Potental anti farm change - more resources in Th

I am not against farming, I see it as part of the game, however, i know many people feel it is contrary to the game so I was thinking one way to address this might be to make 3 changes to the th building:
1) the amount of resources held by the Th increase with each Th lvl and based on the average storage lvl.
2) Th resources always fill first, so a th would be full before the storages begin to fill (might already work this way)
3) all resources in a Th are available in an attack.

The idea being that many farmers (myself included, but i prefer the term Hunter over the F word) place their th outside their walls for an easy shield, however, in the case of a lvl 8 th with maxed out storages, this would move from losing 1000 of each resource to 100,000 of each resource.

this would make people have to defend their th or suffer a significant penalty. It also would give a bit more of a bonus to people in general with more resource space. As a downside, the average of the storages might not work as well because someone could build lower storages and not upgrade them to lower the average. But i think this idea could move the game toward where the non farmers want it.

I personally do not care how people have fun, but i have noticed that the folks most anti farming have also dumped the most gems into the game. I am not a Pay2win guy either, but we need the folks that are gemming to be happy and farming does cut into the 'value' of their gem purchases.

Parts 2 and 3 of your suggestion already work that way.

As to part 1, I think it's a horrible idea. Why would you want to ruin the game? Why does it matter to others where people choose to put their TH?

This wouldn't hurt farming at all really. Even if the TH held enough to make people put it inside, they would still be farming, just without the easy shields.

i guess i need a definition of farming. i see it as attacking for only resources without consideration of trophies. I think attacking for resources is part of the game, otherwise this should just be 100% pay2win.

So, if losing more resources by not protecting your th would have no impact on farming, because you lose trophies off of this. You farm to gain resources so you need to address the ability to get an easy shield and hold the resources.

Again, i have no issue with farming. i think resource gain is a bit convoluted as it is (which encourages farming because how else do you not have idle builders)

Remind me...what is bad about farming again?

I think by putting anti-farming in your title people will think you are against farming no matter what your post says.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by zachUVA

This wouldn't hurt farming at all really. Even if the TH held enough to make people put it inside, they would still be farming, just without the easy shields.

---

This is true I really don't see how it would hurt farming at all.

I just see people with farm builds and the TH is outside. It seems there is a correlation between a 'farming build' and a th outside your walls, so the idea was to incentivise people to put the th in the walls.

Again, not against farming, but i see people complain about it all the time. Still not sure what the difference is, i guess some people attack for trophies regardless of resource return. I am not aware of someone attacking without consideration of resources unless they are in the very top of the players list and I do not see how 'farming' impacts the game in a negitive way...

Yeah, probably a bad title choice.

It is a STRATEGY game, therefore if people's strategy is to farm, then so be it!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ibthanos

I personally do not care how people have fun, but i have noticed that the folks most anti farming have also dumped the most gems into the game. I am not a Pay2win guy either, but we need the folks that are gemming to be happy and farming does cut into the 'value' of their gem purchases.

---

Are you saying that we ought to show greater sympathy and consideration for paying players than for non-paying players?
Oh no, I cannot raid this guy! He paid for his full storage! Cry me a river.