War donations not being accounted for?

Printable View

January 3rd, 2015
Jondon

War donations not being accounted for?

I know this issue may be small but i have always wondered why donations toward your clan mates warcastle are tallied up for total troops donated? To me these donations are the most crucial and some of the most need. So just wondering :)
January 3rd, 2015
Jondon

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jondon

I know this issue may be small but i have always wondered why donations toward your clan mates warcastle are tallied up for total troops donated? To me these donations are the most crucial and some of the most need. So just wondering :)

Sorry just able to find a similar link for this question and i understand how it can be taken advantage of by teammates dumping troops. But could supercell establish a set xp limit for each player based of the individuals clan castle level? or Maybe dish out small amount of xp for each donation?
January 4th, 2015
CPH3

This is why

They don't count because those troops are for war, not to gain xp or donations on. Also look at it this way, if you attack well enough and you donate good war cc troops your clan will be rewarded with war loot.
January 4th, 2015
JakeaLake

Heres why

It is because people could just dismiss their troops and to have a person donate again and have that process repeated for easy donations to level up or look good.
January 4th, 2015
Blahyakyak

The answers in the FAQ

War donations is for 1 thing; to win the war.
January 4th, 2015
Deadlyxda

Also this could easily lead to low players donating gob or barb to get XP. Only attracts trouble. It shows how good your clan is to be able to donate with loyalty rather than for personal gain.
January 4th, 2015
mmf01

I feel the same way.

I think there should be SOMETHING done to make sure that a donator gets credit, because you can donate 200+ troops to a base in the clan war map, and get no credit. The credit to me is important because that way your leader sees how much you donate, or lack thereof, and can make decisions accordingly... tell me if I'm wrong, but I think this should happen...
January 4th, 2015
Spurs978

Quote:

Originally Posted by mmf01

I feel the same way.

I think there should be SOMETHING done to make sure that a donator gets credit, because you can donate 200+ troops to a base in the clan war map, and get no credit. The credit to me is important because that way your leader sees how much you donate, or lack thereof, and can make decisions accordingly... tell me if I'm wrong, but I think this should happen...

Then tell them that u donated..
January 4th, 2015
AxionXD

Quote:

Originally Posted by mmf01

I feel the same way.

I think there should be SOMETHING done to make sure that a donator gets credit, because you can donate 200+ troops to a base in the clan war map, and get no credit. The credit to me is important because that way your leader sees how much you donate, or lack thereof, and can make decisions accordingly... tell me if I'm wrong, but I think this should happen...

You do get credit. The better the troops, the better chance of winning some good loot and bragging rights
January 5th, 2015
Jondon

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jondon

I know this issue may be small but i have always wondered why donations toward your clan mates warcastle are tallied up for total troops donated? To me these donations are the most crucial and some of the most need. So just wondering :)

well i appreciate the feed back but no real answers were given to me. I understand that it can be taken advantage of as i previously stated but there has to be a compensate for this. i cant take " you'll have bragging right and the wins should be a good enough reason" as a answer.
January 5th, 2015
DragoonXV

Well

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jondon

well i appreciate the feed back but no real answers were given to me. I understand that it can be taken advantage of as i previously stated but there has to be a compensate for this. i cant take " you'll have bragging right and the wins should be a good enough reason" as a answer.

Well if you wanted constructive criticism, this is the best you get. You can't expect everyone to agree with you.
January 6th, 2015
miamiheat

Quote:

Originally Posted by JakeaLake

It is because people could just dismiss their troops and to have a person donate again and have that process repeated for easy donations to level up or look good.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blahyakyak

War donations is for 1 thing; to win the war.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Deadlyxda

Also this could easily lead to low players donating gob or barb to get XP. Only attracts trouble. It shows how good your clan is to be able to donate with loyalty rather than for personal gain.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spurs978

Then tell them that u donated..

Quote:

Originally Posted by AxionXD

You do get credit. The better the troops, the better chance of winning some good loot and bragging rights

These guys have my thoughts put down already 👍
January 7th, 2015
Jondon

Quote:

Originally Posted by DragoonXV

Well if you wanted constructive criticism, this is the best you get. You can't expect everyone to agree with you.

I never said you have to agree with me I was just looking for a clearer answer to the question. I have and do respect everyone's opinion. I just felt like some people were repeating each other or didn't answer it at all :D.
January 7th, 2015
Beezermen

If you're not willing to part with your troops without receiving credit then refrain from donating. The point of a clan war is team effort; asking for individual acknowledgement/credit is selfish.....don't be "Willie Beamen"