Leaderboards based on Clan War wins

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ThePeskyDingo

Do you have an idea how they would rank the different levels of clans that have the same amount of players?

For instance should a 10 person clan with an average level of 45 be rated in the same league as a clan with an average level of 125?

The reason I ask is that clan wars at lvl 45 are so much simpler and easy to achieve 30/30 stars with mass dragons when compared to high level clans where you have to attack with different armies and cannot just drop all the dragons out and watch.


If these were the rules I would put together a 50 person clan and not allow anyone to level past TH7. They would use mass lvl 2 dragons in every attack and we would always get 150/150 stars and never lose.

This way we would be at the top of the biggest leader board (50x50) and get the biggest gem reward.

Once we do this for a year or so we would have a giant gem stash saved up and can just gem our way to max everything.

---

You are correct that dragons make it easier to gain stars on lower TH's, but there are a lot of things that you can rely on.
1. Dragons are dumb and don't always go where you want them to. I can't tell you how many times I've seen dragon attacks go askew...
2. With the number of people coming and going in this game, there are a large number of people who fail to attack. Getting full participation in wars is really hard to achieve at times.
3. The way war matching works would still make it difficult for a clan of 50 TH7's. Wars are matched up by the system pairing 2 clans with similar strengths. So there is a good chance that the opposing clan will have TH8's and TH9's in them. Making it impossible to get perfect stars in war every war. We have had 106 wars wins and only have had a perfect win maybe twice...

As for the gem bonus, the bigger clan would not necessarily get more gems than a smaller clan. The top clans would get the same amount of gems per player for each tier. Let me explain my thoughts on how it should be, and I'll use 100 gems for first place, 50 gems for second, and 25 gems for third place just for easy math.

First Place Tiers:
10x10 clans win 1000 gems. That's 100 gems per player.
15x15 clans win 1500 gems. That's still 100 gems per player.
20x20 clans win 2000 gems. Again 100 gems per player.

And so on.

Second Place Tiers:
10x10 = 500 gems. 50 each.
15x15 = 750 gems. 50 each.
20x20 = 1000 gems. 50 each.
And so on.

Third Place Tiers:
10x10 = 250 gems. 25 each.
15x15 = 375 gems. 25 each.
20x20 = 500 gems. 25 each.
And so on.

Now this may get expensive for SC, especially if they do it in accordance with current seasons. So I see them probably giving 25 gems for first, 15 for second and 5 for third place.

Even if there is not an season contest. We think there should be some sort of war leader board. A board for most wins ever, a board for average stars per clan, and one still showing how many wins/stars per season. The last one is to include the younger fresh clans.

the united fami, #GOOVQGO

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ThePeskyDingo

Do you have an idea how they would rank the different levels of clans that have the same amount of players?

For instance should a 10 person clan with an average level of 45 be rated in the same league as a clan with an average level of 125?

The reason I ask is that clan wars at lvl 45 are so much simpler and easy to achieve 30/30 stars with mass dragons when compared to high level clans where you have to attack with different armies and cannot just drop all the dragons out and watch.


If these were the rules I would put together a 50 person clan and not allow anyone to level past TH7. They would use mass lvl 2 dragons in every attack and we would always get 150/150 stars and never lose.

This way we would be at the top of the biggest leader board (50x50) and get the biggest gem reward.

Once we do this for a year or so we would have a giant gem stash saved up and can just gem our way to max everything.

---

I think yes it should since clan wars are usually matched against same level opponents, therefore being as equally challenging as a clan with max players. Even at th 8 and 9 people could summon max dragons and blaze through, the issue here is with the OP force of dragons not with the level brackets.

Great Support guys

Keep it up!

Supporting this
Mods need to see this
trophies are pretty useless for clan ranking unless you have worked your way till max troops and 99% players haven't

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Xswamp

Keep it up!

---

Stop bumping your thread, its against the forum rules.
Half of the posts in this threads are yours saying "anymore support" and "keep going"
That is nothing but bumping.

If your idea is dropped, move on with it like everyone else.

I love this idea

probably the best idea out . i support you as well

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ashtagger

Stop bumping your thread, its against the forum rules.
Half of the posts in this threads are yours saying "anymore support" and "keep going"
That is nothing but bumping.

If your idea is dropped, move on with it like everyone else.

---

Your post is also a bump, so thank you kind sir.

If this were to actually happen, what would happen at the end of the season? Tens of thousands of clans tied for most wins. Then you can limit it to stars earned, but as someone stated before, only low level clans would win, because every base is an easy 3 star. Therefore they would have 100+ stars each war which would be ridiculous. Higher levelled players would have no chance whatsoever.