Leaving a clan during Clan Wars - NO GO

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jammer0816

Please fix the issue of people leaving when war has been declared. It puts the other clan at such an advantage. Mercy! :mad:

---

Make anyone new wait through one full war before you will let them in one it will help with several issues, including hoppers.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

Make anyone new wait through one full war before you will let them in one it will help with several issues, including hoppers.

---

Not possible. If they are in the top "x" amount, they are included in the war.

If the leader was able to select or have a "vote in" option for war, then that would work.

You can't blame the leader people. How in the world is he/she to know that someone joining their clan isn't going to battle? If they don't battle, then the lead boots them. Plain and simple. But leaving after war has been declared puts your clan behind the eight ball.

There has to be some way this can be resolved. Maybe rule the opposing clans same number inactive. Hmmmmm..... That sounds interesting yes? If the person is ranked say number 10 and leaves during war prep, then the number 10 of the opposing clan is deemed inactive by default. Perfect. Make it so. =)

well some of this will b solved with opt in/out war update. so new members should not b included in wars immediately..


other than that its impossible. they will start abusing or donating wrong and u will kick them anyways. so i think better concentrate on option for excluding members from war

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jammer0816

Not possible. If they are in the top "x" amount, they are included in the war. So tell them what you are doing, then kick them, start war, invite back right after. If they don't return you have learned something important without getting hurt by it.

If the leader was able to select or have a "vote in" option for war, then that would work. Maybe someday, but for now what I say above is best way.

You can't blame the leader people. (Actually, that's exactly who to blame. If you don't want to take the precautions being advised then don't complain about the consequences) How in the world is he/she to know that someone joining their clan isn't going to battle? (That's what you are being told is how to protect against those people) If they don't battle, then the lead boots them. Plain and simple. But leaving after war has been declared puts your clan behind the eight ball.

There has to be some way this can be resolved. Maybe rule the opposing clans same number inactive. Hmmmmm..... That sounds interesting yes? If the person is ranked say number 10 and leaves during war prep, then the number 10 of the opposing clan is deemed inactive by default. Perfect. (No, this final paragraph is the worst approach to the problem I think I have ever seen suggested, how are your internal problems supposed to become the opponents problems too) Make it so. (Please No) =)

---

Please see responses in bold,. There is hope to add in an opt in/out system and it would be nice. But for your immediate problem, if you are not willing to take the steps to resolve you problems then you have only yourself to blame for them. Sorry to say it that starkly, but its really true.