Printable View
Greetings
I think it's going to be better,if you could choose what kind of skeletons,the witch can resurrect.. ground or air,just like the skeleton trap does. This way Town Hall 7 can finally have a chance against full dragons,or you could prepare for an air attack,where enemies uses other good air strategies,like Lavaloonion...
Thanks
Th7s cant make witches first, secondly giving th7 anyway to defend against LavaLoonion (a th9+ attack) then that is to OP and no offense just stupid.Quote:
Originally Posted by LudogoretsRazgrad
So overall no bad idea
Have you even read what I wrote? TH 7 CAN'T make witch,but someone CAN donate it,in his clan castle..also I never said someone will attack a th7 base,with a defending witch,reviving air skeletons,with LavaLoonion...firstly no,one will waste his army to attack th7.. the witch can still be put in a TH8,9 and 10 bases,to defend against Lavaloonion.Quote:
Originally Posted by BattleBorn007
The request is - Update the Witch,so she can revive air skeletons,instead of ground,holding themselfs in a balloon just like the air skeleton traps,and NO,NOT replace the ground skeletons for air,but make it selectable which you want your witch to revive. I don't see where is this OP.. It will be fair,but lets see what others will say,and again read carefully first,then write.
Thanks :)
I'm indecisive about whether I like this idea, but I do have one question. Where would this option be? When training witches, when donating them, when using them? Would they have to implement a second trainable troop, identical to the witch but with air skeletons?
Yeah,I have though about this,but I'm sure supercell can think of a good idea to make it. It might be made with one of these blue boxes -> Attachment 90334 it will be held,in the witch icon,and you can click it to change it on ground or air..it can be clickable even in a clan castle. The player to choose what he want his witch to resurrect... ground skeletons or air skeletonsQuote:
Originally Posted by hawkeye5366
If you can choose the witch to AIR,all of your witches (IN CC,army camp..) will resurrect air troops,or if you choose on ground,all of them will bring back the normal ground skeletons.
Thanks :) and sorry for my bad english
Oh and btw, I meant the option to choose what your witch can resurrect,should be in ur base..not when you attack
To start you never mentioned a Clan castle at all in your post, secondly your example was horrible, examples are suppose to reasonably support your idea not saying Th7s defending against lavaloonion. I dont even see why you are focusing on Th7 since this will affect any town hall that can hold a witch in the clan castle, thus breaking air attacks in all townhalls that can hold a witch in the CC since at th8 you have the skeleton trap as well. Th7- dont get air skeles if they were meant to they would have the skeleton trap. Finally having a troop that you can toggle their ability is a bad idea. Remember read carefully first, then write.Quote:
Originally Posted by LudogoretsRazgrad
It's true that I didn't mentioned a clan castle,but I though its obviously that you can donate a Witch at Town Hall Level 7. Do you know that Town Hall Level 7 can have only 2 Air Defenses,max at level 5 ? if you have 3 Lightning Spells,and full army of dragons,AT TH7, you can always get 3 stars against a TH7 base,no matter how it's upgraded,or placed. <-- That is OP. And a witch,reviving air skeletons can fix this. + That kind of witch doesn't become OP,it just revives air skeletons,that can die with one air bomb,and also this way,the witch will be even more vulnerable to attacks,since her air skeletons are flying,and cannons/mortars can't shoot air troops,so they will target the witch. The air skeleons can hold small bombs,to drop them at the buildings.Quote:
Originally Posted by BattleBorn007
no hard feelings,but I think you misunderstood me a lot. :) Never ment what you though
Nothing is obvious on the IFR ive had people ask for Xbows at th8 and Pekka kings that spawn pekkas....So you saying witches at th7 is nothing new to me so I had no reason to assume you meant CC witches. Secondly dragons are strong at th7 yes HOWEVER they are not OP anywhere else so by trying to nerf drags at Th7 you are making them worse in the upper townhalls where its already hard enough to use them.Quote:
Originally Posted by LudogoretsRazgrad
Do a few attacks with TH7 all dragons and 3 Lightnings max lvl for the TH,against a TH7 base,and you will see,they always do 3 stars. Anyway back to the subject..xbows at th8 and pekka kings are obviously OP,and won't be done,but ur mistaking my idea,for something else.. It's probably cause I cannot explain it good. Back to the thread anywayQuote:
Originally Posted by BattleBorn007
With that kind of an Update,the witch will stay the same,JUST you will be able to select beforehand,what kind of skeletons,you want her to resurrect. And I didn't meant to select them,when ur about to attack someone,but before you go and start searching for an opponent. The option can be in the Dark Barrack,at the witch icon. I just gived the idea,if for some reason is approved,supercell can always make it to be selected differently.
I did use dragons in war then I was th7 and th8 and they are expensive yes you can win the raid but the amount of loot you get isnt worth it.Quote:
Originally Posted by LudogoretsRazgrad
Anyways,so let me make sure this is all clear you want witches the be able to have either Air or ground skeletons but you can only choose BEFORE you create the troop and the air skeletons respond just like the Air Skele traps?
Yes,and should be choosed,when you want... even after the creation is done,just like the skeleton trap,you select it on air,and its on air,until u bring it back to ground,you can choose air/ground skeletons when u want. Yes to respond just like the air skele traps,but the design should be changed a little,since on the air skele trap,the skeletons can't hit ground units,but they should be able to attack ground building,when the witch are making them,cause there aren't any air buildings. Hope u understood,and give ur opinion,for realQuote:
Originally Posted by BattleBorn007
If the Air/ground could only be chosen before they are made i could support this but not if they could be changed at anytime.Quote:
Originally Posted by LudogoretsRazgrad
I have read this thread ands must say, the idea itself isnīt that bad. To some extend it does make sense.
I do also have a few issues with it. First issue is already mentioned, which is this. If this would be possible, it would be the first troop with a toggle air/ground mode button on defense, which would be odd.
Second, compared to a trap I understand the trap can hold already trained flying skeletons (for as far as skeletons make any sense at all, as I personally find those skeleton traps ridiculous anyway). I fail to understand how a skeleton could be revived out of a grave by a witch and all of the sudden have a operating balloon.
But, most importantly, mass dragon attack is not going to be stopped by any troop in a castle, not even dragon lvl4 is stopping this for a TH7 being attcjked with lvl3 mass dragon so your suggestion isnīt going to solve that issue you are mentioning.
BTW, it isnīt an issue, it is actually the nature of the game. As a TH7 you get screwed by TH8, 9 and 10, while you as TH7 are wrecking TH6 bases.
I don't really see difference when they should be changed?Quote:
Originally Posted by BattleBorn007
Example - You send a warrior to the battlefield,and you can tell him whats better to take..a sword or a hammer. Just like the witches...you select what to resurrect ground or air skeletons.
I just don't see what difference makes,when you should choose it.. I don't think it should be changed in the battlefield.
Here's another example with the skeleton trap - lets say the skeleton trap is the witch, you put it on "Air" AND then click Attack -> Find a Match,and couldn't be changed,unless you get back to ur base and switch it. I hope this finally is understandable.
I'm just trying to give the Idea,and explain it how I think it should be. Its not necessary to happen,the same way I wrote..it can be corrected by supercell. And about the witch,reviving out of the grave a skeleton with balloon,now don't make any logic,but the design can always be changed..like to have a small bag in the back,where the balloon will come out,like a parachute or something similiar. It can be invented,by smarter people hehe :D and you're probably right,that mass dragons won't be stopped,but they can always be slowed down.. when you have now a witch in CC,and a mass dragons attacks u,the witch only resurrects skeletons,and they don't move,cause they cannot attack air troops,but if your witch is set on air, the skeletons will attack air troops,and definitely slow them down.Quote:
Originally Posted by mcleo
Good idea, but as said already, it wouldn't stop dragons destroying a th7 base.
no troop can stop them,but there is time and can always be slowed down,and the witch can resurrect every second,one air skeletons will die,and more will pop out,which is slowing,or the dragons can be redirected.Quote:
Originally Posted by Keepo
They would disrupt dragons a bit, but the outcome will be the same.Quote:
Originally Posted by LudogoretsRazgrad
It depends.Quote:
Originally Posted by Keepo