Some hoppers will join a clan, request troops, then leave. I believe that if you decide to leave a clan with troops in the castle they should disappear. Clan castle troops should remain loyal to their birth clan and abandon a person if they leave.
Printable View
Some hoppers will join a clan, request troops, then leave. I believe that if you decide to leave a clan with troops in the castle they should disappear. Clan castle troops should remain loyal to their birth clan and abandon a person if they leave.
This would ruin those Req and Leave clans. Seriously no. Just deal with it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
Nope, not something that's needed.
This problem was solved before I got CoC. It's called invite only:rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
Hoppers have taken advantage of this loop hole in COC. You should have CC troops if you are with a clan.
If this was a glitch then wouldn't this be the wrong subforum. Plus, it's not a glitch if it has a solution called invite only.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
Whao whao whao... what glitch? Its perfectly fine for players to keep troops if they aren't in a clan. Seriously there are Req and Leave clans actually want people to come and go. There is no glitch, keep rethinking. This won't work.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
Are we positive he knows what a glitch is?Quote:
Originally Posted by DragoonXV
Sorry let me rephrase: loop hole.
this should be fun. Explain how requesting and leaving is a loop hole?Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
Loop hole!? This ain't even a loophole. Come on man, this isn't the solution to the problem. Rethink of a different way to fight hoppers. This one just won't work.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
Read original idea now.
So it is a loop hole to have a stratigy? This seems like the DE zapping threads. Plus, don't have Supercell fix this. There's a perfectly good solution that I gave you before. Set your clan to INVITE ONLY. Then hoppers won't go to your clan.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
I know people say "Set your clan to invite only." But then there are people who ask to invite, request then leave. So that's a pretty lame solution. I don't see why it isn't already a thing where when you join a clan you have a "Request timer." It's like the War Timer but only given when you just join the clan. What's more I think if this were implemented it'd have to be a 6 hour waiting period. Long enough so that people can't just wait for their armies to cook then join a clan then go but not long enough to be that big of a deal.
it may stop all hoppers but would certainly deter most Id imagine.
thats really all you can ask for.
The whole point is you shouldn't have CC troops when you aren't in a clan. If you leave, you are temporarily not in a clan.
No good. This ruins still, Req and Leave clans. This idea is really that good honestly, it just isn't.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
Don't invite players who ask, make them req to join. Or live with the fact that there will be hoppers and give those players who join then req weak troops, not ones that cost you.Quote:
Originally Posted by JibuRiRu
Don't wreck Req and Leave clans srsly.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
I completely understand your your frustrated with people coming in getting troops and leaving. If it's that big of a problem institute a policy where new members have to donate a certain number before requesting.
There is 100% no reason for supercell to do anything about this. You and your clan can easily handle it. If your clan won't agree with you, find another clan.
I am looking from a different perspective, and that's those who use Req and Go clans.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
A glitch is something not going his way.Quote:
Originally Posted by BlahBlah161616
They are taking an advantage of a loop hole in your methods, not one in the game. There are many situations where it is good that a person can get troops and leave. its up to you to allow it or not allow it how you see fit.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
Invite only.
Require all members to donate troops.
Don't donate to someone new until they start donating.
Problem solved.
Sounds like a clan problem to me.
Exactly what I said...but he's not listening.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pyroflame
I congratulate you for twisting my words. Try this perspective: A CC troop is donated (pretend they think). What would it think if the person they were donated to departed from its birth clan?Quote:
Originally Posted by BlahBlah161616
i would guess it's thinking let me outta here. Time to smash some buildings.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
I agree with Tex for the most part. Hoppers should have their cc cleared when they leave a clan. I have to things to add one though.
1) They should be able to keep their cc troops if their kicked.
2) It should be an option when your creating the clan if u want them to be able to leave with their cc troops or not.
I think you are not understanding what they say to you.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
- A request and leave clan is a clan that is there for the purpose of having guys come in, get troops, and leave.
- Sister clans are cases where members visit each other and work together to give eachother troops. Guys jump over get troops and jump back all the time.
Explain how each of those groups are to function if the change you request was made? If you can then we might agree with you so please...
Also explain why this is not the clans responsibility. The posters have been very kind to point out all of the existing ways of dealing with it.Quote:
Originally Posted by aaronjnc
The key thing to remember is if someone has only just joined you are not obligated to give him troops. If you do its at your own risk and your own fault if you get taken for it.
Here are solutions I have thought of:Quote:
Originally Posted by Tex6170
1. they don't care
2. honestly, they already left their village to go into battle and die, seriously?
3. They don't think
4. They left their home village, what do they care after that?
So that's what I came up with. BTW troops are made of elixir from the ground. So basically your using a liquid from the ground to mold troops in your barracks, so the chances they care are low.
Lol its become a hassle explaining this to you. Seriously, think of another way.