Printable View
OMG Dude, I am talking about the dreamed up donation leaderboard.Quote:
Originally Posted by abstrusecon
Would the donation stats reset every time you left a clan in the dreamed up leaderboard system. Duh!
I JUST TOLD YOU WHY PEOPLE CLAN HOP TO DONATE TROOPS, WHY WOULD U ASK THE SAME QUESTION AGAIN.
read my previous post. :rolleyes:
lol, this guy just doesnt get it.Quote:
Originally Posted by TJwTC
He was speaking in the hypothetical; he said, "if," and the hypothetical is correct, for if things changed such that hoppers donation stats weren't reset, then (and only then) clan hopping, not only could be, but would be, encouraged. Of course, there is no indication of such a change being a natural consequence of your suggestion, yet be it a misplaced hypothical or not, the truth or falsity of the proposition as expressed by his sentence is not altered by it, so if nothing else, I do take issue with your saying he is wrong.Quote:
Originally Posted by abstrusecon
What this guy is saying, is that if there is a global leader board on donations, it is not a given that the stats would reset when leaving a clan.Quote:
Originally Posted by abstrusecon
oh, and people clan hop to donate all the time. I'm doing it right now on my second account to finish up friend in need for those 250 gems, and get the fourth builder as an early TH7, no money spent.
If they clan hop to donate troops, more power to them. At least they're doing something positive, even though i see no point of doing so. You all act like clan hopping is defeating the purpose of this idea. I'm seeing giants a lot in this thread, is that what your afraid of, people hopping clan to clan, just to donate giants? Its simply ludicrous.
We don't describe something as positive when the negatives strongly outweigh the positives, but there is a point, be it visible to you or not: donations do not happen in the absence of requests. If one's aim is to climb a "who donated the most troops" leaderboard, and if (if, I say) donations are computated by the number of actual troops donated (and is thus not necessarily a product of one's troop donation count in any particular clan), then after all open requests have been filled, it would behoove a champ-wannabe to move on to another clan and fill whatever open requests that may be open there.Quote:
Originally Posted by abstrusecon
Personally, I have no qualms with your proposal, so long as it's executed in such a way as to not provide an incentive for the very disruptive behavior of repeated clan hopping.
'behoove' won u that argument. nice work.Quote:
Originally Posted by fast1
1. This post should be in the Suggestions folder, no? (beat Dahimi to it, muhahahah!)
2. I'm not sure if there are other clan "systems" out there... but in our Farming4 family, we rotate members from Gold to Elixir and from Elixir to Gold to clear out bars if they hang for more than 30 seconds... So, our stats are always getting wiped out, anyways...
If the stats would not get so erased, from our intra-clan family rotations, or from clan hopping... the number would make more sense, but then you have all kinds of weird incentives of people hopping around, stuffing giants, etc...
Illustris the Ever Blind to Donation Stats
A leader board for Top lv players would be better , I also wanna see their bases set up , they got higher exp than gemmers ( top players leader board )
One of the reasons I slipped in, "repeated" when I said, "repeated clan hopping" was to provide exception to hoppers that are not disruptive, but now I fear I didn't articulate with sufficient justice to include all non-disruptive behavior. Just as I've pondered the need to limit elder powers to kicking limited members a day, so too I have given thought to the number of permissible clan jumps. Sometimes our ideas are doable if not for the limitations of other processes already in place.Quote:
Originally Posted by Illustris