Clans: Reject Message

Printable View

February 4th, 2015
Jyrik

Clans: Reject Message

I'm in a clan, and an old clanmate requests to join. The clan was full though with no kick candidates. So in order to tell our old friend to request to join back when we had a slot open; I had to leave and they accepted him. They then kicked him with a message as to why they couldn't accept him. In my opinion; instead of going through all of that, you should be able to send a message as why their request was rejected. So basically you click reject and it allows to you type a message as to why they were rejected.

Thanks,

jyrik
February 4th, 2015
trooperc007

This would create abuse problems.
Example:

Co leader: *Clicks on reject and types "Sorry, we rejected because you are a (insert word choice here)*

Member: *Calls Supercell and boring stuff which I don't need to say happens.*
February 4th, 2015
rwelshjr

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jyrik

I'm in a clan, and an old clanmate requests to join. The clan was full though with no kick candidates. So in order to tell our old friend to request to join back when we had a slot open; I had to leave and they accepted him. They then kicked him with a message as to why they couldn't accept him. In my opinion; instead of going through all of that, you should be able to send a message as why their request was rejected. So basically you click reject and it allows to you type a message as to why they were rejected.

Thanks,

jyrik

What you describe would a classy, kind, and considerate use of such a feature. The problem is all the people that would use it to be nasty. Unfortunately the punk/brat segment would use it heavily this way so its better in the big picture if they not have the channel to do that.
February 4th, 2015
FireThief

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jyrik

I'm in a clan, and an old clanmate requests to join. The clan was full though with no kick candidates. So in order to tell our old friend to request to join back when we had a slot open; I had to leave and they accepted him. They then kicked him with a message as to why they couldn't accept him. In my opinion; instead of going through all of that, you should be able to send a message as why their request was rejected. So basically you click reject and it allows to you type a message as to why they were rejected.

Thanks,

jyrik

Clan Related:
*Add other clan requirements to apply besides trophies, ex: Specific troop lvl, TH lvl, lab lvl, game lvl
*Customizable clan flag
*Add ability to send short message to rejected applicants similar to when expelling

Hey there!

Unfortunately this idea is ruled out and will not be added to the game. :( Sorry pal- in the future please remember to read this sticky before posting ideas:

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines

Thanks! And cya around the forums!:cool:
February 4th, 2015
Jwp721

Quote:

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

What you describe would a classy, kind, and considerate use of such a feature. The problem is all the people that would use it to be nasty. Unfortunately the punk/brat segment would use it heavily this way so its better in the big picture if they not have the channel to do that.

Whats the difference between the OP's idea and the current ability to leave a comment when you kick someone out of your clan? Classy or not doesn't depend upon on what you can do.
February 4th, 2015
BattleBorn007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jwp721

Whats the difference between the OP's idea and the current ability to leave a comment when you kick someone out of your clan? Classy or not doesn't depend upon on what you can do.

I think its due to quantity more people get rejected from clans on average than get kicked I believe, if this is true than that would mean it would be more than double the chances of inappropriate language.
February 4th, 2015
Jwp721

Quote:

Originally Posted by BattleBorn007

I think its due to quantity more people get rejected from clans on average than get kicked I believe, if this is true than that would mean it would be more than double the chances of inappropriate language.

i don't think frequency determines if a person is going to behave in a classy manner or not either.
February 4th, 2015
BattleBorn007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jwp721

i don't think frequency determines if a person is going to behave in a classy manner or not either.

However it increases the chances of it...nonetheless not like it matters SC ruled it out already
February 4th, 2015
Jwp721

Quote:

Originally Posted by BattleBorn007

However it increases the chances of it...nonetheless not like it matters SC ruled it out already

Did SC rule it out or did this forum? So many times I think this forum is simply a place to say all ideas are ruled out. lol.

Like the OP I have found a solution. Accept someone, kick them out and then explain why. We do this all the time during wars as we don't add new members then , but if someone is willing to come back in 2 days they are welcome to join.
February 4th, 2015
FireThief

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jwp721

Did SC rule it out or did this forum? So many times I think this forum is simply a place to say all ideas are ruled out. lol.

Like the OP I have found a solution. Accept someone, kick them out and then explain why. We do this all the time during wars as we don't add new members then , but if someone is willing to come back in 2 days they are welcome to join.

The giants of Super Cell did mi amigo.

This sticky: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines :rolleyes:
February 4th, 2015
webbie

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jwp721

Did SC rule it out or did this forum? So many times I think this forum is simply a place to say all ideas are ruled out. lol.

Like the OP I have found a solution. Accept someone, kick them out and then explain why. We do this all the time during wars as we don't add new members then , but if someone is willing to come back in 2 days they are welcome to join.

Be careful doing this. There is another thread that said once accepted if they manage to get into one war base they can scroll through all of them using the arrows even after being booted. They may not see the cc's but they can see all the bases even if they are only in the clan for 10 seconds.
February 4th, 2015
BattleBorn007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jwp721

Did SC rule it out or did this forum? So many times I think this forum is simply a place to say all ideas are ruled out. lol.

Like the OP I have found a solution. Accept someone, kick them out and then explain why. We do this all the time during wars as we don't add new members then , but if someone is willing to come back in 2 days they are welcome to join.

If I say its ruled out It most likely is I dont lie about those things lol
Ruled Out ideas can be found here make sure its Under Ruled Out (Toward the bottom of the page)
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines
Clan Related:
*Add other clan requirements to apply besides trophies, ex: Specific troop lvl, TH lvl, lab lvl, game lvl
*Customizable clan flag
*Add ability to send short message to rejected applicants similar to when expelling
*A large text area for clan rules that just the clan can see (separate from public clan description)
*Leader (and co-leaders) ability to delete messages in chat
*Modify clan msg of player joining with who invited player: xx joined clan, invited by xx
*Add clan rank to Clan Info Screen – Quicker to reference than scrolling to end of top 200 list
*Increase clan size: 75 or 100 are most common requests
* Separate Elder+ chat tab in-game
February 4th, 2015
NF2335

It ruled out.
The only way this could work, if the reject message was chosen from an option of message. (e.g. "Your level is too low, sorry" or "Our clan is full, try again when there's space").