Defensive Win League Bonus

Again, not a new idea..but we need to get this bumped. This is NOT ruled out...I have searched.


When you get attacked and the attacker DOES NOT get 1 star.... YOU GET THE LEAGUE BONUS AS THE DEFENDER!!!


it is that simple....someone gets the bonus...why not you for the awesome defense you just provided. It costs to reload traps/bomb/xbows/infernos......why not get the league bonus for defensive wins? A win is a win isn't it? SO, explain why this is not implemented? Why are we getting punished for having great defense? We keep a defensive win stat after all....why not get the bonus loot.


THIS IS ACTUALLY ON THE IDEAS PAGE OF THE "IDEAS, RULED OUT" sticky......


POLL ADDED....LETS GET SOME STEAM ON THIS ONE!!!

In my opinion I don't think it should be implemented. Sometimes I'll sign on and three people have dropped one barb and quit to drop levels and I'm up 40 trophies, that had nothing to do with my awesome defence just got lucky. I think the incentive for winning is for being active,encouraging you to play more. Sitting idle doesn't warrant a bonus I don't think. I mean don't get me wrong I'd love extra loot, I just don't think it would be completely fair.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BurnsTheBallbag

In my opinion I don't think it should be implemented. Sometimes I'll sign on and three people have dropped one barb and quit to drop levels and I'm up 40 trophies, that had nothing to do with my awesome defence just got lucky. I think the incentive for winning is for being active,encouraging you to play more. Sitting idle doesn't warrant a bonus I don't think. I mean don't get me wrong I'd love extra loot, I just don't think it would be completely fair.

---

Same can be said about TH sniping though, with the win bonus.

Not really, you actively snipped it and they decided to leave it out there. You still paid for troops to hit it and paid to search for the base. If there's an easy TH people will take it. But they are paying to find them and paying to attack them with troops.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by xmaxer

Same can be said about TH sniping though, with the win bonus.

---

BINGO!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BurnsTheBallbag

In my opinion I don't think it should be implemented. Sometimes I'll sign on and three people have dropped one barb and quit to drop levels and I'm up 40 trophies, that had nothing to do with my awesome defence just got lucky. I think the incentive for winning is for being active,encouraging you to play more. Sitting idle doesn't warrant a bonus I don't think. I mean don't get me wrong I'd love extra loot, I just don't think it would be completely fair.

---

xmaxer is correct... they got lucky they found a TH outside...they get the bonus. Are you actually idle? Did you not work hard to set your base up to defend? Load your traps/bombs/xbow/inferno/CC? How is that sitting idle? All in all....it is perfectly fair. If there is a "win bonus" as it is stated....should it matter if the WIN is defense or offense? It shouldn't matter...to quote The Rock "IT DOESN"T MATTER" just give the bonus either way.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BurnsTheBallbag

Not really, you actively snipped it and they decided to leave it out there. You still paid for troops to hit it and paid to search for the base. If there's an easy TH people will take it. But they are paying to find them and paying to attack them with troops.

---

so i drop my BK or AQ, spend no loot except the search loot and snipe a TH and get the win bonus.....what effort did I really exert? How was that truly "active"?

Flip side: I drop my BK/AQ then end raid to trophy drop...how was that active...same loot spent to search..

GIVE THE DEFENSIVE WIN BONUS ALREADY!!!

Meh, ok I'll take a defencive win bonus then ;) Just think the people on the end of a barb drop are getting something they don't deserve, but we all get them so it would even out I guess. But I'm in Crystal 2, do I deserve a 50,000 bonus for someone dropping levels, I don't think so, but I'd take it ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BurnsTheBallbag

Meh, ok I'll take a defencive win bonus then ;) Just think the people on the end of a barb drop are getting something they don't deserve, but we all get them so it would even out I guess. But I'm in Crystal 2, do I deserve a 50,000 bonus for someone dropping levels, I don't think so, but I'd take it ;)

---

The defensive win bonus =/= the offensive win bonus.
realistically it would have to be lower.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BurnsTheBallbag

Meh, ok I'll take a defencive win bonus then ;) Just think the people on the end of a barb drop are getting something they don't deserve, but we all get them so it would even out I guess. But I'm in Crystal 2, do I deserve a 50,000 bonus for someone dropping levels, I don't think so, but I'd take it ;)

---

Do you deserve the trophy's for the same thing?....but you will still take them :p

Make sure you vote on this!!!!!