efficiently enough so that there's too little survivors for clean up

Besides, why should war get more time when you already get plenty of planning time? If it's hard to 3 star in war, then it'll be harder to 3 star in normal raids when you can't even prepare an army for a certain base

You probably attack lower than you; we don't, you get kicked for that here.

Let's take into consideration that we're extremely skilled TH8's using maxed troops and perfect strategies. Stratigies/troops/skills, it's not a factor.

If you are TH7 or lower or attack lower than yourself; don't bother posting, please. :o
February 11th, 2015
Spurs978

If you are extremely skilled then you can find a way to make it work within the time constraints.
February 11th, 2015
Jordun

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spurs978

If you are extremely skilled then you can find a way to make it work within the time constraints.

Nah dude I just said I couldn't...
February 11th, 2015
Slaskio

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

You probably attack lower than you; we don't, you get kicked for that here.

Let's take into consideration that we're extremely skilled TH8's using maxed troops and perfect strategies. Stratigies/troops/skills, it's not a factor.

Troop speed is the key factor here. If youre using all drags or using a bunch of slow moving pekkas then you should be saving some archers/barbs/gobs/minis something else for clean up. 3 minutes is definitely plenty of time to 3 star a base.
February 11th, 2015
mtommy2597

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

You probably attack lower than you; we don't, you get kicked for that here.

Let's take into consideration that we're extremely skilled TH8's using maxed troops and perfect strategies. Stratigies/troops/skills, it's not a factor.

No strategy is quite truly "perfect", and you should be a bit more respectful to the people taking time to give feedback.

Anyway, How much extra time were you thinking? Hog riders can decimate a base rather quickly. If you use full spells and drop them properly, you should be able to 3 star. Maybe you're just not as great as you think you are.
February 11th, 2015
Spurs978

I believe a 4 star war system is a better solution to this so that those who can three star in the given time are rewarded but it does recognize those in between that consistently get above 75% and fail to get the three
February 11th, 2015
Jordun

Quote:

Originally Posted by mtommy2597

No strategy is quite truly "perfect", and you should be a bit more respectful to the people taking time to give feedback.

Anyway, How much extra time were you thinking? Hog riders can decimate a base rather quickly. If you use full spells and drop them properly, you should be able to 3 star. Maybe you're just not as great as you think you are.

If you're going to give feedback make it worthwhile. Don't just say "no because you are bad do better k? "

Nah be like I attack people my same skill level and I always every single time make it work without having time errors.
February 11th, 2015
Sirix

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

You probably attack lower than you; we don't, you get kicked for that here.

Let's take into consideration that we're extremely skilled TH8's using maxed troops and perfect strategies. Stratigies/troops/skills, it's not a factor.

I like how the default reaction is "if you can 3 star, it must have been someone lower than you"

When I was TH8, I attacked TH8/9. Bad layouts makes it easier, but it's very easy to 3 star mid TH8 with those max dragons that you're talking about. Maxed TH8 aren't impossible either and there's a lot of videos to teach you how to do that online... in case you want to see what other people can do rather, rather than just disregarding the other side

Edit: Here's a video for you. It was the first one I found and the TH8 3 starred a nearly maxed TH8
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QYU7SWJO5tg

Here's another video since you were talking about spreaded base
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nJ5g7Zka4_c

Spreaded base makes it easier for HoLoWiWi too
February 11th, 2015
mtommy2597

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spurs978

I believe a 4 star war system is a better solution to this so that those who can three star in the given time are rewarded but it does recognize those in between that consistently get above 75% and fail to get the three

Or maybe a five star war system to recognize those who dont finish but get above 80 percent
February 11th, 2015
Jordun

Why would it be bad to have 30 seconds more?
February 11th, 2015
mtommy2597

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

If you're going to give feedback make it worthwhile. Don't just say "no because you are bad do better k? "

Nah be like I attack people my same skill level and I always every single time make it work without having time errors.

There is no time error and what makes you think i attack people lower than me? I attack people who are my level.

And maybe post a vid of one of your flawless attacks so you can make a valid point
February 11th, 2015
Spurs978

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

Why would it be bad to have 30 seconds more?

It seperates the elite from the good and as I said above a new star system for war would be better and you can use the search function to find threads about this
February 11th, 2015
mtommy2597

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

Why would it be bad to have 30 seconds more?

We don't need 30 seconds more
February 11th, 2015
Jordun

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirix

I like how the default reaction is "if you can 3 star, it must have been someone lower than you"

When I was TH8, I attacked TH8/9. Bad layouts makes it easier, but it's very easy to 3 star mid TH8 with those max dragons that you're talking about. Maxed TH8 aren't impossible either and there's a lot of videos to teach you how to do that online... in case you want to see what other people can do rather, rather than just disregarding the other side

I know the other side I get 3 stars too buddy. Not looking for why I'm bad, looking for why having extra time is bad.
February 11th, 2015
Spurs978

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

I know the other side I get 3 stars too buddy. Not looking for why I'm bad, looking for why having extra time is bad.

We have told you why it is bad. Elite raiders can three star within the given time and this seperates the elite from the average
February 11th, 2015
Jordun

Quote:

Originally Posted by mtommy2597

We don't need 30 seconds more

I'm pretty sure we do? Why wouldn't we need it?

I guess I don't understand like if they rolled out that update someone would be like "crud not extra time to attack.... 30 SECONDS, THATS OUTRAGEOUS".
February 11th, 2015
mtommy2597

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

I'm pretty sure we do? Why wouldn't we need it?

I guess I don't understand like if they rolled out that update someone would be like "crud not extra time to attack.... 30 SECONDS, THATS OUTRAGEOUS".

If we needed it, someone experienced would've posted the idea by now
February 11th, 2015
Jordun

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spurs978

We have told you why it is bad. Elite raiders can three star within the given time and this seperates the elite from the average

So I'm elite most of the time, but some times I'm one second away from being elite?
February 11th, 2015
Spurs978

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

So I'm elite most of the time, but some times I'm one second away from being elite?

True statement. And as I said before there would be better solutions such as a new star system....
February 11th, 2015
mtommy2597

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

So I'm elite most of the time, but some times I'm one second away from being elite?

Ooooh lol this guy lost a star because of 1 second. Maybe you should've done a better attack
February 11th, 2015
Jordun

Quote:

Originally Posted by mtommy2597

If we needed it, someone experienced would've posted the idea by now

I'm a maxed TH8 after 125 days of playing on this device. I'm doing something right. I think I'm experienced.
February 11th, 2015
mtommy2597

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordun

I'm a maxed TH8 after 125 days of playing on this device. I'm doing something right. I think I'm experienced.

I'm a near max Th9, All i have left is walls,valks and heroes and I've never thought that this was necessary in my 591 days of playing
February 11th, 2015
Spurs978

If they increased the time then someone would get a 99percent raid then complain about the time. I think the time they have now has a good balance
February 11th, 2015
Jladams

I speak from being in the position as you are; I am a maxed TH8 with max troops for my TH. I admit there have been times I have ran out of time in order for the 3 star, especially when I'm using GoWiPe. However, I am not going to complain that its not fair with only 3 minutes. Of course the bases are harder than those in raids because its war, in war you bring your best and sometimes you hold and sometimes you don't. I am confident that another TH8 can't 3 star my base within the given 3 minutes so why isn't it fair If occasionally I can't 3 star one of my enemies. Its perfectly fair since the enemy has the same time frame and if they 3 star you, maybe consider changing your base so you don't get 3 stared by someone of your same status. As for being attacked by someone higher than you, there's nothing you can do about that. So unless someone can create a more valid argument for why more time is needed or why 3 minutes isn't fair, than I stick by my statement that 3 minutes is fine, even if I occasionally can't 3 star a base because that means they occasionally can't 3 star mine.

All times are GMT. The time now is 04:03 AM.