Please Please Please Add a Booking/Reservation System for Clan Wars

It is too difficult to coordinate who will be attacked by whom over the clan wars. This leads to frustration, yelling, arguments, and other during the clan wars. Please add some type of booking/reservation system to eliminate this unnecessary problem.

Example problem: A person builds a custom army for a target. They come back later to find the target has been attacked by someone else. They now have wasted troop, time, and elixir... In addition to being frustrated and aggravated.

Example problem: People are unable to coordinate attacks in clan chat, because the clan chat scrolls off screen. So if someone is not online to see it, they won't even know someone was trying to reserve a target.

Example SOLUTION: Add a, "book" button right next to the, "scout" button (to give a visual the target is claimed). Everyone can have only one active, "book" at a time.

Please add some type of booking system for clan wars.

Thank you.

What will happen when Someone is trying to book someone and another guy booked it first and the guy who tried to booked it Cant Attack anyone else as he/she is weakest

I assume guys are telling each other their desires but someone else doesn't care. Having a different way to tell them is not going to change that much.

Have a set strategy for first wave so people always know where they are supposed to go. Sometimes a guy won't like his target that leads to but if your guys are serious then they should be willing to suck it up and go for it rather than switching to someone else's. I won't say its a requirement you have to do the same, but in my own clan we have weeded out (we don't always kick but somehow they wind up gone sometimes even mutual agreement) the guys that start complaining about their assigned target instead of getting the job done.

Or, have that set strategy where everyone has an assigned target but they are then allowed to barter. If a guy can get another guy to switch that's fine but the rule is both guys have to agree. (we don't do this but I have seen clans that did and have it working out)

or teach guys not to get too married to a strategy ahead of time and be better at adjusting. If they have a general strategy they always use have them make the key part of that army they always have and hold until they are ready to attack. Then they make the final troops and adjust the choices to fine tune. And also be a good enough attacker that they can be flexible in a pinch where they have to be.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AriyanTheGreat

What will happen when Someone is trying to book someone and another guy booked it first and the guy who tried to booked it Cant Attack anyone else as he/she is weakest

---

Why not make it so it can be "booked" but not preclude someone else from attacking. That way you know it's been called, and it can still be attacked. I would think this would help cut down on some of the negative clan chatter.

I'm for something like this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AA88x

Why not make it so it can be "booked" but not preclude someone else from attacking. That way you know it's been called, and it can still be attacked. I would think this would help cut down on some of the negative clan chatter.

I'm for something like this.

---

I like this Idea ,some times too is too much to go back and see who clamed what

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AA88x

Why not make it so it can be "booked" but not preclude someone else from attacking. That way you know it's been called, and it can still be attacked. I would think this would help cut down on some of the negative clan chatter.

I'm for something like this.

---

Like it :D.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AA88x

Why not make it so it can be "booked" but not preclude someone else from attacking. That way you know it's been called, and it can still be attacked. I would think this would help cut down on some of the negative clan chatter.

I'm for something like this.

---

Yes, exactly the sentiment.

We are at the stage where we have wide range of Town Hall levels. Some have GoWi, some have only dragons, some are not even there yet. It's becoming increasing difficult to plan, and a simple little visual of some sort would be tremendously helpful and reduce negative experiences.

It is unrealistic to expect folks to parse clan chat all the time... It scrolls out anyways, making it virtually impossible, especially since it spans 24 hour period.


Supercell, please add a lite visual/booking/reservation/whatever-you-call-it to reduce conflict in the clan wars.

I see where you're coming from. I don't agree...but I kinda don't disagree either. Flagging would be fine, but it should still be open to anyone. Perhaps the leader or co leader should have the power to flag something? If players can flag their own targets....that doesn't really solve anything. Attacking too high and flagging too high would be pretty much the same thing. I run a really organized clan and don't have this problem. When someone is ready to attack they jump in chat and say so. I then look at their army, scout bases, and assign a target, maybe talk some strat if we need to. Get everyone onboard with this and it works just fine.

I don't need another reason for drama on the topic of clan wars. It would be just an annoyance because these flags wouldn't guarantee they actually use that attack or attack the target they flagged.

I have a very similar request.

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-for-clan-wars

I agree with this. But the booking shouldn't account to anything more than coordination, people should still be able to attack whoever they want, it would just help plan a war.

The question is whether or not people should have 1 or 2 bookings and whether or not more than one person can book a base. Different clans work differently and that needs to be addressed before putting this idea forward, to make sure it doesn't hinder that in any shape or form.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gama321

I agree with this. But the booking shouldn't account to anything more than coordination, people should still be able to attack whoever they want, it would just help plan a war.

The question is whether or not people should have 1 or 2 bookings and whether or not more than one person can book a base. Different clans work differently and that needs to be addressed before putting this idea forward, to make sure it doesn't hinder that in any shape or form.

---

Yes, exactly! Perhaps that's how I meant to frame the suggestion. So, instead of, "Clan_Member_01" asking in clan chat,"Has anyone booked so and so?", we're just making it easier for coordination.

+1 for indicative flagging. Clanchat scrolls too much (maybe we are too chatty :p)