WHAT IF..Revenge was available, regardless of a Shield but,...

But the available swag was a function of how much you had when you initially lost your TH / When the latest shield went up?

Basically this requires the design of one good formula which would define the amount of G/E/DE available for plunder via Revenge

In brief if you had just 1 million gold and your TH was left out for easy pickings (losing 1000 Gold only),.. People whom you had raided previously (who had you as an available AngryNeesom52) could still raid you for everything else - Your TH would be back & need destroying, but you would not get that 1000 gold ..

This clearly needs some fine tuning ... Ideas? Suggestions?

I would have to respectfully say 'no'. That idea would cause too much protest among players.

Any kind of attack under the shield would be disheartening to players. Given the number of attacks a player does, the list of possible revenge attacks would be too huge to manage. You could easily be looted dry, depending on league, from so many people attacking back.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

I would have to respectfully say 'no'. That idea would cause too much protest among players.

Any kind of attack under the shield would be disheartening to players. Given the number of attacks a player does, the list of possible revenge attacks would be too huge to manage. You could easily be looted dry, depending on league, from so many people attacking back.

---

I have and idea how about loot from revenge comes from supercell like war we can scout and etc
but player need to pay 1/5 of avaible resources so if player lose he loss more than before
so only revenge guy u know u can win

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AlvinSoehendryWijaya

I have and idea how about loot from revenge comes from supercell like war we can scout and etc
but player need to pay 1/5 of avaible resources so if player lose he loss more than before
so only revenge guy u know u can win

---

I've made two threads already on trying to solve the revenge issue. One of them is along those lines.
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...evenge-attacks (Earliest one that has sunk already from spam)
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...stem-Revamp%21 (Another asking for help on details for a mirrored base that can be attacked)

Obviously super popular and awesome ideas that everyone supports.
Italicize text hinting at sarcasm.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

I would have to respectfully say 'no'. That idea would cause too much protest among players.

Any kind of attack under the shield would be disheartening to players. Given the number of attacks a player does, the list of possible revenge attacks would be too huge to manage. You could easily be looted dry, depending on league, from so many people attacking back.

---

What about those (of which I am one) who attack with impunity, and simply leave their TH outside for any low level attacker to give them a 12 hr shield?

Again, one palatable code segment (bearing in mind that ya can't please em all) which would reasonably promote revenge, and mitigate MY incentive to leave my TH outside my walls?

If a lot more of your loot was available to be pillaged from the TH... I'd be more likely to keep it where it should be.. safely inside the walls

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shmegler

What about those (of which I am one) who attack with impunity, and simply leave their TH outside for any low level attacker to give them a 12 hr shield?

Again, one palatable code segment (bearing in mind that ya can't please em all) which would reasonably promote revenge, and mitigate MY incentive to leave my TH outside my walls?

---

I personally still get my revenge attack on people with farming bases, it is only a matter of time. Most of my revenge attacks are actually against farmer bases, many of them likely hating the fact they attacked me, if they remember days later (longest time10 days later). The only attack you would like me to have on your base is if you were lucky enough to do a trophy drop 'attack' with one unit. I can't just raid or zap a base if all they are doing is giving away trophies! So to remove them from the list, I TH snipe them, since that's what they wanted anyway, a shield and less trophies.

Again, you don't attack with total impunity. Someone can still get to you. :D

It will take more than some simple code change to stop people from using farming bases, while not causing a mass quiting spree of players. So you guys are safe for now. Supercell would have done something by now if they had a plan they felt as though could work with a high degree of success.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

I've made two threads already on trying to solve the revenge issue. One of them is along those lines.
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...evenge-attacks (Earliest one that has sunk already from spam)
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...stem-Revamp%21 (Another asking for help on details for a mirrored base that can be attacked)

Obviously super popular and awesome ideas that everyone supports.
Italicize text hinting at sarcasm.

---

Perfect time for this quote

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by prancingpony

Happens to all the good ideas. The bad ones float because everyone loves to rip on the OP, good ones sink because people don't know how to comment positively.

---

Pretty much. If you want to help with half of that problem, report Ruled-out idea threads so mods can nip them in the bud.