community clan loot

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mARCSBUG

I don't understand your point? Alt joins clan where primary sits, primary donates higher strength troops to alt, Alt proceeds to smash bases. This is already happening in Clash.

Software is exploitable by nature as well.

It makes no difference to the game if we're allowed to donate resources to other players/accounts but it does to SuperCells' revenue model.

---

Actually, alts boost the main. That's how it is up in the high trophy ranges, and that's how it will be if this idea gets put in.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wooman

I'd like to see a community clan pot... where members can donate if they wish to a community loot and elixir pot. Then other clan members can take out certain amounts of loot. amounts could be limited based on level, member, elder, co, leader or trophies. There could be a time frame of when you can take loot. I understand there is a war win bonus... but think this would be cool aspect of the game on the farming side. Give the clan the ability to set it up as they wish to customize as they see fit.

Also, new members would not be able to receive this until after a certain point while in the clan, so they don't clan jump from clan to clan stealing loot.

---

I think the clan pot shouldn't be for resources. It should be for troops. Resources would be nice, but it's not realistic to think the game developers would let gold and elixir, which are monetized, to be traded freely. But if the clan pot were for troops it would help international clans where people are in different time zones to contribute to each other.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ataraxia

No one will leave to keep. It's just that no one will donate, and the second that it does, it will be snapped up by another member, maybe even a member they didn't want the resources to go to.

Also, if you have ten other accounts other than your main, all with max collectors and mines, that's a lot of free gold and elixir per day. That's pretty exploitable.

---

I can see your point if you clan has high volume inflow/outflow of members and definitely makes sense, I doubt the longer lasting clans will have the same problem 'and if they do it would be immaterial'.

Doesn't your second point prove mine? Having access to large volume resources allows you to wall/upgrade quicker, hence decrease the possibility of purchasing gems for resources?

I think the same applies to increased builder speed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mARCSBUG

I don't understand your point? Alt joins clan where primary sits, primary donates higher strength troops to alt, Alt proceeds to smash bases. This is already happening in Clash.
*sigh*
Think of a clan with a main account and at least one alt account. Main account puts a huge loot on the community chest. Alt account takes lots of loot without breaking a sweat. Get my point now, buddy?

If you don't got this, you're a sad little guy.


Software is exploitable by nature as well.

Your point about this on the OP is?

It makes no difference to the game if we're allowed to donate resources to other players/accounts but it does to SuperCells' revenue model.

It will make a LOT of difference. We're already pointing out possible things that will happen if this gets added to the game.

---

Replies in bold characters.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bsigua

I think the clan pot shouldn't be for resources. It should be for troops. Resources would be nice, but it's not realistic to think the game developers would let gold and elixir, which are monetized, to be traded freely. But if the clan pot were for troops it would help international clans where people are in different time zones to contribute to each other.

---

Troops are fine tho IMHO...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mARCSBUG

I can see your point if you clan has high volume inflow/outflow of members and definitely makes sense, I doubt the longer lasting clans will have the same problem 'and if they do it would be immaterial'.

Doesn't your second point prove mine? Having access to large volume resources allows you to wall/upgrade quicker, hence decrease the possibility of purchasing gems for resources?

I think the same applies to increased builder speed.

---

I agree with your first point. Glad we agree.:)

Ah. My bad. I was only addressing your first point, and nothing else. I agree with your logic, though.

And I agree with this point, as well.

HydroPenguin, I suggest you read my posts again and understand them before you reply 'if you can't comprehend them it would be fair to state that the sad little guy is you my friend'.

Obviously the point of sharing resources is to make it easier for any account to upgrade, I am simply stating that:

• It will enable any base to upgrade faster and decrease the amount of spent resources
• SuperCell will lose revenue due to people not geming for resources

Have you considered the positives? There is always going to be people dropping out of the game so if these bases have higher level collectors everyone benefits. A benefit also arises for everyone if there are more bases out there with a higher level collectors/more resources available.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mARCSBUG

HydroPenguin, I suggest you read my posts again and understand them before you reply 'if you can't comprehend them it would be fair to state that the sad little guy is you my friend'.

I don't pay much attention on other post. Sorry about that :3

Obviously the point of sharing resources is to make it easier for any account to upgrade, I am simply stating that:

• It will enable any base to upgrade faster and decrease the amount of spent resources
• SuperCell will lose revenue due to people not geming for resources

This.
If you put it this way, it doesn't sound like 'exploiting'. But people will find horrible benefits for this feature, like what I as saying before that it will be an exploit. It this get added to the game, the result is everybody is on TH7 on a month, leaving TH4 players with nothing to raid for their level as other players already advanced, being unfair for those lower players.

And yeah... Supercell will most likely not add this because they'll lose revenue.


Have you considered the positives?

nah... Better criticise stuff beforehand before it gets added to make sure the game is kept enjoyable.

There is always going to be people dropping out of the game so if these bases have higher level collectors everyone benefits.

A game should have disadvantages for players. If players can get loot 'that' easily, they won't feel rewarded. Then, they'll get bored and eventually quit the game.

A benefit also arises for everyone if there are more bases out there with a higher level collectors/more resources available.

---

*sigh* It's hard to not have English as a native language. -_-

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HydroPenguin

*sigh* It's hard to not have English as a native language. -_-

---

English isnt your native language wow I never would have thought that (that isnt sarcasm I actually am suprised)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HydroPenguin

*sigh* It's hard to not have English as a native language. -_-

---

My friend your English is very good, please don't criticize it, especially since its a second language :)