Printable View
I see your point here but I just am not feeling it. I don't think it would aid either side in the battles. I think if you don't get the th then you deserve to feel like you lost. Now on the star-loot thing. No. I've gotten 99% 2 stars and that does not mean grounds for punishment, I shouldn't loose loot cause I didn't have time.Quote:
Originally Posted by choczombie
75% is too easy for 3rd star. At least it should be 85/90% for 3rd if its going to be added. But 3 stars is fine as is.Quote:
Originally Posted by choczombie
You get half damage 1*
Full damage 1*
Th 1*
If you get only 1* on 99% that means the defense was so good. I know it hurts and frustrating. But that's what it is all about th defending in this game. The main concept is to defend your th. 3* system is fun. Also I don't think loot should be divided per star. Its hard already that you won't get back how much elixir you spend on an attack. If its divided per attack, there will be too much loss to those who try hard and using de troops will feel insanely costly.
The 3 star format is perfect for this game.
However, I think there should be some way to reward players for going the extra mile and getting 90%+.
How about this?
1 star if you destroy 50% base OR Town Hall.
"2 stars if you destroy 90% base"
OR 2 stars if you destroy Town Hall AND 50% base.
3 stars if you destroy 100% base.
So the only thing that changes is what I wrote in quotes.
2 stars if you destroy 90% base irrespective of whether you get the Town Hall or not.
Why don't you tweak your attack strategy to get that remaining 10% rather than asking everyone else to tweak it to cater to you?Quote:
Originally Posted by KREYZEE7
Why you get 90% 1 star, is because you spam troops, they run around the base destroying everything else except the TH. It takes skills to 100% so please learn those skills.
This makes great sense. And just to clear things up a bit, it still rewards the people getting 100%. It still requires skill to get all four stars and will help the war total more than coming up short. Pretty much any decent TH 9 or 10 player can get two stars in war. But there are many times when they do not get to the 75% threshold. There should be a difference between getting the TH and 52% of the base and getting the TH and 87% of he base.Quote:
Originally Posted by choczombie
And it's also already been added multiple times.
This would be the only way it would ever workQuote:
Originally Posted by choczombie
That's your problem who can't funnel your troops to get that TH :PQuote:
Originally Posted by KREYZEE7
Plan a Better Raid , Go Ahead ! No Need Of 4 Stars
I never once complained of my lack of 100%.. I do fairly well with my attacks and don't "spam" troops either. Read a little better before joining a conversation. I just think that the way stars are earned are just unbalanced. Also how can anyone post in the suggestion forum with out it catering to something they want?!?!? You make no sense😑Quote:
Originally Posted by necro17000