Attacks decided by level, and not trophy count

So to me this is like a mediaeval game (lol). And each base represents a kingdom. Kingdoms have always been attacked by stronger kingdoms and the weaker one falls. But on clash this happens if you are lv 20 with TH3 being attacked by a TH6. Or me with maxed TH8 lv 89 being beat up by a TH9. That is what makes the game interesting. If the game wasn't like that I would have quit a long time ago. Because TH8 troops could not 100% my base (not counting De troops cause I haven't been attacked by much of those) fairly certain (haven't seen it in war or on raids). That is why kingdoms don't attack kingdoms with similar strength because you know it will be a waste of time and will not accomplish much if you win. Attacking kingdoms (bases) that are smaller allow them to concur and become stronger (getting loot for upgrades).

I know that I cannot hope to get more then 2 out 3 stars attacking another maxed TH8(I dont like the idea ;P)

If you just feel the need to test your skills war! And go to a league were your lv and base are fit and search for others that are your lv

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HiFliya

Same thing with Donation clans with ridiculously high XP levels for their TH. Xp has little to do with anything in the game, other than a title.

---

Lol, so true. I wonder how Alex(highest level player) will find ANYONE to attack if this is implemented...lol.

Based on Clan Wars, where you typically hit peoe of the same strength, it shows how much resources is needed to do that. If i had to attack only other level 105s, id have to use war armies to get any type of loot. I'm not a fan of this idea at all.

No sir, that wouldn't work with all the players who donate like crazy to level up ...then again, that would be funny for those who have donated like crazy and are "high level" now.:rolleyes:

Trophy count is a horrible way to do it and IMO is a huge part of the reason we have a loot problem.

However level is not much better to fix it.

Your Town hall +/- 1 level is what should determine who you get to see for attacks. Then limit how high in trophys lower townhalls can go.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by QueenBeeq

Trophy count is a horrible way to do it and IMO is a huge part of the reason we have a loot problem.

---

Uh no. The whole point of match making is to match opponents based on trophies. Trophies are the ranking system. The problem is trophies are not tied to the game's reward mechanism in any real meaningful way.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by QueenBeeq

Your Town hall +/- 1 level is what should determine who you get to see for attacks. Then limit how high in trophys lower townhalls can go.

---

Why should they impose an artificial limit on how high you can go? That's a terrible idea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by QueenBeeq

Trophy count is a horrible way to do it and IMO is a huge part of the reason we have a loot problem.

However level is not much better to fix it.

Your Town hall +/- 1 level is what should determine who you get to see for attacks. Then limit how high in trophys lower townhalls can go.

---

Nawwww, WE should determine what range works for us and the trophy system lets us do just that. In addition, trophy hunting for anyone including "lower townhalls" is a good thing ..it helps with raiding skills (assuming they aren't just th snipping).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NeonFire15

not a chance. im level 110 and have a base that looks like a level 80. donations would become a curse instead of an achievement.

---

This is the main problem. It highly discourages generosity and instead places emphasis on efficiency and ability to look out for yourself and only yourself. This is a cooperative tycoon-ish war game, not a first person shooter.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TEGU

Nawwww, WE should determine what range works for us and the trophy system lets us do just that. In addition, trophy hunting for anyone including "lower townhalls" is a good thing ..it helps with raiding skills (assuming they aren't just th snipping).

---

No way. Trophy system is like going fishing. You pick a spot and cast your line to see what you get. Other than the very top it is no measure of skill at all.

Its a totally broken system.

Most dead bases are th 6,7 and 8 me farming tons this would take away a lot of my prey- I mean fellow clashers