TH 9 and 10 Balance Please

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

Then why argue penalty semantics? It's clear that there is a very real and tangible benefit to not immediately upgrading. This is also a benefit that only starts to be realized with TH9.



Again my point is that the loot penalty is scarcely a concern until TH9 so prior to that there is little reason to provide a large incentive and advantage for upgrading to a higher TH.

---

I'm not arguing the loot penalty and I don't think you are either. I guess you're trying to say the freeze spell and inferno towers are the incentive to upgrade to town hall 10? I'm confused at what point you are trying to make.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dbut87

With the inferno towers still being unlocked at town hall 10 there would definitely be an incentive. My concern leans more toward trophy progression rather than loot. I teeter between crystal and master and most bases are well developed town hall 10's with inferno towers buried in their bases. I'm not sure what kind of town hall 10's you're raiding in the gold range (no offense :D) but it gets very difficult to even keep my trophy count up once I get to master between behind attacked and not being able to attack without the handiness of the freeze spell for inferno towers.

---

I get your point, I really do, I'm not in disagreement with you, but it will never happen. Also, it is your choice to settle for raiding in Master/Crystal. I choose Gold because it's easy and I don't have to worry about getting my loot stolen considering I'm fairly well upgraded. Your argument has a valid point but the fact is that a well-upgraded Town Hall 10 is already fairly overpowered. Add some of that power to Town Hall 9 and their will be an imbalance. And the TH10's I raid in Gold are usually inactive, but I get like 5-7 million of each resource per 2 hour boost. I don't do all out raids like I'm assuming you're forced to do in Crystal and Master. I'm not arguing with you, but I'm in complete disbelief that things like the Freeze spell and possibly more troop upgrades will drop to TH9, especially with Supercell working on specs for TH11 that could come out as soon as later this year. Your opinion makes sense and at least your argument is based on logic and concern, but as the intelligent person you appear to be you know that none of the Town Hall 10 luxuries will be passed down.

As far as Trophy-pushing goes, the Champion league wasn't entirely designed to include all Town Hall levels (if you want to survive, that is). I won't trophy push until I max my troops out, so I can't exactly see your point of view there.

Using the argument that freeze should only be for th10s, surely that same argument applies to th7 with tesla that cannot train pekka but can have teslas!

i would also agree pre tesla upgrade that th9 should not have maximum pekka but lvl 4 is surely a sensible balancing act after lvl 5 pekka was released

i am also an advocate of lvl 3 witches for th10 I am not suggesting the game should be balanced in favour of th9 i am suggesting the game can be better ballanced to enhance game play and worth for many farmers and gemmers and war mongers.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dbut87

I'm not arguing the loot penalty and I don't think you are either. I guess you're trying to say the freeze spell and inferno towers are the incentive to upgrade to town hall 10? I'm confused at what point you are trying to make.

---

If TH10 is so good why don't you upgrade to th10 already?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by chrispeterson

exactly a lot of town hall 9s have defended just fine against town hall 10s....if town hall 9s get a freeze they'll just be even more overpowered against town hall 8s..

---

I have one of each so I compare every day. A balance detail I would like is to give th9 pekka 4 but only witch 1.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dbut87

I'm not arguing the loot penalty and I don't think you are either. I guess you're trying to say the freeze spell and inferno towers are the incentive to upgrade to town hall 10? I'm confused at what point you are trying to make.

---

I don't think you're confused at all. You know exactly what I'm saying.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

I don't think you're confused at all. You know exactly what I'm saying.

---

I think you're saying because town hall 10 is currently max town hall level there needs to be a large incentive for it because they can only loot other town hall 10's and town hall 9's with any chance at getting decent loot. Is this correct?

The game is tops in the world 4 a reason. Recently went th10 and 4 sure its much tougher to find loot loot. Basically your stuck attacking the same level targets since the loot penalty is in full force. To give the 9s that sort of advantage with no penalty would be ludicrous on so many levels.be happy with what u have or take your toys and shuffle off.