Clan War Friendly Quit/Forfeit Option

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BattleBorn007

Who needs a "girlfriend" when you have clash in one hand and the warm touch of pizza in the other

---

So coc in one hand and something warm in the other.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

So coc in one hand and something warm in the other.

---

Just how I like it

Y not just make it NOT an option to leave a clan during war? Pop up a message that says you can't bail on your clan during war. That basically solves everything.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bigchefboyRD

Y not just make it NOT an option to leave a clan during war? Pop up a message that says you can bail on your clan during war. That basically solves everything.

---

Its not SuperCells job to babysit you, if you have someone in your clan that doesnt want to raid in war keeping him/her there first off is pointless if you dont want to war you just arnt going to attack and most likely spam chat till you are kicked, secondly you shouldn't be forced to stay anywhere.

How is it easily exploitable? It would only be between the opposing clan leaders to decide. No bonus would be issued for a friendly quit if it's BEFORE the war started. And a forfeit, seriously think. ONE CLAN IS GONNA WIN REGARDLESS AND GET A BONUS ANYWAY. So why not have an option to end the war early if you're admitting defeat? If you start a war with 20 members and 7 leave before it's even started, that's already an unfair advantage for the opposing clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BattleBorn007

This would require social skills that a lot of Clashers dont have nor can acquire

---

LOL. To true.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kingbeezy1988

How is it easily exploitable? It would only be between the opposing clan leaders to decide. No bonus would be issued for a friendly quit if it's BEFORE the war started. And a forfeit, seriously think. ONE CLAN IS GONNA WIN REGARDLESS AND GET A BONUS ANYWAY. So why not have an option to end the war early if you're admitting defeat? If you start a war with 20 members and 7 leave before it's even started, that's already an unfair advantage for the opposing clan.

---

This has a hopped up tone to it. Of the poster can't see the exploitable flaw then the poster doesn't intend to see it. Its too late at night to get sucked into one of those pointless debates explaining something to someone that doesn't want to understand.

Guys leaving is a clan management issue. Clans that cant do the things to avoid it should get a new leader. Its not something SC should have to fix.

From the bottom of the page:

Similar Threads

• Clan War Friendly Quit
  
  By kingbeezy1988 in forum Clan Wars
  
  
  Replies: 0Last Post: 4 Hours Ago, 01:04 AM
  
• New Match up system needed or forfeit option needed
  
  By loby56 in forum Clan Wars
  
  
  Replies: 21Last Post: December 12th, 2014, 03:17 PM
  
• Have you ever quit/temp quit the forums? How long did you quit?
  
  By Ali7861 in forum Off-topic
  
  
  Replies: 44Last Post: October 26th, 2014, 09:01 PM
  
• Clan war forfeit button
  
  By Gobob in forum Ideas & Feature Requests
  
  
  Replies: 4Last Post: July 3rd, 2014, 11:13 PM
  
• Clan Wars forfeit option
  
  By Shadow436 in forum Ideas & Feature Requests
  
  
  Replies: 10Last Post: June 16th, 2014, 09:42 AM
  
  
  

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

This has a hopped up tone to it. Of the poster can't see the exploitable flaw then the poster doesn't intend to see it. Its too late at night to get sucked into one of those pointless debates explaining something to someone that doesn't want to understand.

Guys leaving is a clan management issue. Clans that cant do the things to avoid it should get a new leader. Its not something SC should have to fix.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ninja352

From the bottom of the page:

Similar Threads

• Clan War Friendly Quit
  
  By kingbeezy1988 in forum Clan Wars
  
  
  Replies: 0Last Post: 4 Hours Ago, 01:04 AM
  
• New Match up system needed or forfeit option needed
  
  By loby56 in forum Clan Wars
  
  
  Replies: 21Last Post: December 12th, 2014, 03:17 PM
  
• Have you ever quit/temp quit the forums? How long did you quit?
  
  By Ali7861 in forum Off-topic
  
  
  Replies: 44Last Post: October 26th, 2014, 09:01 PM
  
• Clan war forfeit button
  
  By Gobob in forum Ideas & Feature Requests
  
  
  Replies: 4Last Post: July 3rd, 2014, 11:13 PM
  
• Clan Wars forfeit option
  
  By Shadow436 in forum Ideas & Feature Requests
  
  
  Replies: 10Last Post: June 16th, 2014, 09:42 AM
  
  
  

---

Again I say, how is it exploitable? If there is an OPTION given to the clan leader of the opposing clan to ACCEPT or DECLINE a forfeit/friendly quit, how can you exploit that? It is completely on that clan leader. It's not like the two clan leaders know each other and can continuously use these options over and over again. If it is before the war, neither side is losing anything when using a friendly quit. During war, the side that forfeits loses obviously. Just saves time, resources, money, etc when the result is pretty much set in stone once a clan loses X amount of members and doesn't have a fair shot to win.

And to address the clan leader being at fault. HOW? A leader can't make people stay. Some people leave for absolutely no reason at all. They won't or don't say anything in clan chat, just up and leave. Being the best clan member in the world can't make people stay if they decide to randomly leave.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kingbeezy1988

Again I say, how is it exploitable? If there is an OPTION given to the clan leader of the opposing clan to ACCEPT or DECLINE a forfeit/friendly quit, how can you exploit that? It is completely on that clan leader. It's not like the two clan leaders know each other and can continuously use these options over and over again. If it is before the war, neither side is losing anything when using a friendly quit. During war, the side that forfeits loses obviously. Just saves time, resources, money, etc when the result is pretty much set in stone once a clan loses X amount of members and doesn't have a fair shot to win. .

---

Why would anyone want to let the other clan off the hook because they lost some guys? Its the other clan's problem to live with they aren't able to hold together through a war. Its not a big problem for most clans so they are going to just chuckle at the other clans bad leadership while they look forward to picking up easy loot bonus.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kingbeezy1988

And to address the clan leader being at fault. HOW? A leader can't make people stay. Some people leave for absolutely no reason at all. They won't or don't say anything in clan chat, just up and leave. Being the best clan member in the world can't make people stay if they decide to randomly leave.

---

If a leader is not 1) putting guys through a screening process before he is willing to let them be in a war and b) not frustrating a stable team culture in their clan then that is not an effective leader. If your clan cannot shake this problem don't blame the people, replace the leader. They are falling down on their job. If they are asking what anyone would ever expect them to do then you know they are hopeless. Chances are people are leaving the clan because they see that and know they should just get away from it. Sorry but that's the straight truth.