A more integrated clan

This is my first forum so hopefully it's not too bad. I know that this has kind of already been ruled out (yes I read the sticky) but I will try to propose a little bit of a different idea so that it's not quite the same thing... Anyway here it goes:
my idea is to have members in a clan be able to trade and donate resources. I know that it's out ruled because people might use it to make double accounts and funnel resources into one account but I have a new idea that will solve the problem. This makes it a bit more like a loan than a donation but here goes:
so I'm thinking that maybe there should be a limit on the amount you can donate before some is donated back(say 500,000) so how it works is let's say player 1 needs 500,000 more for an upgrade so player 2 gives him the 500,000 and then player 1 can no longer receive resources from player 2 until player 2 gives some resources back to player 1. That way you can receive donations at the time you need them and then pay them back when you can which would also prevent the multi-account people from just funneling because they would need to give some back which would make it pointless for them. (Btw this is edited so the first comments apply to what was up before) tell me what you think now. :)

The thing is, XP level is almost too easy to manipulate. If its Th Level you are referring to, people usually work their alts to TH8 for farming troops and that's about it. Making the funneling possible for TH9-10 depending on the scope of your proposition. Even so, people would rush the TH and not care about walls or Defenses, and focus on Collectors/Storages and Troops. Any way you look at it, this is exploitable with a little bit of work and time

*Coleader: "Give me loot or I kick you".* NO. Not to mentions hoppers are gonna get worse.

It would be nice to help others but what one could do is make multiple accounts, then they pick the one they max. The others all funnel resources until the good one is completely maxed for its level then they go around just rushing resources into a single producing base to get the next th level and max its resource production buildings. Then you use them to boost the maxed one to the next th level and do the same to get the producers there. I did the math and if i have a base with lvl12 gold mines/elixer producers they make 3.5 mil in a week. If I have 7 bases they produce that in a day. If I have 28 bases (yea its a bit wild there) it can do it in 6 hours. That means in a very short amount of time i can totally move my good bases and my max base up to very very high levels

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HiFliya

The thing is, XP level is almost too easy to manipulate. If its Th Level you are referring to, people usually work their alts to TH8 for farming troops and that's about it. Making the funneling possible for TH9-10 depending on the scope of your proposition. Even so, people would rush the TH and not care about walls or Defenses, and focus on Collectors/Storages and Troops. Any way you look at it, this is exploitable with a little bit of work and time

---

I see what your saying and XP would be explotable but I didn't mean XP I meant however they do it in war. And if that doesn't work hopefully they can think of something else that works because this would definitely make clans more cooperative and work together better.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sniper16

It would be nice to help others but what one could do is make multiple accounts, then they pick the one they max. The others all funnel resources until the good one is completely maxed for its level then they go around just rushing resources into a single producing base to get the next th level and max its resource production buildings. Then you use them to boost the maxed one to the next th level and do the same to get the producers there. I did the math and if i have a base with lvl12 gold mines/elixer producers they make 3.5 mil in a week. If I have 7 bases they produce that in a day. If I have 28 bases (yea its a bit wild there) it can do it in 6 hours. That means in a very short amount of time i can totally move my good bases and my max base up to very very high levels

---

Yeah but that's why the whole point of the level range is to prevent that

It's still ruled out... Just saying...

It would just be a lot more rules people have to worry about...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EddieKing

I see what your saying and XP would be explotable but I didn't mean XP I meant however they do it in war. And if that doesn't work hopefully they can think of something else that works because this would definitely make clans more cooperative and work together better.

---

They match people based on Defense levels (altogether not separately) to judge your standings vs. The enemy's. The only way that this would be un-exploitable is if they had a limit on what is transferrable, but in the end, makes the whole concept obsolete and unneeded.

Just to clarify the point of this is to allow clans to work together and share to act more like one group than just a bunch of individual villages that just do war together. There will always be people who find loopholes in the system even with rules in act today but it's for the majority of the people that just want to be able to help each other out and work together. And if my system of levels doesn't seem to work, maybe supercell or another player could come up with a better way to prevent the resource funneling thing. I'll keep thinking of a better way but in the mean time, tell me what you think.

I have kept my bases reasonably close to each other. no more than one TH difference. I would be able to easily exploit such a setup even with the restrictions you specify. I mean, I would love what you propose for how rich I would get. But others might not appreciate me being able to do that.

You would also be able to move your loot from base to base to keep it under shield.