WHAT IF..Revenge was available, regardless of a Shield but,...
But the available swag was a function of how much you had when you initially lost your TH / When the latest shield went up?
Basically this requires the design of one good formula which would define the amount of G/E/DE available for plunder via Revenge
In brief if you had just 1 million gold and your TH was left out for easy pickings (losing 1000 Gold only),.. People whom you had raided previously (who had you as an available AngryNeesom52) could still raid you for everything else - Your TH would be back & need destroying, but you would not get that 1000 gold ..
This clearly needs some fine tuning ... Ideas? Suggestions?
And / Or.. have your TH hold 50% of your treasure?.. (G/E/DE)
If a lot more of your loot was available to be pillaged from the TH... I'd be more likely to keep it where it should be.. safely inside the walls