How is that possible ?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by icey567

Your sure it's Chinese mate? I'm at a school of about 700 kids, and I only know of two Chinese natives that play CoC. And they're pretty bad.

---

Aw cmon dude lol, just because you know two chinese players that are as you say bade, doesnt mean the other chinese clashers are bad too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Daddy

Nope, Maybach in my clan got 2,500 wins the season before last - and he's not a bot.

---

It's more at the troop receives I think Daddy. Unless there is some serious gemming of requests, something fishy is going on.
We already know there is some funny business going on with clans with ridiculous numbers. Stevo even excluded them from the top requests record.
The highest currently is 21k in the full 4 days. He is at 16k after half a season. I don't want to point the finger, as everyone should get the benefit of the doubt. But it's worth looking in to.
Thats my 2 cents. I don't wanna be in infraction land.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Daddy

Guys, the only thing that suggests this is not normal is the fact he has a moderately high attacks won number, as mentioned above he might have boosted before the OP noticed.

This is at the end of the season so it is 2 weeks worth, he is at a cup level where there are a lot of exposed THs he may be sniping for the loot bonus small as it is, he has a lot of donations given and received so he is active.

I see no evidence whatsoever that this person has done anything wrong.

25k snipes is the record, i've seen for my own eyes 2,500 farming wins, why would 1089 wins be anything strange?

If the guy is doing something wrong why would he bother being in war?

---

Makes sens what you are saying !

On the other hand could it be explained the fact that they knew where all the traps were and most of them lured them before attacking ?

And we are talking about wide bases not the regular compact base where everyone can guess where the giant bombs are.

One of our clan mates has his giant bombs on the outside of the base where everything is widely spread.. impossible to guess.. And the attacker knew exactly where they were and lured them all precisely ..

Im just curious if there is anyone possible explanation to that.

I've had a pretty unhealthy (high) number of attacks won in the past. Not a high as this but bare in mind I had a job and a life. It's perfectly conceivable that, without either of those 'distractions', someone could farm and snipe to those numbers in 6 days. His troops received aren't abnormal for someone in an active clan.

This is turning into a bit of a witch hunt.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gama321

Whats getting out of hand is the blind accusations by people who dont know anything acting like they do. Once that number passes the record of 25000 attacks a season you may be onto something, but it would be a new record holder, not a bot.

---

25k is the record by Brandon

Ignore the record of 25,000.

That was a person, for one season only, trying to set a record number of wins, and creating the right environment to do it.

As in, going to bronze and dropping monster heroes for a win in seconds.

No, we should not be so quick to point the finger, but until SC actually make a genuine effort to detect exploits, we have little choice.

Forgive the cynicism, but the 1000s of att per day players of a dubious nature, have perma-boosted barracks.
That may have something to do with the reluctance to tackle the issue.

I do find it genuinely amazing that a billion dollar industry cannot in any way detect any kind of wrongdoing themselves, and must rely on reports.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Daddy

Guys, the only thing that suggests this is not normal is the fact he has a moderately high attacks won number, as mentioned above he might have boosted before the OP noticed.

This is at the end of the season so it is 2 weeks worth, he is at a cup level where there are a lot of exposed THs he may be sniping for the loot bonus small as it is, he has a lot of donations given and received so he is active.

I see no evidence whatsoever that this person has done anything wrong.

25k snipes is the record, i've seen for my own eyes 2,500 farming wins, why would 1089 wins be anything strange?

If the guy is doing something wrong why would he bother being in war?

---

Im not sure if you didnt notice or your being ignorat the OP said this was 8 days into the league not the end and he also stated that the war attacks were premeditated as in they new hidden building locations please tell me you just didnt realize that he said that otherwise your a terrible supercell representative

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Daddy

Guys, the only thing that suggests this is not normal is the fact he has a moderately high attacks won number, as mentioned above he might have boosted before the OP noticed.

This is at the end of the season so it is 2 weeks worth, he is at a cup level where there are a lot of exposed THs he may be sniping for the loot bonus small as it is, he has a lot of donations given and received so he is active.

I see no evidence whatsoever that this person has done anything wrong.

25k snipes is the record, i've seen for my own eyes 2,500 farming wins, why would 1089 wins be anything strange?

If the guy is doing something wrong why would he bother being in war?

---

I won't argue that it's not human possible, but I will say that it's super suspicious.

First, the 25k snipe win/season record mean nothing. It's one time record, from one guy. It's not what everyone does every season. Yes, it proved that a person can do it. But it doesn't mean everyone can do it all the time.

Second, all bot I've ever know end up to around 1k2-2k attack win per season.

Third, since bot appears in coc, the number of people get more than 1k2 win per season suddenly increase.

Four, look at the cup range. It's all about Gold I-Gold III. It's where TH8 and TH9 stays. If he snipe, what's his purpose? Why doesn't his cup increase? The loot bonus in Gold I- Gold III is way too low to benefit from sniping. To be able to constantly sniping, he must drop his cup sometime to stay in Gold I- Gold III. The question become, why? There is no benefit of sniping then drop your cup. If he goes on to break the 25k attack win record, I would understand. But suddenly, everyone try to get a lot of win per season, but always end up at 1k2-2k win, then we have a problem.

Yet, you are right. There is no prove just from the stats. As long as they can agrue that it's human possible, and the just want to "kill time" and "I do it because I can", there is nothing we can do.

@OP and everyone think it's bot: Give it up. It's an argument that you can't win. Trust me. I tried. As long as it's human possible, then there is nothing you can say to prove it's a bot. Brian made 25k win per season. What he did is constantly sniping, and constantly drop trophy count. He did it just for the record. But people keep bring it out as a prove: 1k, 2k win per season is nothing. All we can do is asking: what's the motive to get 1k, 2k win per season in Gold I-III that suddenly everyone does that. Well, because they can, I guess. So... let it go...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by THEBANDIT240

I doubt even a bot would get that many attacks and based on his donate stats he probs just an extremely active player who either gems his troops outright (instead of boosting) or is using royals to snipe THs

---

How could an incredibly active player donate more than a bot?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lifeontwo

exactly what I thought ..

The clan we are at war with now have the same similar stats..

And they Always knew where the traps and teslas are in our very wide bases judging by their EVERY attack..
They would lure traps.. This can not be a coincidence on EVERY attack.

We have been playing for almost two years and we war non stop.. Were not noobs who complain about loot or troops..

But this is getting out of hand.. We are getting more and more of these and mostly Chinese clans.

This is really unfair and kills the whole point of the game.

Cant supercell do something about this ??

---

Uh oh, that's a red flag there if they have insane attack counts as well. I've seen that some of the shady software out there includes a button where you can basically disconnect from the server to practice attack in wars with no consequences.