So many loot solution, none being used!

Hi, i'm going to do a compilation of all the loot problem solutions i can remember or think of. I'll also add a personnal rating on each of them, ranging between 1 and 5. These idea aren't to be added all in once, just differents possibilities. (Expect #6, his only goal is to give merit to league bonus farmer back)

Please do not consider the fact that some thing would make loot easier because of collectors, without collectors bases, the game would die.

1. Remove or reduce loot penality from collectors.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

2. Incitate people to upgrade collectors:
•1 gems each time you upgrade a collector
•Achievement when you upgrade all your collector to the max of a TH level.
-10 gems for 12 lvl11 mines/extractors and 1 drill lvl3 (Th7)
-25 gems for 12 lvl12 mines/extractors and 2 drill lvl3 (Th8)
-50 gems for 14 lvl12 mines/extractors and 3 drill lvl6 (Th10)
Personnal rating: 3
Community rating:

3. Put more dead bases in circulation.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

4. Add utilities to goblin's maps by making map regenerate loot, like in the good old time.
Personnal rating: 4
Community rating:

5. Increase league bonus depending on stars or percentage.
Personnal rating: 4
Community rating:

6. Make league bonus count toward Gold Grab. If idea number 4 is added, make it so it counts too(not sure if it does though).
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

7. Add next fee to the loot available. The loot would be gained all by the one who win, if the defender come back and there is still a bonus, he get it all.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

So feel free to give thing i should add to the list and give your personnal rating with reason.

Hello there. It seems that you have spelt a lot of community's wrong. --- > community Hopefully you will learn through the English language!

Number two seems to be nice.

Also number 6 may be a bit useless but I still like it though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sylveonzmushi

Hello there. It seems that you have spelt a lot of community's wrong. --- > community Hopefully you will learn through the English language!

Number two seems to be nice.

Also number 6 may be a bit useless but I still like it though.

---

Thanks, corrected it.

As for number 6, it's to make people having a great GG even if they got it by league bonus so people don't think they gemmed because it's less rewarding(a lot of people thinks this). So people farm more league bonus.

I added number7.

I like all of them but I can't really speak to number 3 as I don't know enough about how it works

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Spurs978

I like all of them but I can't really speak to number 3 as I don't know enough about how it works

---

Inactive(dead) base are being push back in the queue, what i ask is to stop it.

I'll add a poll soon.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Varklix

Inactive(dead) base are being push back in the queue, what i ask is to stop it.

I'll add a poll soon.

---

why not keep the dead bases?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Varklix

Hi, i'm going to do a compilation of all the loot problem solutions i can remember or think of. I'll also add a personnal rating on each of them, ranging between 1 and 5.

1. Remove or reduce loot penality from collectors.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating: 5
would solve a lot actually, but then strong players might go down and bully the really low collectors.

2. Incitate people to upgrade collectors:
•1 gems each time you upgrade a collector
•Achievement when you upgrade all your collector to the max of a TH level.
-10 gems for 12 lvl11 mines/extractors and 1 drill lvl3 (Th7)
-25 gems for 12 lvl12 mines/extractors and 2 drill lvl3 (Th8)
-50 gems for 14 lvl12 mines/extractors and 3 drill lvl6 (Th10)
Personnal rating: 3
Community rating: 3
there is incentive for upgrading- loot. Wile this might solve things, the few gems you get aren't enough. Personally I don't like how gold mine lvl10 looks so mines are at lvl9.

3. Put more dead bases in circulation.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating: 5
Yea, I don't know why SC decided to move dead bases to the end of the queue. If there is a reason, please tell me, because I seriously don't know.

4. Add utilities to goblin's maps by making map regenerate loot, like in the good old time.
Personnal rating: 4
Community rating: 5
This would work really well and advertise the single player maps but you need to be careful it doesn't get too exploitable...

5. Increase league bonus depending on stars or percentage.
Personnal rating: 4
Community rating: 5
Adding loot and incentive to play the game in its original intention seems like a good idea.

6. Make league bonus count toward Gold Grab. If idea number 4 is added, make it so it counts too(not sure if it does though).
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:2
i don't see how this would help. Sure, some people actively try to get gold to get the achievement but most just reach it though regular gameplay.

7. Add next fee to the loot available. The loot would be gained all by the one who win, if the defender come back and there is still a bonus, he get it all.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating: ?
what? I don't quite understand

So feel free to give thing i should add to the list and give your personnal rating with reason.

---

Comments in ​bold.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by chrispeterson

why not keep the dead bases?

---

Supercell push dead base back in the queue, what i ask is to keep they position in the queue like if they weren't dead, resulting in more dead base.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Varklix

Supercell push dead base back in the queue, what i ask is to keep they position in the queue like if they weren't dead, resulting in more dead base.

---

oh ok. your post confused me thanks for the clarification bro

1. This encourages people to attack collectors instead of actually destroying a base and getting the storages. The latter is harder to do and should be more rewarding than barching collectors. It'd also encourage players to attack 2-3 TH levels below them since it'd be more profitable than fighting someone their level | Rating: 1

2. I'd prefer if it was faster or cheaper (even cheaper than it is now) so that people hardly have anything to lose when upgrading them | Rating: 2

3. Like with #1, this discourages more skilled types of attacks and encourages people to next until they find a dead base because it's more rewarding | Rating: 1

4. I see single player as a place to practice and get a bit of emergency loot but it shouldn't be a crutch to support players forever since this game seems to focus a lot on multiplayer | Rating: 2

5. It would encourage people to destroy more of the base than to just snipe around | Rating: 4

6. This doesn't improve loot at all. Plus I like how GG is counted currently. It shows how much I actually stole and ignores other sources like war bonus, collectors, etc | Rating: 0

7. This would make it so that bases without resources get easy gold. Even if it's not a huge amount, it's like rewarding people for not having anything to offer to the attackers | Rating: 2

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EmeraldRange

Comments in ​bold.

---

How can i quote you? (your answer)

1. Yeah they could, but they are dead base, active base usually don't have enough.

2.186 gems just for upgrading them(first possibility) or 85 gems for achievement (second possibility)

3.I think they want us to spend gems on ressources so we buy gems but i'd be buying gems only to boost but it's not worth it actually.

4. Should regenerate loot slowly

5. Nothing to say

6. Just so league bonus and goblin's maps(if added) farmer don't look like gemmers.

7.You know that gold you waste by nexting? Instead of wasting it, it should be added to the available loot on that base and when the owner of the base come back, he get the loot if nobody took it.(You get the loot when you win, like a league bonus)

Thanks for your feedback.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Varklix

Hi, i'm going to do a compilation of all the loot problem solutions i can remember or think of. I'll also add a personnal rating on each of them, ranging between 1 and 5.

1. Remove or reduce loot penality from collectors.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

2. Incitate people to upgrade collectors:
•1 gems each time you upgrade a collector
•Achievement when you upgrade all your collector to the max of a TH level.
-10 gems for 12 lvl11 mines/extractors and 1 drill lvl3 (Th7)
-25 gems for 12 lvl12 mines/extractors and 2 drill lvl3 (Th8)
-50 gems for 14 lvl12 mines/extractors and 3 drill lvl6 (Th10)
Personnal rating: 3
Community rating:

3. Put more dead bases in circulation.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

4. Add utilities to goblin's maps by making map regenerate loot, like in the good old time.
Personnal rating: 4
Community rating:

5. Increase league bonus depending on stars or percentage.
Personnal rating: 4
Community rating:

6. Make league bonus count toward Gold Grab. If idea number 4 is added, make it so it counts too(not sure if it does though).
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

7. Add next fee to the loot available. The loot would be gained all by the one who win, if the defender come back and there is still a bonus, he get it all.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

So feel free to give thing i should add to the list and give your personnal rating with reason.

---

1. Reduce not remove. Maye make any 2 th8s below you or less only 10% 3 below is 50%....
2.Yeah I think there should be an incitive. Maybe a little more to encourage. I mean a time gem reward wouldn't really stop most people from getting gems.
3. I don't think they should be counted equally so the game isn't that easy but not push it back that much.
4. Meh, if they fix loot in multiplayer this won't be needed. Game should be mostly multiplayer.
5. Yeah I agree.
6. Don't realy care homestly.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sirix

1. This encourages people to attack collectors instead of actually destroying a base and getting the storages. The latter is harder to do and should be more rewarding than barching collectors. It'd also encourage players to attack 2-3 TH levels below them since it'd be more profitable than fighting someone their level. So you argument is based on the fact you don't like collectors farmers. And i can take Th10 collectors as much as Th5 one.| Rating: 1

2. I'd prefer if it was faster or cheaper (even cheaper than it is now) so that people hardly have anything to lose when upgrading them That could work too, same goal, diffeents ways| Rating: 2

3. Like with #1, this discourages more skilled types of attacks and encourages people to next until they find a dead base because it's more rewarding Same as #1 | Rating: 1

4. I see single player as a place to practice and get a bit of emergency loot but it shouldn't be a crutch to support players forever since this game seems to focus a lot on multiplayer | Rating: 2

5. It would encourage people to destroy more of the base than to just snipe around | Rating: 4

6. This doesn't improve loot at all. Plus I like how GG is counted currently. It shows how much I actually stole and ignores other sources like war bonus, collectors, etc The problems with the actual count is that people who get loot by league bonus look like gemmers, losing their merit in the eyes of a lot of player | Rating: 0

7. This would make it so that bases without resources get easy gold. Even if it's not a huge amount, it's like rewarding people for not having anything to offer to the attackers No because the gold would have been took by an attacker | Rating: 2

---

Comments in bold

And i see that you don't like collectors farmers.

Added a poll and edited the Op, read before voting please.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Varklix

Hi, i'm going to do a compilation of all the loot problem solutions i can remember or think of. I'll also add a personnal rating on each of them, ranging between 1 and 5. These idea aren't to be added all in once, just differents possibilities. (Expect #6, his only goal is to give merit to league bonus farmer back)

Please do not consider the fact that some thing would make loot easier because of collectors, without collectors bases, the game would die.

1. Remove or reduce loot penality from collectors.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

2. Incitate people to upgrade collectors:
•1 gems each time you upgrade a collector
•Achievement when you upgrade all your collector to the max of a TH level.
-10 gems for 12 lvl11 mines/extractors and 1 drill lvl3 (Th7)
-25 gems for 12 lvl12 mines/extractors and 2 drill lvl3 (Th8)
-50 gems for 14 lvl12 mines/extractors and 3 drill lvl6 (Th10)
Personnal rating: 3
Community rating:

3. Put more dead bases in circulation.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

4. Add utilities to goblin's maps by making map regenerate loot, like in the good old time.
Personnal rating: 4
Community rating:

5. Increase league bonus depending on stars or percentage.
Personnal rating: 4
Community rating:

6. Make league bonus count toward Gold Grab. If idea number 4 is added, make it so it counts too(not sure if it does though).
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

7. Add next fee to the loot available. The loot would be gained all by the one who win, if the defender come back and there is still a bonus, he get it all.
Personnal rating: 5
Community rating:

So feel free to give thing i should add to the list and give your personnal rating with reason.

---

This is Supercell bro,
Less loot = More money

They will do the least to increase loot for players.
If loot was abundant, no one would get annoyed about getting a last bit of loot for an upgrade and buy gems.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ashtagger

This is Supercell bro,
Less loot = More money

They will do the least to increase loot for players.
If loot was abundant, no one would get annoyed about getting a last bit of loot for an upgrade and buy gems.

---

If there was more loot, i'd be buying gems to boost my barrack so i can take it all but it's not worth it because it take so much time to find a good attack.

It's annoying when they say "We know loot is bad and we are working on solving this" then add 1 lvl of collectors, super usefull, loot is now plentifull... They are trowing at us useless loot update so it look like they want to solve it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ashtagger

This is Supercell bro,
Less loot = More money

They will do the least to increase loot for players.
If loot was abundant, no one would get annoyed about getting a last bit of loot for an upgrade and buy gems.

---

This is very true, and it is actually a shame that they are trying to maximise profit rather than improve players gameplay experience....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Obu12345

This is very true, and it is actually a shame that they are trying to maximise profit rather than improve players gameplay experience....

---

It's not that.
They do value player's game-play experience. They have done a lot to make the game better.
But, when its come to less profit for them/too much work for them, it hurts them and they try to deal it in a way which keeps their reputation without cutting their profits down.