POLL: Please rate my TH 8 farm and War base thanks Happy new year! 🎉🎉

War base
http://i60.tinypic.com/169i9gl.jpg

Farm base
http://i62.tinypic.com/azcp6v.jpg

Your War Base is solid. Only problem is GoWiPe. As for your farming base, switch the right mortar and the adjacent WT, and you can compress the top and bottom areas of the outer areas; hogging a farming base is a waste of time and you don't need to protect those collectors. Make more funnels out of it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

Your War Base is solid. Only problem is GoWiPe. As for your farming base, switch the right mortar and the adjacent WT, and you can compress the top and bottom areas of the outer areas; hogging a farming base is a waste of time and you don't need to protect those collectors. Make more funnels out of it.

---

Yeah i know! But what th 8 can defend against a well executed gowipe :/
as for the wt and mortar on the ryt side i purposely placed my WT closer to the D.E storage for more protection.
as for the upper collector and giant bomb i surrounded that collector with walls for my clan castle to be unlureable :)
and nope actually people do hog bases for farming (Th 9/10 ppl)or some for trophy pushers if they see it fit that my storages are full they will surely attack me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KazieL

Yeah i know! But what th 8 can defend against a well executed gowipe :/
You're missing my point. My point is that GoWiPe from the top will decimate it, since the attack does not have to deal with walls connecting the second and first layer.
as for the wt and mortar on the ryt side i purposely placed my WT closer to the D.E storage for more protection True. It's probably better that you do it with the left side then.
as for the upper collector and giant bomb i surrounded that collector with walls for my clan castle to be unlureable :)
I'll take a second look at it.
and nope actually people do hog bases for farming (Th 9/10 ppl)or some for trophy pushers if they see it fit that my storages are full they will surely attack me This reasoning is nonsense. I don't have time to explain since I have to leave for something important soon but just be aware that that is not correct at all. Edit: Alright, I have some time now. The reasoning why people use anti-hog is for transformers. Transformers are bases that easily switch between farming and pushing bases. At TH8 you have no reason to be pushing unless you're in Forum Elite, which I doubt. Further, your range: nobody uses hogs. You'd have to be pretty unlucky to hit one. Pushers also don't care about loot. A-a-and you don't have a hog ring either.

---

Responses in bold. I really hate to say this, but it seems you are attempting to deflect or defend what improvements I'm saying about your base. Don't do that, you're asking for advice, so embrace it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

Responses in bold. I really hate to say this, but it seems you are attempting to deflect or defend what improvements I'm saying about your base. Don't do that, you're asking for advice, so embrace it.

---

Dont be so grandiose dude im not deflecting or defending or trying to be a smartass when i designed it that's what i had on my mind, that's why i posted it here.. I told you that coz thats what i designed it for and i told you that becoz thats what it is suppose to do on my mind! You have another suggestion i truly appreciate that, but in my experience and in my current league as a farming base thats what this base is meant for.. For ex. If someone gowipe me here 1300-1500 i would welcome him more lol. I said my point and you completely overreacted lol chill.

edit: i am fully aware that hogs/gowipe are the weakness of my farm base lol. Its a farm base for godsakes!. But i dont really care about a full hog attack in my league and a gowipe lol.. And actually people who do hog attacks while pushing do care about the loot.. Especially in my league maybe when they hit the 2400 cups mark they dont but surely and logically in the earlier marks 1300-1600 they would surely hit ppl's with good loot for prep. But that is truly very unlikely to be hit by hogs at gold 3 except for revenge. I made that bombs thing for the sole purpose of "I dont care about heavy hog attacks but i would at least put some defense against it" thats why i didnt do any full anti hog build lol. Dont be a smartass u dont know everything or better yet i hate to say this but maybe before setting up a conclusion in your mind by trying to correct anyone be sure to know whats their side of the story first then try to correct him after lol.

War = Mediocre, Farm = Good. The clan castle's extremely easy to lure, and the mortars' wide ranges are not fully utilized.
The storage placement, other than the dark elixir, is very bad.

Looking at the poll, it seems that I am with the majority in my evaluation.