New Clan Feature

I already know that many people will not like this idea because some people dont donate to their clan and only request.


my idea is that the clan leader (not co) may set a minimum amount of donations and it be a clan rule that you must meet that amount of donations. If one does not meet the donation minimum, depending on their clan rank, they will either be kicked or demoted (demoted one rank, ie: co --> elder or elder --> member or member --> kicked). I realize that this ignores the clan leader please reply saying what should happen if the leader does not meet the required amount and if there should be a way to negate/excuse this (maybe ask the leader or a co if you may be excused from a certain week because you are on vacation or something like that (keep in mind if you ask for this it may not be approved). And another option could be setting the clan to a point where donations must be within 30 (30 is not a set number, it is just being used for example) troops of requests meaning your donations must be close to or equal to the number of received troops.
i think this would solve the following problems:
1) inactive people being in a otherwise active clan
2) inactive people being in war
3) knowing who to give elder and co-leader to



Please list any problems that may arise, thank you!

clash on!

All of this can be done manually. Find a clan that says "MUST DONATE TROOPS" in the clan description and you're golden. I've only been playing for a few weeks and I've donated over 2,500 troops while I've received over 4,000. You just have to find the right clan for any of those issues. Clans are love, clans are life.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pyroflame

All of this can be done manually. Find a clan that says "MUST DONATE TROOPS" in the clan description and you're golden. I've only been playing for a few weeks and I've donated over 2,500 troops while I've received over 4,000. You just have to find the right clan for any of those issues. Clans are love, clans are life.

---

I get that all of these things can be done manually, i have been playing for two years now, im saying a lot of people get of the hook donating 5 and getting 300 while others get the opposite and nothing is done. I think it would be nice if it would auto check and do as i said before. Im guessing your trying to start a clan or in a large clan, in a 50 person clan it is very annoying to have to check all the names to see if they met the qouta because even tho it mays say in the desc that doesnt mean people will do it

thanks

Clash On!

Or you could just look before the season ends.

It's a pretty bad method imo. Auto-kick in general's bad because there'll be instances where it'd do something unintended due to some circumstances, and while they might not be the most common they can cause a lot of damage.

For this example, if the leader's phone was damaged before a member went on a vacation. There would be no exempt and that member would be kicked even if it wasn't really his fault.

It really wouldn't work as intended and while it may help some clans it would destroy others.