Give me more time!

I just read the ruled out stickies for about 15 minutes combing them to find this idea but couldn't find it. Hopefully nobody else can find it because I really want this.

I feel that it is a bit strange that a town hall 2 has the same amount of time that a town hall 10 has to do an attack. 3 minutes is fine for raids through town hall 8 (I have no sympathy for those who miss the corner huts) but once you get to town hall 9 I feel that more time is needed for attacks. At town hall 9 and 10 you can start to get really creative with your attacks and sometimes 3 minutes is not enough to do it.

If town hall 9's got 4 minutes and town hall 10's got 5 minutes I would be happy. All this would do is help out when you take out all of the defenses leaving nothing left to defend a base. Defenses should be the real reason a 2 or 3 star is prevented, not time.

TH2 has fewer troops to work with as well and they do less damage. Thus it's not really reasonable to say, well TH2 has 3 minutes so why doesn't TH10 get more?

3 minutes is more than enough time for a well coordinated attack at TH10 to succeed. If you can't get it done in 3 minutes, you aren't bringing troops that do enough DPS with you or you're taking way too long to drop them.

As you get better at attacking, your decision making becomes better and you simply wont need as much time to plan. Also for the defender, a certain element of surprise has to be in order.

No thanks --- 3 mins is fine for a decnt attacker ----- I dont want noobs having any longer or more chance of getting my loot ........ if they cant do it in 3 mins -- tough!:cool:

I must be really bad at attacking :(

I can get 2 stars just fine but that elusive third star is really hard with only 3 minutes.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheMan131505

I must be really bad at attacking :(

I can get 2 stars just fine but that elusive third star is really hard with only 3 minutes.

---

what army are you using? Deploying faster or using higher DPS troops will get threes. If you're stuck behind walls, sub some troops for WBS obviously.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

TH2 has fewer troops to work with as well and they do less damage. Thus it's not really reasonable to say, well TH2 has 3 minutes so why doesn't TH10 get more?

3 minutes is more than enough time for a well coordinated attack at TH10 to succeed. If you can't get it done in 3 minutes, you aren't bringing troops that do enough DPS with you or you're taking way too long to drop them.

---

This isn't tru, sometime u need to be patient when dropping troops or u screw up the whole raid, timing is key. That being said, 4-5min is too long. Extending them an extra 30seconds would be fine. But a whole 1 or 3 min!! Wow!! So I think th 9 & 10 should have between 3:30-3:45ish to atk, just becouse it does take an extra 7-12 seconds b4 u can fully lay all ur troops with atk stratigy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ravenwood1

This isn't tru, sometime u need to be patient when dropping troops or u screw up the whole raid, timing is key. That being said, 4-5min is too long. Extending them an extra 30seconds would be fine. But a whole 1 or 3 min!! Wow!! So I think th 9 & 10 should have between 3:30-3:45ish to atk, just becouse it does take an extra 7-12 seconds b4 u can fully lay all ur troops with atk stratigy

---

Like judge Judy said, maybe bringing in higher DPS troops will work out better. Dropping troops right after a tank might be beneficial, but its definitely possible to get three stars with a rushed attack even at higher TH levels. Add in rages and you have the speed and DPS boost necessary to finish the job

As for th9, no. Theres absolutely no more time needed i promise ya. Th10 is on the verge of a needed extra 15 seconds already. However i dont forsee that happening.

Th11 should be out sometime this year. Personally i do believe there will be a need for more time since theyll be adding more building structures with overall damage total for entire base increasing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by newdles

As for th9, no. Theres absolutely no more time needed i promise ya. Th10 is on the verge of a needed extra 15 seconds already. However i dont forsee that happening.

Th11 should be out sometime this year. Personally i do believe there will be a need for more time since theyll be adding more building structures with overall damage total for entire base increasing.

---

All they have to do is make sure to add enough additional troop slots or levels to keep the necessary additional dps in check.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

All they have to do is make sure to add enough additional troop slots or levels to keep the necessary additional dps in check.

---

Any changes in time of battle will be to all TH levels. It doesn't make sense to give a new th level the advantage of 15 extra seconds when that doesn't always correlate with actually having the extra army camp space or any new troops. Rushers would be the ones benefitting from this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NeonFire15

Any changes in time of battle will be to all TH levels. It doesn't make sense to give a new th level the advantage of 15 extra seconds when that doesn't always correlate with actually having the extra army camp space or any new troops. Rushers would be the ones benefitting from this.

---

Did you mean to quote me in this reply?

My point is that if SC determines that there isn't enough time for offense to complete its job, they should fix that by upping offensive strength.

Think about it more. If you got more time at all in an update it would be for all town halls because if you were a town hall 9 and you were getting attacked by a town hall 10, then the revenge would not have the same amount of time. That's not fair at all. Also, the time limit is part of attack strategies. Giving everybody more time would take away an entire factor of attacking.

.. ..

For us really bad attackers a spell that ADDS time AND slows down the attack to 1/2 speed (or 1/4). No mental mistakes as you rush.

LOL.

I think that normal trophy raids should be timed. Though I believe the clan war attacks shouldn't be timed.

4 and 5 minutes is too much time. As many of us win defenses just because if time limits. Maybe 3:30 would suffice seeing as most people that I've seen that run out of time on an attack only had 1 or 2 buildings left. Plus it should be for all TH's, it wouldn't be fair if a TH10 did a 5 minute attack on a TH9 and 3-starred while only letting the TH9 have a 4 minute revenge. Just my thoughts though.:cool:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wryhorn

For us really bad attackers a spell that ADDS time AND slows down the attack to 1/2 speed (or 1/4). No mental mistakes as you rush.

LOL.

---

LOL indeed. Although that would be cool.

For me, its just not needed. Any well-planned attack strategy can 3 star a base in less than 3 mins...so yeah. But i see where you coming from.