Kicks in clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Unoki

So what was the reasoning in making them co in the first place? You get a new member, 4 weeks later you think you can trust them so you make them co? Co should be someone you know you can trust, and for specific reasons. Recruiting skills, keeping members in line, etc. it should be a manager position at work. You just don't make someone a manager for no reason, especially when it involves giving them the power to fire (kick) employees (members). Choose wisely, and you won't need to be here looking for SC to fix your problems.

---

First of all I'm not looking for supercell to fix my problems I'm trying to help prevent it from happening to other people because I know how it feels...and even if you personally know and trust a guy and make him co...someone is bound to make a bad call and promote someone he isn't sopposed and even if it WAS preventable. It still could happen and the entire clan gets scrubbed. I'm not looking for SC to fix my prob. I jst thought I would be a decent thing to do. But OK let's say the 5 kick thing is scrubbed. Shouldn't there at least be an alert sent out to the clan leader telling him of suspicious activity. If u don't agree the just remove this post...jst thought it would have been a decent thing to do.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by destuctor

First of all I'm not looking for supercell to fix my problems I'm trying to help prevent it from happening to other people because I know how it feels...and even if you personally know and trust a guy and make him co...someone is bound to make a bad call and promote someone he isn't sopposed and even if it WAS preventable. (Just like at work, its still managements job to prevent that) It still could happen and the entire clan gets scrubbed. (Just like at work, and like there the managements that make those judgement errors get hurt while those that avoid them thrive. Work is a competition with the rest of the world, the game is a competition with just the rest of the COC world. Its the same concept.) I'm not looking for SC to fix my prob. I jst thought I would be a decent thing to do. (Agreed, and thank you. Even if I disagree I still think you have had a nice thought) But OK let's say the 5 kick thing is scrubbed. Shouldn't there at least be an alert sent out to the clan leader telling him of suspicious activity. (Since its a competition they may feel that making the game easier for those that don't successfully carry their part goes against the competitive environment they are trying to build) If u don't agree the just remove this post (NO, whether agreed or not your thoughts are valid and your expressing them is still appreciated. Plus, someone other than myself might agree)...jst thought it would have been a decent thing to do.

---

Please see comments above. You will get differing opinions as to whether SC should step in to help those that struggle to successfully manage. My own spin (which you can see) is that management is a job and how well someone does it has bearing on how well they fare the actual competition. For this reason I am in principle opposed to anything that does the job for them. In this case the successful selection of the right people is what I look at as being the job. yes, sometimes someone does it wrong and that's no different from if they dropped a troop wrong. There is a consequence.