4 stars per base

I am sure it's been discussed but I didn't see it. Would it be possible in the base was divided into 1/4's instead of 1/3's? Have the base count for 75% of the stars and the TH for the other 25%.. It seems that the way that a victory is decided isn't right. In raids and wars I have seen it all to much. In my attacks and defense. Me or some other poor guy will get a 96% 1 star. If you get 90% or higher that is way more than 1 stars worth. Just seems like the victory deciding factor isn't balanced enough. Opinions?

So would 25% give one star? That's can be done with 5 archers getting junk buildings.

Well I am sure that it wouldn't be a simple fix.. Whether it's 1/4 or 1/3 I just think that the deciding factor in a star isn't balanced enough. Seems broken... Am I wrong?

No just no. I like everything how it is.

Have you ever had a 90% 1 star? I like the game as well but what's wrong with a tweak here and there :-)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KREYZEE7

Have you ever had a 90% 1 star? I like the game as well but what's wrong with a tweak here and there :-)

---

It would be too easy to get one star.No one would win on defense

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KREYZEE7

Well I am sure that it wouldn't be a simple fix.. Whether it's 1/4 or 1/3 I just think that the deciding factor in a star isn't balanced enough. Seems broken... Am I wrong?

---

It sucks getting 99% one star, but you have to get the town hall for a star. I like the idea that the "most important" building can make a difference between 1 star (next to failure) and perfection. At least war has brought that concept back that I think SC meant for it to be.

My opinion is that the current system differentiates between okay attacks (50% one star), good attacks (two stars), and perfect attacks. Adding more stars or adusting the percentages would make bad attackers seem better than they are. I don't think they deserve that. Wanna get better? Keep practicing.

hmmm.. i dunno, i like the sound of three stars better than four stars.

nope. i like 3 stars better.
beside, almost every game i have played use 3 stars thing. so does clash of clans. lol

25% for a win is poor. However, I do think that 75% damage is significant particularly in clan wars. There is such a huge margin between a two star win and a three star win that a 75% win as a marker gives a good incentive. I'd suggest:

50% = one star
75% = one more star
Town hall = one star
100% = one star.


I also want to see loot bonuses applied for each star. That is, a three star win should get at least double the loot bonus that you currently get awarded, and a town hall snipe should get about half.