a few ideas to bat around

The first is easy, if say your searching for the right base to attack and you accidentally deploy your default troop, there should be something to nullify the action. I really hate losing 20+ trophies to an accident.

Modify the trophies so that they reflect the current town hall and activity. What would happen is you get a set of trophies based off of where you are on a particular level of upgrading a th, while the current trophies act as they do. What this would do is when attacking someone, it looks at your th trophies and shows you people to attack based on a range of your th trophies and your active trophies. This would actually give people a chance to actually hit people that are around your strength rather then getting clobbered by an uber person that's farming far to low

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by aaronrichter

The first is easy, if say your searching for the right base to attack and you accidentally deploy your default troop, there should be something to nullify the action. I really hate losing 20+ trophies to an accident.

Modify the trophies so that they reflect the current town hall and activity. What would happen is you get a set of trophies based off of where you are on a particular level of upgrading a th, while the current trophies act as they do. What this would do is when attacking someone, it looks at your th trophies and shows you people to attack based on a range of your th trophies and your active trophies. This would actually give people a chance to actually hit people that are around your strength rather then getting clobbered by an uber person that's framing far to low

---

First one is already being considered: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines

The second one I'm not so sure.. farming has become a part of the game

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mmf01

The second one I'm not so sure.. farming has become a part of the game

---

It wouldn't get rid of farming it would make farming a bit more strategic and would ever have to worry about some level 20 archer queen that absolutely destroys you and taking loot that you really worked hard to get yourself

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by aaronrichter

It wouldn't get rid of farming it would make farming a bit more strategic and would ever have to worry about some level 20 archer queen that absolutely destroys you and taking loot that you really worked hard to get yourself

---

Some guys don't want that. They want to go low and clobber little guys for easy wins. And then get their DE zapped so they can come to the forum about it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

Some guys don't want that. They want to go low and clobber little guys for easy wins. And then get their DE zapped so they can come to the forum about it.

---

And that's driving away paying customers. Honestly if I was that low and constantly getting hit by someone so far ahead I has no chance against him I wouldn't pay. what I suggested just makes everything fair

I like the second idea and think it would be a good way to sort of stop the super trophy drops. I mean come on... why should a maxxed th9 be raiding in bronze????

This idea though, would have to change the raid match algorithm completely. I think maybe instead to stop the crazy trophy drops they should consider a cap. If you are TH9 or above your league stops at silver II. No matter how few trophies you go, you would still be matched against Silver II or higher. again, it would have to compare TH and defense/offense levels.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kristinepixie

I like the second idea and think it would be a good way to sort of stop the super trophy drops. I mean come on... why should a maxxed th9 be raiding in bronze????

This idea though, would have to change the raid match algorithm completely. I think maybe instead to stop the crazy trophy drops they should consider a cap. If you are TH9 or above your league stops at silver II. No matter how few trophies you go, you would still be matched against Silver II or higher. again, it would have to compare TH and defense/offense levels.

---

I had honestly thought of the same idea. The one thing that held me back was that would make trophies meaningless. Hence my idea about adding additional trophies just for the th. This would make it a lot easier to do. As for the farming worries, farming is still there and prevalent its just you'll have to do a little more work for it...ie you won't be able to drop all the way down to bronze to pick on a newbie who has much needed loot that they need.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kristinepixie

I like the second idea and think it would be a good way to sort of stop the super trophy drops. I mean come on... why should a maxxed th9 be raiding in bronze????

This idea though, would have to change the raid match algorithm completely. I think maybe instead to stop the crazy trophy drops they should consider a cap. If you are TH9 or above your league stops at silver II. No matter how few trophies you go, you would still be matched against Silver II or higher. again, it would have to compare TH and defense/offense levels.

---

Max th9's only can max because there are tons of th8's inactive in bronze. The game is about picking on someone lower then you or at you level. Don't tell me you didn't go and raid a th below you for the loot. Plus, Upgrade are expensive at th9-10.

The second idea is not a good idea at all!!! Say you are a level 7 town hall and u want to be champion league. Well all u have to do is attack other town hall 7's instead of maxed th 10's. the game would become insanely unbalanced league wise. Idk why they havnt ruled this out but it will soon

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by firestar123

Max th9's only can max because there are tons of th8's inactive in bronze. The game is about picking on someone lower then you or at you level. Don't tell me you didn't go and raid a th below you for the loot. Plus, Upgrade are expensive at th9-10.

---

As they are for 5-8 with their respective collectors. The problem right now is that there are a few to many advance players in the lower ranks attacking the smaller people, thus cutting off potential gem buyers later. The problem really confess down to math and something called the Bell Curve. In this case where can SC make the most money while pleasing the most people the bell curve here likely points at the people who are th 7-9 where most of the upgrades happen.

So the problem what to do about peopled who drop trophies to farm inexperienced players, who quit, because they are easy targets? What I proposed is just one answer, might not be the best, however, it puts what's needed: a restriction on who you can and cannot attack, and that's what's ultimately the end result alot of these topics are wanting.

As for them throwing out the idea completely, that's just a horrible thing to even suggest, as that would case the game to become stagnate and lose money as people aren't going to spend money on something they know they are going to lose.