4 star clan war system

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Yardey

With 4 stars you have to change the whole game, where as 3 stars rewarded in halves means you only have to modify it.

---

Depends on how it's all coded underneath. From a programming perspective, I think the 4th star would be much simpler to implement than trying to add in half stars.

At any rate, only SEE knows which way is more complex from a programming perspective, because it's their game. We can only guess.

From a gameplay perspective, I think 4 stars is easier to understand. Stars are an "all or nothing" kind of achievement. If you get 49%, you might feel some consolation that you "almost" got a star, but as far as the game is concerned, you got nothing. 50% might seem like you only "barely" got a star, but as far as the game is concerned, you got the star. Introducing half stars would somewhat cheapen what a star represents.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Xitra

Depends on how it's all coded underneath. From a programming perspective, I think the 4th star would be much simpler to implement than trying to add in half stars.

At any rate, only SEE knows which way is more complex from a programming perspective, because it's their game. We can only guess.

From a gameplay perspective, I think 4 stars is easier to understand. Stars are an "all or nothing" kind of achievement. If you get 49%, you might feel some consolation that you "almost" got a star, but as far as the game is concerned, you got nothing. 50% might seem like you only "barely" got a star, but as far as the game is concerned, you got the star. Introducing half stars would somewhat cheapen what a star represents.

---

totally agree !!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Skenderbeu

• star: 25% damage (except TH of course)
• 2 star: 50% damage (except TH of course)
• 3 star: 75% damage (except TH of course)
• 4 star: 99% damage (except TH of course)
• +1 star bonus if TH destroyed

---

I would actually attack the suggestion with a 5 star clan war system. Used your original suggestion and made adjustments.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Durant01

I would actually attack the suggestion with a 5 star clan war system. Used your original suggestion and made adjustments.

---

No with 25 you can win all tha attacs and get loot as consequence. That's not a good idea.

2 days until the poll end! Vote if you like the idea!