Battle Time

Just a thought about the times available for attacking other bases. I get it that 3 minutes is the standard. However, I believe there should be an extra allowance for raiding higher town halls, and a penalty for raiding lower town halls. This would compensate/penalise raiders for the extra troops relative to the extra buildings. For example, if a TH8 raids a TH9 or higher they should get say an extra 15 seconds to complete their raid for a total raid time of 3:15. But if a TH9 raids a TH8 or lower they should lose 15 seconds and only get a raid time of 2:45. This would apply either to all town hall levels, or maybe only from TH6 and upwards. In most cases it shouldn't change anything given it is hard to raid up successfully and get 3 stars, and often the attacks are over relatively quickly when raiding down. However, there are times where a hard fought battle should benefit the lower TH who either put up a good attack or a good defence only to be beaten by the clock. Thoughts?

Sorry, but I feel like only another 10 secounds are needed for all TH lvls, not the amount of time you want, sorry.

3 minutes is more than enough time. If you find yourself running short of time that's on you.

3 mins is perfect. No more is needed.

I get the impression the replies think this is a whinge-fest that 3 minutes is not enough. I recommend you read my post again because this was in NO WAY saying that 3 minutes was not enough. It's no wonder people don't bother posting here if the only replies are banalities based on a skim read of the original post. Sheesh....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ferg

I get the impression the replies think this is a whinge-fest that 3 minutes is not enough. I recommend you read my post again because this was in NO WAY saying that 3 minutes was not enough. It's no wonder people don't bother posting here if the only replies are banalities based on a skim read of the original post. Sheesh....

---

This is a strategy game. Part of it is the clock. Your goal (generally): 3 star your opponent in 3 minutes or less. Not: 3 star your opponent in 3:15 or less. This is the time Supercell has put aside, and its worked for years now, no reason to change. Sorry if this came out rudely.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mmf01

This is a strategy game. Part of it is the clock. Your goal (generally): 3 star your opponent in 3 minutes or less. Not: 3 star your opponent in 3:15 or less. This is the time Supercell has put aside, and its worked for years now, no reason to change. Sorry if this came out rudely.

---

I get it (I have been playing for over a year and am a maxxed TH9) but once again that is not what I am referring to. Where is the allowance for a lower TH with weaker troops taking on a greater quantity of buildings that have higher hitpoints? There is none. Should there be is the question. And vice versa.

Sorry Ferg if we misunderstood you in any way:(

We apologize and the opinions above are just trying to help,
not criticize and make you feel worse.

Do you have problems if we only have 3 minutes for higher townhalls?

I don't seem to, but anyways,

Have a nice day!;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ferg

I get it (I have been playing for over a year and am a maxxed TH9) but once again that is not what I am referring to. Where is the allowance for a lower TH with weaker troops taking on a greater quantity of buildings that have higher hitpoints? There is none. Should there be is the question. And vice versa.

---

Here is my theory:

Supercell decided that 3 minutes was adequate time to take out a TH9/TH10. To make things less complicated, they gave 3 minutes to people of all levels, meaning that everyone got extra time than what should be needed besides those taking out higher level THs.

I see what your saying but there is no need for it. If they are attacking a higher th their troops probably won't last as long anyway.