IDEA: Variations at Townhall level 9

This game has only one pathway of upgrading. I would like to see some variations in upgrading. Here is my idea: When a player reaches Townhall level 9, the player gets to choose his class among 4 classes. [Fire, Water, Thunder, and Earth].
Each class has advantage over another class.

Fire: has increased power to Thunder class by 5% when attacking a player of Thunder class.
Water: has increased power to Fire class by 5% when attacking a player of Fire class.
Thunder: has increased power to Water class by 5% when attacking a player of Water class.
Earth: has increased power to other classes by 2% when attacking a player of other classes.
(The basic idea is rock-paper-scissors relationship.)

This variation will allow players to have more fun of choosing which class they would like to be in, which can also impact on clan wars.

Thank you!

good idea boss

Sounds good to me

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by minjeekim1

This game has only one pathway of upgrading. I would like to see some variations in upgrading. Here is my idea: When a player reaches Townhall level 9, the player gets to choose his class among 4 classes. [Fire, Water, Thunder, and Earth].
Each class has advantage over another class.

Fire: has increased power to Thunder class by 5% when attacking a player of Thunder class.
Water: has increased power to Fire class by 5% when attacking a player of Fire class.
Thunder: has increased power to Water class by 5% when attacking a player of Water class.
Earth: has increased power to other classes by 2% when attacking a player of other classes.
(The basic idea is rock-paper-scissors relationship.)

This variation will allow players to have more fun of choosing which class they would like to be in, which can also impact on clan wars.

Thank you!

---

Ok first off no thats a bad idea

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by minjeekim1

good idea boss

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by minjeekim1

Sounds good to me

---

Secondly this is bumping which isnt allowed

Dude you literally just posted 2 comments complimenting your own idea

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MysticArcherr

Dude you literally just posted 2 comments complimenting your own idea

---

Lol I have never seen that TWICE on one post

Why do you guys think it's a bad idea? I think it will add some strategic advancement in clan wars.

Don't you think it's boring to follow the same route evey time? To me, it does, as it's only a matter of how much time one puts in. A player who's played this game for 1 year cannot lose to a player who's only played 8 months if we assume that both have five builders and never spent real money on gems.
However, if this variation is applied, there could be. An 8-month player of Fire class could possibly beat an 1-yr player of Thunder class

Don't just say it's bad. I wanna know why.

I like this idea. But would it increase the stats of offense and defense against said classes, or would it be something else?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Buttermink

I like this idea. But would it increase the stats of offense and defense against said classes, or would it be something else?

---

Probably stats of offense.
Simply put, an army who does 100 damage per second will do 105 damage instead if attacking a base. (Ex. Fire to Thunder)

then what happens to say, "Thunder" to "Fire" attck