Printable View
Giants should target troops. Are they really just going to sit there and get beat on? I hate when I get destroyed by 2 skeletons for the skeleton trap and my 16 giants with 2 healers on them get destroyed by 2 little skeletons. And they should be able to target clan troops
Sorry, but Giants are sado's they enjoy taking a beating, the skeleton trap has to have it's use aswell, take some supporting troops next time. Learn from errors of judgement not complain about it.
I agree it's so annoying.
Are you possibly.... suggesting that it is... illogical that giants just sit there as they get attacked by cc troops?
Well, here's what happens when Clash of Clans become logical....
Disclaimer:I am not advocating ideas on this list, in fact I might die if the they were implemented.
If Clash was logical....
- Archer Queen wouldn't stop shooting at walls when unneccessary.
- Troops that don't die would come back
- there would be trekking time to go to the next village (maybe a month)
- you would need some type of container to take resources back.
- many defences would still work while upgrading (painting wizard tower shouldn't stop wizard from shooting fire at troops.)
- At least one troop has to survive to bring the resources back
- the more troops left, the shorter the trekking time back.
- enemy cc troops could attack said container to get the resources back
- shooting at a elixir or dark elixir storage would make all the elixr and dark elixir spill into the ground if not caught properly
- troops would take at least 20 years to train
- you would have to have farms and such to feed your villagers.
- once you have been raided, it might take months to repair everything.
- shields wouldn't exist
- spells would require a troop to go in and place it (potentially dying)
- upgraded pumps and mines will drain the resources
- eventually there will be no resources and we will have to resort to buying resources with gems
- spells would be coloured according to their spell factory colour
- heroes wouldn't need to be hammered to get upgraded
- heroes would just have to drink d. Elixir and get upgraded instantaneously
- builders would have to have different materials not just a magic hammer
- villagers wouldn't run to the town hall when it is being attacked.
- villagers wouldn't disappear when town hall is destroyed
- mortars and other splash defences would hurt the defending troops and heroes too.
- projectiles that pass thought things (like cannonballs through walls) should stop at the first obstacle and damage that
- you need to train some sort of person to operate the autonomous defences
- if enemy kills the operator or the archer on the tower, the thing is useless.
- clan castle troops would be attacked by every troop, making them almost useless
- goblins wouldn't exist
- giants of that size and immunity wouldn't exist
- skeletons running around with bombs wouldn't exist
- skeletons flying around with bombs wouldn't exist
- large healing angels wouldn't exist
- dragons wouldn't exist
- robot samurai knight things wouldn't exist
- dark flying little creatures wouldn't exist
- hog riding hammer wielding men wouldn't exist
- animated piles of rock wouldn't exist
- undead women summoning animated skeletons wouldn't exist
- fiery flying dogs wouldn't exist.
- flying troops (except balloons) could go to the ground and avoid air defences when the time is right.
- Teslas and lvl 11 walls wouldn't work, because at the time period clash is in, electricity hadntbeen harnessed.
- loot penalty wouldn't exist
- troops would be able to leap over walls at all times like they can when defending
- defending troops wouldn't be able to jump that much (unless hog rider) (yea, just contradicted myself)
- civilians wouldn't be divided by gender (boys live in huts, girls live in the town hall)
- there would be pets everywhere
- farm animals would exist
- fully trained army wouldn't run off when the base is being attacked
- "You" would have an avatar that walks around giving orders.
- Troops can only be deployed from the forest around a base.
- Only toops close to "You" would get orders to do something.
- If "you" gets killed, the game blacks out and you have to restart.
- Clash would be a horrible game
*Logic and CoC don't go well together, that is my point.*
Not trying to be mean to you, but we don't need it, just plan a different attack strategy. This would completely rebalance the game.
Emerald is in an illogical mood, please excuse him....
but seriously perhaps change it so that once they have destroyed the building they were beating on they would turn on the skelies, but perhaps that is too logical who knows perhaps there will be so much "illogicalness" that it may become logical...
So it will be so illogical it would be logical?Quote:
Originally Posted by ironagedave
well it is possible to have some logical elements to the illogical, so it may yet become somewhat logical.
Your idea already exists. If you place giants in the clan castle and go on defense. Your castle will free the giants and they will attack the troops that will soon be attacking your base. Cheers. :cool::cool::cool:
Quote:
Originally Posted by ironagedave
Quote:
Originally Posted by ironagedave
Lol, literally laughed and people near me wondered what was going on.:rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Alfesicob
Im it saying all logic is bad, but the only "good" reason I can get from OP is that the current system is illogical, which I consider to be a rubbish reason. Now if OP provided other reasons alongside with it, I would happily ignore the logic part.
It adds to the strategy. Next you will be asking that when your troops are attacking the town hall they should stay there and finish it before running after the skeletons. Its just something you have to deal with and adapt to.