Which TH9 Farming Base Do You Think Is Better?

So I'm working on a TH9 Farming base, and I would like some feedback one which one you guys think is better.

Please vote in the poll and post why you think this option is better.

Thank you!
- Drakon

Option 1:

http://i62.tinypic.com/2hf59q9.jpg

Option 2:

http://i57.tinypic.com/ic39z8.jpg

Thanks for the replies everyone -.- lol

Id go with the second one, it has better funneling imo.

Ima go with Option 1 because a bit harder to get to the Air defenses, unlike Option 2 which has exposed Air defenses =)

Both of them have their flaws, but I like the first better.

It has better funnelling and just looks better IMO, also the double giants bombs are more difficult to set off as they are in a space

I know it doesn't have much to do with the post, but you should upgrade you new defenses instead of your new walls first buddy.

Base 2 I might use it, is that cool?

Option 2.
But nice work, both look really good

Tried the base first attack was a maxed troop attack

168 archers lvl 7
45 barb lvl7
2 giants lvl 7
AQ lvl40
3 witches lvl 2
8 wbs
CC
1 Rage lvl 5
1 freeze

Result 2 Star 66%

I'll try it a bit more