A partial fix for players leaving clan during war

Open clans have a problem with players who leave during wars without attacking. A proposed suggestion was to not let players leave during wars. This was shot down because it would be difficult to leave a clan that wars constantly.

A better idea is to only allow leaving on battle day, and only after the player has used both of their attacks.

If SC did this, some players would try for stars since they have to attack anyway. Other players would just drop one troop and leave. Still, since some players would attack who otherwise wouldn't, it would be an improvement over the current situation.

If they didn't want to war with your clan before being held hostage, why would they want to fight in a war with a clan thats holding them hostage?

Whats stopping me from turning on Troll Base mode on my war base and either not attacking, or wasting my attacks on purpose? Oh i can leave after i use two attacks? Drop one archer, end battle, drop one archer, end battle. Leave clan.

War abandoners are going to happen. It happens to us too. Key is managing the loss. If you have more than 2 abandon in a war, id take a closer look at the clan. If you are losing wars because of two people, id also be looking closer at the clan.

In a 20 v 20, a max score can be accomplished with only 10 people.

What if they where jerks and spawned one barb each...then left? What then...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BlahBlah161616

What if they where jerks and spawned one barb each...then left? What then...

---

Of course SOME players would do that, but others wouldn't. As it is now, you get 0 stars from every player who leaves. If they could only leave after attacking, then you would still get 0 stars from players who dropped 1 barb, but you would get a few stars from players who made legit attacks.

Since this wouldn't result in fewer stars, and it might result in more, it would benefit clans to have this policy. Of course the benefit comes at the expense of the hoppers who like to join a clan for a few hours and leave, but SC should be discouraging that anyway. So, it has a double benefit of deterring hopping in general.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by paddyflynn

Open clans have a problem with players who leave during wars without attacking. A proposed suggestion was to not let players leave during wars. This was shot down because it would be difficult to leave a clan that wars constantly.

A better idea is to only allow leaving on battle day, and only after the player has used both of their attacks.

If SC did this, some players would try for stars since they have to attack anyway. Other players would just drop one troop and leave. Still, since some players would attack who otherwise wouldn't, it would be an improvement over the current situation.

---

"Open clans have a problem with players who leave during wars without attacking" Of course they do. Its one of the pitfalls of being an open clan. But disallowing leaving or putting any restrictions on movements you would be penalizing all of the other types of clans. I am not going to suggest you not be an open clan, that is your free choice, but all choices do have downsides so be prepared to take the bad with the good.