I don't understand why the troops you create do not protect their camps and the city when under attack. Where do they go?
Printable View
I don't understand why the troops you create do not protect their camps and the city when under attack. Where do they go?
Then you have even less change to win enemies which are in the higher levels :D
Madt only troops you have stored in your clan castle help on defence, the others do not. This is so attacking is possible, imagine attacking someone with 100 archers if they had 100 archers in their camps already plus their normal defences, it would be impossible
any troops in camps do not appear when they are attacking. all troops in camps die if the camp is destroyed. the only units that can protect you are the one's in clan castle.
Oh I get how it works and I get attacking would be harder but not impossible. Technically they should be a part of your defense if you created them you should be able to use them that's all I'm saying
It's fine that they don't help defense, otherwise it makes winning battles not possible.
But...... can it be changed so that the army will stay alive even the camps are destroyed?? Since they are all on vacation when someone come to attack your city...
Its quite annoying after someone attack you, then you have to rebuild the army.
(well.... the fun part is I used to revenge people who attacked me by just sending few archers to destroy their camps so to just kill their army....especially if they are way higher level than me..... especially if they attack me with full balloons...lol.....so this kind revenge is the best I can do for fun, waste their time)
at the top tiers, attacking is already hard, you are usually lucky to get 1 star, with this change it would be impossibleQuote:
Originally Posted by MadT
The troops in the army camps are not on "vacation". When attacked, they're surprised and unprepared. They're offensive troops (who sleep when they're home), not defensive ones (who are always ready).
We know what you are saying, but you apparently do not know what we are saying. Attacking would not simply be harder it would be impossible. How exactly would you launch a successful attack if they have the same number of troops as you but you have to deal with the defensive buildings as well as blowing other ♥♥♥♥ up?Quote:
Originally Posted by MadT
Go on, explain this. We'll wait.
I can agree it would make it tougher but if they don't defend them they shouldn't die. Don't get me wrong. I'd a p2w harasses me or a higher level I have no chance to beat (not that it really impacts them) I tend to send a few troops to take out their expensive/time consuming troops just to annoy and give a little pain and make them either wait or shift their strategy.
Quote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
Fwiw if they die they don't get replaced so are weaker fir the next fight. Maybe the number that defend could be a percentage or be a handicap for matches where the lower lv defender would be allowed some troops to defend. Another idea would be to allow unclanned players to stock their own castles. Maybe if you stock your own castle you have to pay extra elixer or gold. Either way there are good and bad sides to this. I can understand both. Remember not everyone can spend 2-3 hours on a "marathon" some are casual players. You know the ones with resources to take. The power players are on all the time and spend every bit before logging off for 10 minutes.
You know what people would say then? The same exact thing they say about bombs and clan troops. That on a successful defense everything should be replenished. Look at the double dip thread.Quote:
Originally Posted by Knall
I'm not opposed to the idea of populating your own clan castle, but you might as well just join a clan.
Would love to. In fact when I was I donates the best troops I could fairly often. Problem is they get careless with elders and setting limits that they don't hold their existing members to. Both those are important to me. Not found a single one that is consistent and responsible. When I do I am all in.Quote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
Start your own clan and then you can run it in any way you see fit. Alternatively, just relax.Quote:
Originally Posted by Knall
In my clan invites are totally open. Everyone gets elder status. I initially started to set trophy limits but gave up on that when I realized that the trophy system is currently broken. Now we just chat, talk strategy, and donate troops to each other.
Try not to take it so seriously.
The problem about everyone being an elder is all the clans the ended up broken because someone got upset and dumped everyone or whatever else they could do to cause trouble. But yea. I am not too interested in starting my own and just want to shoot the breeze and help one another. As it should be. Then again I am a casual player so don't care about being in the top clan. Everyone having a good time is way more important to me. So yea we are on the same page there. As far as my empty castle. I pretty much forget about it. It's simply another obstacle I can use to help defend my resources. It's just interesting to see how others think about it. Speaking of which. For those in a clan it would be cool if they could determine what they wanted in the castle instead of getting something useless(for their needs) wasting space for what they could have gotten elsewhere. Or even ability to pull from castle to your own troops. Not sure if that could/would be abused though.
That's beauty of making everyone an elder. Elders can't kick each other.Quote:
Originally Posted by Knall
Haha. That I didn't know. At least there is that. So I guess that is something to consider a bonus when looking at clans.Quote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
I get what you are saying and it does make sense I had not looked at it from the higher up levels, I do see where the delima would play in. It's still freaking annoying
yeah the downside though is the Leader then has to be on a lot more as no one else can manage (i.e. boot) anyone else.
Back on topic I agree it's tough troops in the camps die but as sneaky said it would be impossible to win anything at the higher levels if the camp you attacked had the same number of troops as you are attacking with. This would mean we would just have to attack low level 1 cups more often which no one wants.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Knall
:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes: :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes: :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes: :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes: :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes: :rolleyes:
Someone ban this fool!
Its 2012 post day!:rolleyes: LOL
I love the game but...people who bump ancient threads are annoying.Quote:
Originally Posted by Nezumi
I love this game but....I think old threads are awesome!
What if someone had all wallbreakers in their camps 😂😂😂Quote:
Originally Posted by Sneakydave
Imagine all drags...I would cry 😭😭😭😭
If i lost them i would revenge SO hard😆